MPRE Practice Test

Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination

MPRE overview

  • 200 practice questions
  • 32 flashcards
  • 10 study guide topics
  • 38 key terms

What you'll study

  • Regulation of the Legal Profession10%
  • The Client-Lawyer Relationship12%
  • Client Confidentiality10%
  • Conflicts of Interest15%
  • Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties10%
  • Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy12%
  • Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients10%
  • The Profession and the Public8%
  • Judicial Conduct8%
  • Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession5%

The Multistate Professional Responsibility Examination (MPRE) is a standardized ethics examination used by most U.S. jurisdictions as one of the requirements for admission to the bar. It is also required in some jurisdictions for admission as a limited-scope legal practitioner or for reinstatement after discipline. The exam is administered by the National Conference of Bar Examiners, but each jurisdiction sets its own minimum score, its own rules about when the score must be earned relative to the bar exam, and its own rules about how long a score remains usable - so candidates should always confirm the current requirements on their jurisdiction's bar admissions website rather than relying on secondhand summaries. The test is entirely multiple choice and tests the law governing lawyers: the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct and accompanying commentary, the ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct, and the constitutional and procedural doctrines that accompany them, including agency principles, disqualification, and the reporting of misconduct. Preparation works best as staged review: read the rules in small blocks by topic, then work practice questions and read the explanations closely, because the exam rewards issue-spotting and the ability to pick the best answer among plausible ones rather than rote recall. Most candidates benefit from a dedicated commercial course or a bar-prep ethics module plus several weeks of consistent practice.

Common mistakes

When a question signals a 'hard' scenario (client threatens violence, client is committing a fraud, client lied on the stand), the candidate reflexively picks the answer where the lawyer discloses confidential information without first checking whether disclosure is permitted at all, and often without checking whether informed consent is a prerequisite.

Candidates learn the Rule 1.6 exceptions as a list of triggers and treat each trigger as a duty to speak, rather than as a narrow permission that must be tied to the exact elements of the exception; the emotional framing of the fact pattern pushes toward 'warn the victim.'

What to do instead

Apply the default first: no disclosure unless it fits a specific exception. Rule 1.6(b)(1) permits disclosure to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm. Rule 1.6(b)(2) permits disclosure of the client's crime or fraud, including financial loss, only if the client used the lawyer's services to commit it and only to the extent necessary to prevent, mitigate, or rectify it. Where none of the exceptions fit, the only route is informed consent under 1.6(a) (or a Rule 3.3/1.13/2.3 override).

Picking the 'consent cures conflicts' answer without first asking whether the conflict is consentable, and using the concurrent-conflict test (Rule 1.7: materially limited) for a former client, or the former-client test (Rule 1.9: substantially related and materially adverse) for a current one.

The two tests look similar in the options, and the Model Rules let many concurrent conflicts be cured by informed written consent, so consent feels like a universal solvent; candidates skip the threshold question of which rule governs.

What to do instead

Label the relationship first: current client = 1.7; former client = 1.9; prospective client = 1.18. Then ask whether the representation is prohibited outright even with consent (e.g., asserting a claim against a current client in the same matter, or representing both sides of the same litigation) versus merely consentable with informed written consent. Former-client conflicts usually require no consent if the matters are not substantially related, but the firm-wide imputation under 1.10 still has to be addressed.

Treating an initial consultation as free of consequences, so that the second lawyer in a fact pattern takes the matter even though the first consultation gave the lawyer information that could be significantly harmful to the prospective client.

Candidates equate the existence of duties with the existence of a signed engagement letter or a filed appearance, and assume no fee paid means no client.

What to do instead

Under Rule 1.18, the duty of confidentiality arises from the consultation itself, and a lawyer who received disqualifying information may not represent a client with materially adverse interests in the same or a substantially related matter. Consent from both parties can cure it, and a firm may avoid imputation under Rule 1.18(d) only if the lawyer who received the information is screened and the consulting person received written notice; if the lawyer received no more information than reasonably necessary to decide whether to take the case, no conflict attaches.

Concluding that withdrawal or a quiet 'no questions asked' approach satisfies the duty of candor when the lawyer knows the client or a witness has offered false testimony or false evidence, and choosing the option that keeps the client's secret intact.

Candidates over-weight Rule 1.6 confidentiality and do not recognize that Rule 3.3 overrides it; withdrawal alone also feels like an acceptable remedy because it terminates the lawyer's involvement.

What to do instead

Rule 3.3(a)(3) and (b) require the lawyer to take reasonable remedial measures, including, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal to the extent reasonably necessary, and this duty continues through the end of the proceeding. Withdrawal alone is never sufficient. The preferred sequence is to remonstrate with the client confidentially, seek to withdraw if the client insists, and disclose only if remonstration and withdrawal fail to correct the falsehood.

Sending a friendly email or placing a call directly to a mid-level manager of an adverse corporate party, or to an employee whose statements might bind the company, after the company has retained counsel, on the theory that only senior officers or the company's registered agent count as 'the party.'

Candidates reduce Rule 4.2 to 'don't call the other side's lawyer's client,' and treat a corporation as a single person rather than a set of employees, so they assume only the CEO or in-house counsel are off-limits.

What to do instead

Rule 4.2 bars communication about the subject of the representation with any person the lawyer knows to be represented, and for an organization that includes employees with managerial responsibility, employees whose acts could be imputed to the organization, and employees whose statements could constitute admissions. Consent must come from the organization's counsel. Rank-and-file employees outside those categories may generally be contacted.

Answering questions about legal malpractice by asking whether the lawyer violated a Model Rule, and concluding that because no ethics rule was broken there is no civil liability, or conversely that a rule violation automatically establishes liability.

The exam is about the Rules, so candidates collapse the ethical standard of care into the tort standard; the two are related but not identical, and expert testimony is the usual proof in malpractice cases.

What to do instead

Keep the two tracks separate. Malpractice is ordinary negligence: the lawyer owes a duty to the client (and to intended beneficiaries in some settings), breaches the standard of care of a reasonably competent lawyer, and that breach actually and proximately causes damages. A rule violation may be evidence of breach but is not dispositive, and there is no malpractice without proven damages. Ethical discipline requires no injury; malpractice requires it.

Depositing a client's advance fee payment directly into the firm's operating account, or depositing firm funds into the client trust account 'to cover bank fees,' and treating a settlement advance for costs as the lawyer's own money on receipt.

Candidates treat all money the lawyer receives as earned revenue, and treat trust account rules as bookkeeping trivia rather than as rules about property ownership; the 'flat fee' label makes the payment feel earned at signing.

What to do instead

Under Rule 1.15, client and third-party funds must be held in a separate trust account, and only funds the lawyer has actually earned may be moved to the operating account. Advance fees and cost advances belong in trust until earned or incurred; a lawyer who wants to treat a flat fee as earned on receipt needs a written agreement and must refund any unearned portion on early termination. No commingling, with the narrow exceptions the rule allows.

Selecting the answer where the lawyer mails a targeted letter to a specific accident victim within 30 days of the injury, or has a paralegal make a live telephone call to a stranger to drum up a personal injury case.

Candidates collapse all advertising into one category and forget that Rule 7.3 turns on whether the lawyer knows the recipient needs legal services in a particular matter arising out of a specific event, and forget that 'live telephone' counts as prohibited personal contact.

What to do instead

In-person, live telephone, and real-time electronic solicitation for pecuniary gain are prohibited unless the person solicited is a lawyer, a close friend or relative, or a former client. Written solicitation is allowed but must be labeled 'Advertising Material' and, for wrongful death or personal injury/accident claims, may not be sent to a person known to need legal services in that matter within 30 days of the event. Pre-recorded calls and general advertising remain permissible with the usual content rules.

Deciding a judge need not step aside because the judge personally believes he or she can be fair, even where the judge's former law partner is appearing, a relative is a party, or the judge has a small financial interest in a party.

Candidates import the subjective standard from the lawyer-conflict rules and forget that judicial disqualification under Rule 2.11 uses an objective appearance test and has bright-line per se rules.

What to do instead

Use the 'reasonable person with knowledge of all the facts would question the judge's impartiality' standard, and apply the bright lines: personal bias concerning a party or knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts, prior involvement as a lawyer in the matter, a spouse or close relative who is a party, lawyer, or material witness, and any financial interest in the subject matter or a party. A judge may continue only after disclosing the ground and obtaining the parties' written consent without the judge's participation, and disqualification may be raised sua sponte.

Reporting every rule violation a lawyer hears about, or conversely concluding that a lawyer may never report because 'confidentiality always wins,' and ignoring who is responsible when a subordinate lawyer or a nonlawyer assistant commits an error.

Candidates miss the narrowness of Rule 8.3 (only violations raising a substantial question as to honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness) and the fact that a supervising lawyer's duty under Rules 5.1 and 5.3 runs independently of any reporting duty.

What to do instead

Report only when the lawyer knows of a violation that raises a substantial question as to the offending lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness; a report is discretionary ('may') in most jurisdictions but the information learned in a lawyer's own representation is protected by Rule 1.6, so a report usually requires client consent. Separately, a supervisory lawyer must make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures in place giving reasonable assurance of compliance, and is responsible for a subordinate's violation if the supervisor ordered or knowingly ratified it.

Exam requirements can change. Confirm current details with the exam provider.

MPRE practice

200 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. With JavaScript, this list opens one question at a time. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

  1. Question 1Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer in private practice wants to advertise her services. Which statement about permissible advertising content is correct?

    1. She may pay a nonlawyer a percentage of each fee for clients the nonlawyer recommends.
    2. She may state that she limits her practice to immigration matters. Correct answer.
    3. She may call herself a certified specialist in trial practice without any certification.
    4. She may promise that she will obtain the best possible outcome in every case she handles.

    Explanation

    Rule 7.1 prohibits communications that are false or misleading, but a truthful statement that a lawyer limits her practice is permissible. Paying for recommendations is barred by Rule 7.2(b), and specialist claims are limited by Rule 7.4 to lawyers certified by an approved organization.

  2. Question 2Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer represents a manufacturing company in a contract dispute. In which of the following circumstances may the lawyer disclose information relating to the representation?

    1. To prevent a client from inflicting serious bodily harm on a coworker. Correct answer.
    2. To the lawyer's spouse while discussing a stressful day at work.
    3. To the lawyer's accountant so the accountant can prepare the lawyer's personal tax return.
    4. To a reporter, to explain why the client's position in the lawsuit is weak.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(1) permits disclosure to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm. Other disclosures require the client's informed consent, implied authorization, or another listed exception.

  3. Question 3Regulation of the Legal Profession

    Which of the following fee arrangements complies with the Model Rules?

    1. A lawyer agrees to defend a client in a criminal case for a fee equal to 20 percent of any assets the client retains.
    2. A lawyer handling an uncontested divorce charges a fee that is contingent on the court granting the divorce decree.
    3. The lawyer signs a written contingent-fee agreement stating the percentage and how it is calculated. Correct answer.
    4. A lawyer charges a flat fee of $5,000 and refuses to refund any portion even if the lawyer withdraws immediately after being retained.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.5(c) requires a contingent-fee agreement to be in writing, signed by the client, and to state the method by which the fee is determined, including the percentage and the expenses to be deducted. Contingent fees are barred in criminal cases and in domestic-relations matters where the fee depends on securing a divorce or a settlement amount.

  4. Question 4Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer in general practice is asked to handle a complex patent matter, a field she has never handled. Under the Model Rules, what may she do?

    1. She may accept if she can become competent through reasonable preparation. Correct answer.
    2. She must decline the matter because she does not currently possess the knowledge and skill the matter requires.
    3. She may accept the matter only if the client signs a written waiver of the competence requirement.
    4. She may accept the matter and learn the necessary law as the representation proceeds.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.1 requires competence but allows a lawyer to take on a matter in an unfamiliar field if she can acquire the necessary knowledge and skill through reasonable study or by associating with a lawyer of established competence. The client's consent is not the measure of competence.

  5. Question 5Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer receives a $10,000 advance from a client for future litigation expenses. How must the lawyer handle these funds?

    1. Spend them immediately on firm overhead, provided the lawyer repays the client before the case ends.
    2. Deposit them in a trust account and withdraw funds as expenses are incurred. Correct answer.
    3. Deposit them in the firm's general operating account, because they are advance payments.
    4. Place them in the lawyer's personal savings account with a written record of the deposit.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.15 requires funds belonging in whole or in part to a client to be held in a separate trust account and to be withdrawn only as the lawyer earns them or incurs the expenses. Commingling client money with the lawyer's own funds is prohibited.

  6. Question 6Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A court appoints a lawyer to represent an indigent defendant. The lawyer finds the case distasteful and wants to decline. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. Yes, because a lawyer is never obligated to represent a client she does not wish to represent.
    2. No, unless the matter would violate the Rules or impose an unreasonable financial burden. Correct answer.
    3. No, because a court appointment may never be declined under any circumstances.
    4. Yes, because the client has not paid any retainer or filing fee.

    Explanation

    Rule 6.2 requires a lawyer to accept a court appointment unless doing so would violate the Rules or law or would impose an unreasonable financial burden. Personal dislike of the case or the client is not good cause to decline.

  7. Question 7Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer represented a client in drafting a will. The representation has ended. A second person now asks the lawyer to represent her in a boundary dispute against the former client, a matter unrelated to the will. May the lawyer accept?

    1. Yes, but only if the lawyer first gives the former client written notice of the new matter.
    2. No, because a lawyer may never take a matter adverse to a former client.
    3. No, unless the former client consents in writing after being consulted.
    4. Yes, because the new matter is not substantially related to the earlier representation. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.9(a) bars a lawyer from opposing a former client in the same or a substantially related matter in which the client's interests are materially adverse, absent informed consent. When the new matter is unrelated, no conflict exists, although the lawyer may not use or reveal information learned in the prior representation.

  8. Question 8Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer wants to borrow money from an existing client. What does Rule 1.8(a) require?

    1. Nothing beyond a normal promissory note, because the client offered the loan.
    2. Only that the lawyer disclose the conflict orally before the loan is funded.
    3. That the terms be fair, disclosed in writing, and the client consent in writing. Correct answer.
    4. That the client be separately represented by an independent lawyer in the transaction.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(a) requires that the transaction terms be fair and fully disclosed to the client in writing in a manner the client reasonably understands, that the client be advised in writing to seek independent counsel, and that the client give informed consent in writing.

  9. Question 9Regulation of the Legal Profession

    Midway through trial, a lawyer learns that her client gave testimony that the client has now admitted was false in a material matter. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Withdraw from the representation without telling the court the reason for the withdrawal.
    2. Do nothing, because the lawyer may not reveal information relating to the representation.
    3. Take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure to the court if necessary. Correct answer.
    4. Ask the client to repeat the testimony so the lawyer can cross-examine the client.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(b) requires a lawyer who knows a client has offered false material evidence to take reasonable remedial measures, including, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal. The duty of candor to the court overrides the confidentiality duty for this purpose.

  10. Question 10Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer represents a plaintiff in a negligence suit. The defendant is represented by counsel. The lawyer wants to call the defendant directly to discuss settlement. May the lawyer do so?

    1. Yes, provided the lawyer identifies herself and her client at the start of the call.
    2. No, unless the defendant's counsel consents or the law authorizes the contact. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, because settlement discussions are not part of the litigation.
    4. No, because all communication with an adverse party is forbidden in every circumstance.

    Explanation

    Rule 4.2 prohibits communication about the matter with a person the lawyer knows is represented by counsel, unless that counsel consents or the law authorizes the communication. Settlement is part of the matter, so the prohibition applies.

  11. Question 11Regulation of the Legal Profession

    Two lawyers who practice in different firms want to divide a fee in a single matter. Which arrangement complies with the Model Rules?

    1. Each assumes joint responsibility and the client agrees in writing to the division. Correct answer.
    2. They divide the fee and pay a share to the paralegal who brought in the client.
    3. They divide the fee without telling the client, since the total fee is reasonable.
    4. One lawyer refers the case to the other firm and receives a share without doing any work on the matter.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.5(e) permits a division of fees between lawyers not in the same firm only if the division is proportionate to the services performed or each lawyer assumes joint responsibility, the client agrees in writing, and the total fee is reasonable. Rule 5.4(a) forbids sharing fees with nonlawyers.

  12. Question 12Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A supervising lawyer trains a paralegal to handle client intake. The paralegal begins advising walk-in clients about their legal rights and the likely outcome of their cases. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. None, provided the paralegal's advice is accurate and the firm does not charge the clients for it.
    2. The lawyer must report the paralegal to the disciplinary authorities for the unauthorized practice of law.
    3. The lawyer must make reasonable efforts to ensure the paralegal's conduct complies with the Rules. Correct answer.
    4. None, because a paralegal is not a lawyer and therefore is not subject to the Rules of Professional Conduct.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.3 requires a lawyer with managerial authority to make reasonable efforts to ensure that a nonlawyer's conduct is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations. A nonlawyer may not give legal advice, so the lawyer must stop and correct the conduct.

  13. Question 13Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer is admitted to practice only in State A. A client asks her to represent it in an arbitration being held in State B. Which statement is correct?

    1. She may represent the client if the arbitration is reasonably related to her State A practice. Correct answer.
    2. She may never represent the client, because arbitration is the practice of law in State B.
    3. She may represent the client only if she is admitted pro hac vice in State B.
    4. She may represent the client if she associates a lawyer admitted in State B to sit second chair at the hearing.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.5(c)(3) permits a lawyer admitted in another jurisdiction to provide legal services on a temporary basis in connection with an arbitration or mediation that arises out of or is reasonably related to the lawyer's practice in a jurisdiction where she is admitted.

  14. Question 14Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer represents a client charged with fraud. Which decision belongs to the client rather than to the lawyer?

    1. Whether to file a motion to suppress evidence obtained in a warrantless search.
    2. Whether to call an expert witness the lawyer already retained for trial.
    3. Whether to raise an affirmative defense that the lawyer believes is weak but nonfrivolous.
    4. Whether to accept a plea offer from the prosecution. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.2(a) reserves certain decisions to the client, including whether to plead guilty, whether to accept a plea offer, whether to testify, and whether to settle a civil matter. Tactical decisions such as which motions to file or which witnesses to call ordinarily belong to the lawyer.

  15. Question 15Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer has appeared for a defendant in a pending lawsuit and now wants to withdraw. Which statement is correct?

    1. The lawyer may withdraw only with the client's written consent, even if the client cannot be found.
    2. The lawyer must refund all fees paid, regardless of the work already performed on the matter.
    3. The lawyer must obtain any required tribunal approval and protect the client's interests. Correct answer.
    4. The lawyer may withdraw at any time by filing a notice with the court, without court permission.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.16(c) requires a lawyer to comply with applicable law requiring notice to or permission of a tribunal when terminating representation, and Rule 1.16(d) requires reasonable steps to protect the client's interests, including giving notice and returning papers and unearned fees.

  16. Question 16Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer learns that another lawyer in her county has been filing false affidavits in unrelated cases. When does Rule 8.3 require her to report the misconduct?

    1. Only if the other lawyer's client consents to the report being filed with the bar.
    2. When it raises a substantial question about the other lawyer's honesty or fitness. Correct answer.
    3. Whenever she learns of any violation of the Rules, however minor.
    4. Only if a court has already entered a finding that the other lawyer committed the misconduct.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.3(a) requires a lawyer to report a violation that raises a substantial question as to the other lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer, unless the information is protected by Rule 1.6. Isolated, minor violations need not be reported.

  17. Question 17Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A law firm asks a sophisticated corporate client to consent in advance to future conflicts of interest that are not directly adverse. Which statement best describes the effect of such an agreement?

    1. Prohibited, because a client may never consent to a future conflict of interest.
    2. Prohibited unless the waiver is approved by a court before the conflict arises.
    3. Permissible only if the firm later obtains a second written consent for each new matter.
    4. Permissible if the client gives informed consent and reasonably understands the material risks. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 1.7(b) and its comments, a client may consent in advance to future conflicts, but the effectiveness of the waiver depends on whether the client reasonably understands the material risks, which in turn depends on the explanation given and the client's sophistication.

  18. Question 18Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer meets with a prospective client about a proposed merger. The meeting is brief, but the prospective client reveals sensitive financial information that would be significantly harmful to her if used against her. The lawyer does not take the engagement. A month later, the opposing party in the merger asks the lawyer's firm to handle litigation against the prospective client. What is the result?

    1. The firm is permanently disqualified, because an initial consultation disqualifies every lawyer in the firm from any adverse matter.
    2. The firm may take the matter, because no attorney-client relationship was ever formed with the prospective client.
    3. The firm may take the matter if the prospective client is notified of the conflict and does not object within thirty days.
    4. The lawyer is personally barred; the firm may act only if she is screened and the others are untainted. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.18 protects information learned from a prospective client. The lawyer who received significantly harmful information is personally disqualified, and the firm may act only if that lawyer is timely screened, written notice is given, and no other lawyer in the firm received disqualifying information.

  19. Question 19Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer is litigating a case in which she is likely to be a necessary witness on a contested, material fact. Under Rule 3.7, which statement is correct?

    1. She may not act as advocate at trial under any circumstances, even if she is only a witness about legal fees.
    2. She may serve as both advocate and witness if her testimony will be brief.
    3. She may not act as advocate at trial unless her testimony concerns an uncontested issue. Correct answer.
    4. She may serve as both advocate and witness if the client consents after consultation.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.7(a) bars a lawyer from acting as advocate at a trial in which she is likely to be a necessary witness, with exceptions for uncontested issues, testimony about the nature and value of legal services, and substantial hardship to the client. The rule is not subject to waiver by client consent.

  20. Question 20Regulation of the Legal Profession

    A lawyer holds $50,000 in trust for a client. The client's former business partner claims $20,000 of the funds, and the lawyer knows the client disputes the claim. What must the lawyer do with the disputed $20,000?

    1. Deliver it to the business partner, because the partner has asserted a claim to it.
    2. Turn the entire $50,000 over to the court and close the trust account.
    3. Deliver it to the client, because the funds came from the client's settlement.
    4. Keep the disputed $20,000 in trust until the dispute is resolved. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.15(e) requires a lawyer holding funds in which a third person claims an interest to keep the disputed portion separate in trust until the dispute is resolved, while promptly distributing the undisputed portion to the client.

  21. Question 21The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A woman meets with a lawyer for a free initial consultation about a car accident. She provides confidential details, and the lawyer declines the case. Which statement best describes the lawyer's obligations?

    1. The lawyer owes a duty of confidentiality regarding the information received. Correct answer.
    2. The lawyer must return any notes the client left with the lawyer.
    3. No duties arise because the lawyer never agreed to represent her.
    4. The lawyer may use the information for the lawyer's own benefit.

    Explanation

    Under Model Rule 1.18, a person who consults a lawyer about the possibility of forming a client-lawyer relationship is a prospective client. Even when no representation results, the lawyer generally may not reveal or use information learned in the consultation. The duty is limited but survives the declined representation.

  22. Question 22The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    Which item is protected by the attorney-client privilege?

    1. A preexisting document the client gave the lawyer before the meeting.
    2. The client's observable physical appearance at the meeting.
    3. A confidential communication made to the lawyer to obtain legal advice. Correct answer.
    4. The fact that the client met with the lawyer.

    Explanation

    The attorney-client privilege protects confidential communications between client and lawyer made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice. It does not protect facts the lawyer observes independently or preexisting documents. The existence of the relationship and the client's appearance are generally not privileged.

  23. Question 23The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer accepts a matter in an unfamiliar area of law. What is the lawyer's best course under the Model Rules?

    1. Proceed and learn the law as the case progresses without telling the client.
    2. Decline the case unless the lawyer has handled at least three similar matters.
    3. Ask the client to sign a waiver of the competence requirement.
    4. Accept the case only if the lawyer can become competent through study or association. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.1 requires competent representation, including the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary. A lawyer may take on an unfamiliar matter if the lawyer can become competent through necessary study or by associating with a competent lawyer. Competence cannot be waived by the client.

  24. Question 24The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A client authorizes a lawyer to settle a case for no less than $50,000. The opposing party offers $47,000. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Accept the offer if the lawyer believes the client would ultimately recover less at trial.
    2. Counteroffer $50,000 and not mention the $47,000 offer to the client.
    3. Reject the offer without informing the client because it is below the authorized amount.
    4. Promptly inform the client of the offer and let the client decide. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Settlement is a client decision under Model Rule 1.2(a), and Rule 1.4 requires the lawyer to keep the client reasonably informed and promptly communicate settlement offers. The lawyer may advise the client but may not accept an offer outside the client's authority. The client chooses whether to accept, reject, or counteroffer.

  25. Question 25The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer receives a $10,000 advance fee from a new client. Under the Model Rules, where should the lawyer deposit the funds?

    1. In the lawyer's client trust account until the fees are earned. Correct answer.
    2. In the lawyer's personal savings account to protect the client.
    3. In the lawyer's operating account because the fee has been paid.
    4. With the court clerk pending completion of the matter.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.15 requires client funds, including advance fees not yet earned, to be held in a trust account separate from the lawyer's own funds. The lawyer may withdraw earned fees as work is performed. Commingling client funds with the lawyer's funds is prohibited.

  26. Question 26The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    Which decision belongs to the client rather than the lawyer?

    1. What questions to ask on cross-examination.
    2. Whether to accept a settlement offer. Correct answer.
    3. Which witnesses to call at trial.
    4. Whether to assert a particular affirmative defense.

    Explanation

    Under Model Rule 1.2(a), the client decides the objectives of the representation, including whether to settle a civil case, accept a plea, waive a jury, testify, or appeal. The lawyer decides the means and strategy, such as which witnesses to call and what questions to ask. Asserting a defense is generally a strategic decision.

  27. Question 27The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer represented a client in a divorce five years ago. A former opposing party now asks the lawyer about the client's finances. What is the lawyer's duty?

    1. The lawyer may discuss the matter because the representation has ended.
    2. The lawyer may confirm only information that is already public.
    3. The lawyer must keep the information confidential. Correct answer.
    4. The lawyer may disclose the information if the former client does not object.

    Explanation

    The duty of confidentiality under Model Rule 1.6 continues after the client-lawyer relationship ends. Information relating to the former representation may not be revealed without informed consent or another exception. The passage of time does not eliminate the duty.

  28. Question 28The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer is hired to represent a client in a criminal case and proposes a fee equal to 25% of any fine the client avoids. Is this permissible?

    1. No, contingency fees are prohibited in criminal cases. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, if the client agrees in writing.
    3. Yes, if the fee is ultimately reasonable.
    4. Yes, if the lawyer advances all litigation costs.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.5(d)(1) prohibits contingent fees in criminal cases and in domestic relations matters where the fee is contingent on obtaining a divorce or on the amount of alimony or support. The prohibition applies even if the client consents in writing. Public policy disfavors financial incentives that could affect the lawyer's professional judgment in criminal matters.

  29. Question 29The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer represents two partners in forming a joint venture. A dispute later arises between the partners over the venture. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. The lawyer may continue representing both if the dispute is minor.
    2. The lawyer must represent the partner who first hired the lawyer.
    3. The lawyer may represent one partner if that partner pays the fees.
    4. The lawyer must withdraw from representing both clients in the dispute. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Representing both sides of a dispute between current clients creates a concurrent conflict under Model Rule 1.7. A lawyer may not assert a claim by one client against another client in the same litigation, even with consent. The lawyer must withdraw from representing both in the dispute, though the lawyer may continue in unrelated matters if no conflict exists.

  30. Question 30The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer represented Client A in drafting a will. After the representation ends, Client B asks the lawyer to challenge the will on undue-influence grounds. The lawyer learned confidential family financial details from Client A during the drafting. May the lawyer represent Client B?

    1. No, absent Client A's informed written consent, because the matter is substantially related and adverse. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, if Client A consents orally.
    3. Yes, because the matters are not identical.
    4. No, because a lawyer may never represent a party against a former client.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.9(a) prohibits a lawyer from representing a new client in the same or a substantially related matter in which the new client's interests are materially adverse to a former client without the former client's informed consent confirmed in writing. Challenging the will the lawyer drafted is substantially related to the former representation. The former client's confidential information is directly relevant.

  31. Question 31The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A man consults a lawyer about a business dispute. The lawyer learns the man's confidential strategy but does not take the case. The opposing party later asks the lawyer to represent it in the same dispute. Under Rule 1.18, may the lawyer accept?

    1. Yes, if the lawyer charges the prospective client no fee for the consultation.
    2. Yes, because no attorney-client relationship was formed.
    3. No, because a consultation disqualifies the lawyer forever in all matters.
    4. No, because the lawyer received information that could be significantly harmful to the prospective client. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.18 protects prospective clients. If a lawyer receives information from a prospective client that could be significantly harmful to that person in the matter, the lawyer may not represent a client with materially adverse interests in the same or a substantially related matter. The disqualification is limited to that matter and can be cured by informed consent in some circumstances.

  32. Question 32The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer wants to buy a rental property from a current client for $200,000. The property is fairly valued at $260,000. What must the lawyer do to comply with Rule 1.8(a)?

    1. Wait until the representation ends before discussing terms.
    2. Nothing, because the client proposed the transaction.
    3. Ensure fair terms, disclose in writing, advise independent counsel, and obtain written consent. Correct answer.
    4. Obtain only the client's oral consent after disclosing the price.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.8(a) governs business transactions with a client. The terms must be fair and reasonable to the client and fully disclosed in writing in a manner the client can reasonably understand. The client must be advised in writing to seek independent counsel and must give informed consent in writing.

  33. Question 33The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer represents a client with the client's written consent, and the client's employer pays the legal fees. The employer asks the lawyer to keep certain information from the client. What should the lawyer do?

    1. Follow the employer's request because the employer pays the bills.
    2. Withdraw from the representation immediately in all cases.
    3. Disclose the information only if the client asks for it.
    4. Refuse to let the employer interfere and keep the client reasonably informed. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under Model Rule 1.8(f), a lawyer may accept compensation from a third party only if the client gives informed consent, the third party does not interfere with the lawyer's independent professional judgment, and client information is protected. The lawyer's duty of communication runs to the client. A fee payer cannot direct the lawyer to withhold material information from the client.

  34. Question 34The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer drafts a will for a client that leaves the lawyer a substantial bequest. The client is not related to the lawyer. Is this permissible?

    1. No, because lawyers may never receive any gift from a client.
    2. No, unless the lawyer is related to the client. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, if the lawyer discloses the bequest to the client in writing.
    4. Yes, if the client insists and the will is properly witnessed.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.8(c) prohibits a lawyer from preparing an instrument giving the lawyer or a person related to the lawyer a substantial gift, unless the lawyer or recipient is related to the client. The rule prevents overreaching and undue influence in estate planning. A substantial bequest drafted by the lawyer is therefore improper absent the required family relationship.

  35. Question 35The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer begins representing a company in a commercial dispute. Midway through, the lawyer begins a consensual sexual relationship with the company's CEO, who supervises the litigation. What is the lawyer's ethical obligation?

    1. The lawyer must withdraw because such a relationship is prohibited. Correct answer.
    2. No issue, because the client is a company rather than an individual.
    3. The lawyer may continue only if the CEO signs a conflict waiver.
    4. No issue, because the relationship is consensual and private.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.8(j) prohibits sexual relations with a client unless a consensual relationship existed before the representation began. When the client is an organization, the prohibition applies to a person who supervises or regularly consults with the lawyer about the matter. The relationship is not curable by consent, and the lawyer must withdraw.

  36. Question 36The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer charges a client a $5,000 retainer labeled nonrefundable. The lawyer does $1,500 of work before the client discharges the lawyer. What is the lawyer's obligation regarding the $3,500 balance?

    1. Keep the balance because nonrefundable retainers are always valid.
    2. Refund the balance because fees not yet earned must be returned. Correct answer.
    3. Keep the balance because the client agreed to the term in writing.
    4. Keep the balance because the lawyer reviewed the file.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.16(d) requires a lawyer to refund any advance payment of fee that has not been earned. A provision labeling a retainer nonrefundable does not override the duty to return unearned funds. The lawyer may keep only the reasonable value of services actually performed.

  37. Question 37The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    Lawyer A refers a personal injury client to Lawyer B. They agree that A will receive 20% of the fee but will not work on the case or assume responsibility. The client consents in writing. Is the fee division proper?

    1. Yes, because referral fees are always permitted between lawyers.
    2. Yes, because the client consented in writing.
    3. No, because A did not perform services or assume joint responsibility. Correct answer.
    4. No, because lawyers may never divide fees in any circumstances.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.5(e) permits a division of fees between lawyers not in the same firm only if the client consents in writing, the total fee is reasonable, and the division is proportional to the services performed or each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation. A pure referral fee without services or responsibility fails the rule. Written client consent alone is insufficient.

  38. Question 38The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer discovers that continuing to represent a client will require the lawyer to assist in conduct the lawyer knows is fraudulent. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Withdraw, and seek court permission if the court requires it. Correct answer.
    2. Ask the client to sign a waiver of the lawyer's ethical duties.
    3. Continue but avoid signing any documents related to the fraud.
    4. Continue the representation and report the fraud after the case ends.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.16(a)(1) requires a lawyer to withdraw if continued representation will result in violation of the rules of professional conduct or other law. Assisting fraudulent conduct would violate the rules. If a tribunal requires approval for withdrawal, the lawyer must seek permission but must not continue the improper conduct.

  39. Question 39The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A client tells a lawyer that the client intends to sell fraudulent securities next week to investors. The client is using the lawyer's advice to structure the offering documents. May the lawyer disclose the information?

    1. Yes, because the lawyer may always disclose a client's future plans.
    2. No, because confidentiality applies to all client statements.
    3. No, unless the client has already completed the fraudulent sales.
    4. Yes, because disclosure is permitted to prevent a crime or fraud reasonably certain to cause substantial financial injury. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.6(b)(2) and (b)(3) permit a lawyer to reveal information reasonably necessary to prevent a client from committing a crime or fraud reasonably certain to result in substantial financial injury, or to prevent or mitigate such injury when the lawyer's services were used. The permission is limited and requires a serious, likely harm. The lawyer may disclose only information reasonably necessary to accomplish the purpose.

  40. Question 40The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer represents both a landlord and a tenant in separate, unrelated matters. The tenant asks the lawyer to sue the landlord in an eviction dispute. May the lawyer represent the tenant in that dispute?

    1. No, because the lawyer would assert a claim by one current client against another in the same proceeding. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, if both clients are sophisticated business entities.
    3. Yes, if both clients give informed consent confirmed in writing.
    4. Yes, if the lawyer reasonably believes the representation will not be materially limited.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.7(b)(3) provides that a lawyer may not represent a client in asserting a claim against another current client in the same litigation or other proceeding before a tribunal, even with informed consent. This conflict is nonconsentable. The fact that the other representation is unrelated does not cure the problem once the two clients are adverse in the same proceeding.

  41. Question 41The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    An elderly client with early dementia insists on transferring assets in a way the lawyer believes will cause financial harm. The client understands the basic decision. What should the lawyer do?

    1. Follow the family's instructions instead of the client's.
    2. Refuse to speak with the client until a family member is present.
    3. Immediately petition for guardianship without telling the client.
    4. Maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship as far as possible and consider protective action if the client is at risk. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.14 directs a lawyer to maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship with a client whose capacity is diminished, as far as reasonably possible. The lawyer may take protective action, such as consulting family or seeking guardianship, if the lawyer reasonably believes the client is at risk of substantial harm and cannot act in the client's own interest. The lawyer should not substitute a family member's judgment for the client's.

  42. Question 42The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A corporation's outside counsel interviews the CFO about accounting practices. The CFO admits to fraudulent entries. In later litigation, a shareholder sues the corporation and seeks the CFO's statements. Who holds the attorney-client privilege?

    1. No one, because the statements concern fraud.
    2. The CFO personally, because he made the statements.
    3. The shareholders, because they own the corporation.
    4. The corporation, because the privilege belongs to the entity client. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    When a lawyer represents an organization under Model Rule 1.13, the client is the organization, not its officers or employees. The attorney-client privilege belongs to the entity and may be asserted or waived by those authorized to act for the entity. The CFO's statements to corporate counsel are generally privileged in favor of the corporation, although the crime-fraud exception may apply in some circumstances.

  43. Question 43The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer withdraws from representing a client because the client failed to pay fees. The former client's new lawyer asks for the case file. What must the former lawyer do?

    1. Turn over the file, because the client is entitled to it even if fees are unpaid. Correct answer.
    2. Turn over only documents the client signed.
    3. Destroy the file to protect the client's confidentiality.
    4. Withhold the entire file until the unpaid fees are paid.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.16(e) requires a lawyer upon termination to return all papers and property to which the client is entitled. The lawyer generally may not retain the client's file to pressure payment of fees, although the lawyer may retain a copy and may assert a lien only as permitted by law. Destroying the file would violate duties to the client and the rules on file retention.

  44. Question 44The Client-Lawyer Relationship

    A lawyer asks a new client to sign a blanket waiver allowing the lawyer to represent any current or future adverse party in any matter. Is the waiver effective?

    1. Yes, if the lawyer believes the client understands it.
    2. No, because informed consent requires knowledge of the material risks of a specific conflict. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, if the client is a sophisticated business entity.
    4. Yes, if the waiver is in writing and notarized.

    Explanation

    Informed consent under Model Rule 1.0(e) requires the client to have reasonably adequate information about the material risks of the proposed course of conduct. Open-ended advance waivers are ordinarily ineffective because the client cannot appreciate the risks of unknown future conflicts. A waiver is more likely to be effective when it is specific and the client is sophisticated, but a blanket waiver of all future conflicts is not.

  45. Question 45Client Confidentiality

    Under Model Rule 1.6, the duty of confidentiality covers which of the following?

    1. All information relating to the representation, regardless of its source Correct answer.
    2. Only information the lawyer receives directly from the client
    3. Only communications that would be protected by the attorney-client privilege
    4. Only information the client expressly asks the lawyer to keep secret

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(a) prohibits revealing information relating to the representation of a client. Confidentiality is broader than the attorney-client privilege and reaches information from any source, including third parties, the lawyer's own observations, and public records connected to the matter.

  46. Question 46Client Confidentiality

    A lawyer may reveal confidential client information without violating Rule 1.6 when:

    1. The information has already been shared with one other person
    2. The client gives informed consent to the disclosure Correct answer.
    3. The lawyer believes disclosure would benefit the client's business interests
    4. The lawyer's spouse is curious about the matter

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(a) permits disclosure when the client gives informed consent, when disclosure is impliedly authorized to carry out the representation, or when a specific exception applies. The lawyer's own view that disclosure would be beneficial does not suffice.

  47. Question 47Client Confidentiality

    Which statement best describes the duration of a lawyer's confidentiality obligation?

    1. Confidentiality continues after the representation ends. Correct answer.
    2. The duty ends when the client hires new counsel.
    3. The duty ends when the lawyer sends the final bill.
    4. The duty ends only if the client signs a release.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6 Comment 19 states that the duty of confidentiality continues after the client-lawyer relationship has terminated. Former clients remain protected under Rule 1.9(c) as well.

  48. Question 48Client Confidentiality

    With respect to client information stored electronically, Model Rule 1.6 requires a lawyer to:

    1. Disclose all electronic files to the client monthly
    2. Make reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access Correct answer.
    3. Avoid using email for any client communication
    4. Encrypt every file, regardless of cost or practicality

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(e) requires reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized access to information relating to the representation. Reasonableness depends on the sensitivity of the information and the cost of safeguards, not on a ban on email or a fixed technical mandate.

  49. Question 49Client Confidentiality

    The attorney-client privilege generally protects:

    1. All information the lawyer learns about the client, from any source
    2. The client's underlying facts and documents, even if not communicated to the lawyer
    3. Confidential communications between client and lawyer made to obtain legal advice Correct answer.
    4. Communications made in the presence of third parties strangers to the relationship

    Explanation

    The privilege protects confidential communications between a client and lawyer made for the purpose of obtaining legal advice. It does not protect all information the lawyer learns, nor underlying facts merely because the client knows them.

  50. Question 50Client Confidentiality

    Rule 1.6(d) requires a lawyer to make reasonable efforts to prevent:

    1. The client from discussing the case publicly
    2. Inadvertent disclosure of confidential information to the wrong person Correct answer.
    3. Any communication with the client's family
    4. Opposing counsel from contacting the client directly without permission

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(d) directs lawyers to make reasonable efforts to prevent inadvertent or unauthorized disclosure of, or unauthorized access to, information relating to the representation. It addresses the lawyer's own safeguards rather than the client's speech or opposing counsel's conduct.

  51. Question 51Client Confidentiality

    A client tells the lawyer that he intends to shoot his neighbor tonight. Under Rule 1.6(b)(1), the lawyer may:

    1. Reveal what is necessary to prevent death or substantial bodily harm Correct answer.
    2. Reveal only if the client used the lawyer's services to plan the shooting
    3. Reveal all information about the client's past dealings with the neighbor
    4. Do nothing, because confidentiality is absolute

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(1) permits disclosure to the extent the lawyer reasonably believes necessary to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm. The exception does not require that the lawyer's services have been used.

  52. Question 52Client Confidentiality

    A client tells her lawyer that she plans to use a company the lawyer helped her form to defraud investors of a substantial sum. Under Rule 1.6(b)(2), the lawyer may reveal information to:

    1. Protect the lawyer's reputation in the community
    2. Prevent the fraud, which is reasonably certain to cause substantial injury Correct answer.
    3. Report any past misconduct by the client, whether or not it caused any injury
    4. Recover fees the client has not yet paid

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(2) allows disclosure to prevent a client from committing a crime or fraud reasonably certain to result in substantial injury to another's financial interests or property, if the client has used the lawyer's services in furtherance of the conduct. Here both the use of the lawyer's services and the threatened substantial injury are present.

  53. Question 53Client Confidentiality

    A client tells his lawyer that he intends to key-scratch a neighbor's car, causing several hundred dollars in damage. The client did not use the lawyer's services for this plan. The lawyer may:

    1. Reveal the information to the police immediately
    2. Reveal the information to warn the neighbor
    3. Reveal the information because property damage is always an exception
    4. Not reveal the information, because no exception applies Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(1) covers death or substantial bodily harm, not minor property damage. Rule 1.6(b)(2) requires a crime or fraud reasonably certain to cause substantial financial injury and use of the lawyer's services; here neither element is satisfied.

  54. Question 54Client Confidentiality

    A lawyer who represented a client in a completed real estate sale later receives a subpoena for information about that matter. The lawyer:

    1. May disclose only if the former client is unavailable
    2. Remains bound by confidentiality and may disclose only as Rule 1.6 allows Correct answer.
    3. Must disclose because the matter is public record
    4. May disclose freely because the representation has ended and the sale closed

    Explanation

    The duty of confidentiality continues after the representation ends, and Rule 1.9(c) protects information relating to the former representation. The lawyer may disclose only if an exception such as a court order applies, and must seek to limit disclosure where appropriate.

  55. Question 55Client Confidentiality

    During a free initial consultation, a prospective client tells a lawyer sensitive facts before deciding not to hire the lawyer. Under Rule 1.18, the lawyer:

    1. Must return any notes to the prospective client
    2. Has no confidentiality duty because no fee was paid
    3. May not reveal information learned in the consultation Correct answer.
    4. May use the information for the benefit of another client

    Explanation

    Rule 1.18(b) provides that even when no client-lawyer relationship ensues, a lawyer who learned information from a prospective client may not use or reveal that information except as Rule 1.9 would permit for a former client. Payment of a fee is not required to trigger the duty.

  56. Question 56Client Confidentiality

    A lawyer receives an email containing an opposing party's privileged document that was clearly sent by mistake. Under Rule 4.4(b), the lawyer must:

    1. Notify the sender promptly so the sender can act Correct answer.
    2. Use the document in the case if it helps the client's position
    3. Delete the email without telling anyone
    4. Place the document in the court file so the judge can decide its use

    Explanation

    Rule 4.4(b) requires a lawyer who knows or reasonably should know that a document was inadvertently sent to notify the sender promptly. The lawyer may not simply exploit the mistake, and the rule leaves further obligations to other law.

  57. Question 57Client Confidentiality

    A former client sues the lawyer for malpractice, alleging the lawyer mishandled the case. The lawyer may reveal confidential information:

    1. Only after the court orders disclosure
    2. Never, because confidentiality is absolute
    3. As reasonably necessary to defend against the claim Correct answer.
    4. Only if the client waives confidentiality in writing

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(5) permits a lawyer to reveal information reasonably necessary to defend against a claim or charge based on the lawyer's conduct. A written waiver is not required for this self-defense exception.

  58. Question 58Client Confidentiality

    The client refuses to pay the lawyer's bill, and the lawyer sues to collect. The lawyer may reveal confidential information:

    1. Never, because fee disputes are not covered by Rule 1.6
    2. Only with the client's informed consent
    3. As reasonably necessary to establish the right to fees Correct answer.
    4. Only after the state bar association formally approves the disclosure

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(6) permits disclosure to the extent reasonably necessary to establish a claim or defense in a controversy between the lawyer and client, including establishing the right to fees. The disclosure should be limited to what the fee dispute actually requires.

  59. Question 59Client Confidentiality

    A court orders a lawyer to testify about confidential client information, and no exception other than the order applies. The lawyer:

    1. Must refuse and accept contempt
    2. May disclose information to the extent required by the order Correct answer.
    3. Must appeal before disclosing anything
    4. May disclose whatever the lawyer thinks is relevant

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(7) permits a lawyer to reveal information to comply with a court order. The lawyer should seek to limit the disclosure to what the order requires and may assert available protections, but the order itself supplies an exception.

  60. Question 60Client Confidentiality

    A client asks the lawyer to share confidential information with the client's accountant to prepare tax returns. The lawyer may do so if:

    1. The lawyer determines it is in the client's best interest
    2. The client gives informed consent to the disclosure Correct answer.
    3. The information is not privileged
    4. The accountant agrees to keep the information secret

    Explanation

    Disclosure to a third party such as an accountant generally requires the client's informed consent under Rule 1.6(a). The accountant's own promise of secrecy does not substitute for the client's authorization.

  61. Question 61Client Confidentiality

    A lawyer moves from Firm A to Firm B and needs to check for conflicts arising from the move. Under Rule 1.6(c), Firm B's lawyers may reveal limited information about the matters involved:

    1. When necessary to detect conflicts, without compromising privilege or prejudicing the client Correct answer.
    2. Only if the former clients consent in writing after full disclosure of the conflict
    3. Only if the information is already publicly available in court records
    4. Only after a court determines that an actual conflict exists

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(c) allows a lawyer to reveal information to detect and resolve conflicts of interest arising from a change of employment, but only if the revealed information would not compromise the attorney-client privilege or otherwise prejudice the client. The disclosure must be limited to what the conflict check requires.

  62. Question 62Client Confidentiality

    A client consults a lawyer for help in creating documents to conceal an ongoing securities fraud. The client later asserts privilege over those communications. A court is most likely to:

    1. Hold the privilege applies but only to oral statements
    2. Protect the communications because they were made to a lawyer during a consultation
    3. Hold the communications are unprivileged under the crime-fraud exception Correct answer.
    4. Protect the communications because the client paid a retainer

    Explanation

    The crime-fraud exception removes from privilege communications made to further a crime or fraud. Because the client sought the lawyer's assistance to conceal an ongoing fraud, the communications are not protected.

  63. Question 63Client Confidentiality

    A client insists on testifying falsely in his own defense, and the lawyer knows the testimony is false. Under Rule 3.3, the lawyer must:

    1. Disclose the perjury only after the trial ends
    2. Withdraw without taking any other action
    3. Allow the testimony to proceed and then argue the client's innocence to the jury
    4. Take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure if needed Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(a)(3) prohibits a lawyer from knowingly offering false evidence. If the client insists on testifying falsely, the lawyer must take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure to the tribunal if necessary, and may reveal confidential information to the extent needed.

  64. Question 64Client Confidentiality

    A client used the lawyer's services to complete a fraud that has already caused substantial financial injury to a third party. Under Rule 1.6(b)(3), the lawyer may reveal information reasonably necessary to:

    1. Report the client's conduct to the local news media
    2. Recover the lawyer's unpaid fees
    3. Punish the client for the fraud through the disciplinary system
    4. Prevent, mitigate, or rectify the substantial financial injury Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.6(b)(3) permits disclosure to prevent, mitigate, or rectify substantial injury to the financial interests or property of another that is reasonably certain to result or has resulted from the client's crime or fraud in furtherance of which the client used the lawyer's services. The disclosure must be limited to what is reasonably necessary for that remedial purpose.

  65. Question 65Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer is asked to represent a new client in a matter that is directly adverse to the interests of an existing client in an unrelated matter. Under the ABA Model Rules, which of the following is required before the lawyer may accept the new representation?

    1. The lawyer must decline the representation altogether, because direct adversity to a current client can never be waived by consent.
    2. Each client gives informed consent confirmed in writing, and the lawyer reasonably believes the representation will not adversely affect the other client. Correct answer.
    3. The lawyer must inform the existing client orally, and may proceed with the new matter if that client does not object within a reasonable time.
    4. The lawyer must obtain the approval of the tribunal before undertaking a representation adverse to an existing client.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.7(a)(1) treats a representation directly adverse to a current client as a concurrent conflict of interest. Rule 1.7(b) permits the representation only if the lawyer reasonably believes competent and diligent representation of each client is possible, the representation is not prohibited by law, the clients are not asserting claims against each other in the same litigation, and each affected client gives informed consent confirmed in writing.

  66. Question 66Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer wishes to enter into a business transaction with an existing client. Which of the following must be present for the transaction to comply with Model Rule 1.8(a)?

    1. The transaction must be reviewed and approved in writing by a disinterested lawyer who is not associated with the lawyer's firm.
    2. The terms are fair and reasonable and disclosed in writing, and the client consents in writing after being advised to seek independent counsel. Correct answer.
    3. The lawyer must charge the client no more than the prevailing market rate, and the client must acknowledge the price in a signed receipt.
    4. The client must be represented by independent counsel paid for by the lawyer, and that counsel must approve the transaction.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(a) requires that the transaction be fair and reasonable to the client, that its terms be fully disclosed in writing in a manner the client reasonably understands, that the client be advised in writing to seek independent counsel, and that the client give informed consent in writing. The lawyer must also comply with the general conflict rules.

  67. Question 67Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer's elderly client wishes to make a substantial testamentary gift to the lawyer. When may the lawyer prepare an instrument effecting that gift?

    1. Under no circumstances, because lawyers may never draft instruments benefiting themselves.
    2. Only if the lawyer is related to the client. Correct answer.
    3. Only if the client is advised in writing to seek independent counsel before signing.
    4. Only if the client gives informed consent confirmed in writing.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(c) bars a lawyer from soliciting a substantial gift from a client, including a testamentary gift, or from preparing an instrument giving the lawyer or a person related to the lawyer a substantial gift. The rule contains an exception where the lawyer or other recipient is related to the client.

  68. Question 68Conflicts of Interest

    Which of the following forms of assistance may a lawyer properly provide to a client in a pending civil matter?

    1. Guaranteeing a bank loan that the client will use to satisfy personal obligations.
    2. Paying the client's ordinary living expenses for the duration of the litigation.
    3. Giving the client cash to encourage the client to pursue a valuable claim.
    4. Advancing court costs and litigation expenses, with repayment contingent on the outcome of the case. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(e) allows a lawyer to advance court costs and expenses of litigation, and to make repayment contingent on the outcome of the matter. A lawyer may also pay such costs on behalf of an indigent client. The rule does not permit paying a client's living expenses or guaranteeing loans for personal obligations.

  69. Question 69Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer may begin a sexual relationship with a client only when:

    1. the lawyer's firm screens the lawyer from all matters involving the client.
    2. the client gives informed consent confirmed in writing after disclosure of the risks of the relationship.
    3. the representation is limited to a matter unrelated to the relationship.
    4. the consensual sexual relationship predates the attorney-client relationship. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(j) prohibits a lawyer from having a sexual relationship with a client unless a consensual sexual relationship existed between them before the lawyer-client relationship began. Client consent, screening, or the unrelatedness of the matter does not cure the prohibition.

  70. Question 70Conflicts of Interest

    Which statement correctly describes a lawyer's obligations when a new representation is adverse to a former client?

    1. The lawyer may represent the new client in any matter as long as no confidential information of the former client is actually used in the new matter.
    2. The lawyer may not take a position materially adverse to the former client in a substantially related matter without the former client's informed consent in writing. Correct answer.
    3. The lawyer may take a position adverse to the former client in a different judicial district without obtaining consent.
    4. The lawyer's duty to avoid conflicts of interest ends when the former representation is concluded and the file is returned.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.9(a) bars a lawyer from representing a new client in the same or a substantially related matter where the new client's interests are materially adverse to the former client, unless the former client gives informed consent confirmed in writing. Rule 1.9(c) separately protects the former client's confidential information.

  71. Question 71Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer represents a client in a widely publicized case. With respect to the client's story, the lawyer may:

    1. acquire media rights during the representation if the client is independently represented by separate counsel in the transaction.
    2. negotiate an agreement giving the lawyer book rights before the representation concludes, provided the client consents in writing.
    3. purchase the client's story rights after the representation ends, but only with the approval of the tribunal.
    4. not negotiate or make an agreement giving the lawyer media rights based on the representation until the representation has concluded. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(d) prohibits a lawyer from negotiating or making an agreement giving the lawyer media rights based on the representation before the representation concludes. After the representation ends, the lawyer may negotiate such an agreement, subject to other rules such as those on confidential information.

  72. Question 72Conflicts of Interest

    When a lawyer in a firm is personally disqualified from a representation because of a conflict of interest, the other lawyers in the firm:

    1. may never represent the client in any matter, at any time.
    2. are generally also disqualified, subject to the screening and other exceptions set out in Rule 1.10. Correct answer.
    3. may proceed with the representation if the disqualified lawyer has never met the client.
    4. may proceed with the representation if the disqualified lawyer receives no part of the fee.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.10(a) provides that while lawyers are associated in a firm, none of them may knowingly represent a client when any one of them practicing alone would be prohibited from doing so by Rules 1.7 or 1.9. The rule then sets out limited exceptions, including the screening option for lawyers who move between firms.

  73. Question 73Conflicts of Interest

    A firm hires a lawyer who is personally disqualified under Rule 1.9 from a matter because of work she did at her prior firm. Under Model Rule 1.10(a)(2), the new firm:

    1. may represent the client if the disqualified lawyer is paid a fixed salary rather than a share of the firm's fees.
    2. may represent the client only if the affected former client consents in writing to the new firm's representation.
    3. may represent the client if the disqualified lawyer is timely screened and written notice is promptly given to any affected former client. Correct answer.
    4. may never represent the client, because conflicts under Rule 1.9 are imputed without exception.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.10(a)(2) permits a firm to avoid imputation of a Rule 1.9 conflict arising from a lawyer's move between firms if the personally disqualified lawyer is timely screened from the matter and written notice is promptly given to any affected former client. The firm must also comply with the certification provisions of the rule.

  74. Question 74Conflicts of Interest

    A former government lawyer now in private practice wants to represent a private client in a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially while in government service. When may the lawyer do so?

    1. When the matter involves state rather than federal government service.
    2. When the appropriate government agency gives informed consent, confirmed in writing. Correct answer.
    3. When the lawyer's firm screens the lawyer from the matter and gives notice to the government agency.
    4. When at least one year has passed since the lawyer left government service.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.11(a) provides that a lawyer who has formerly served as a public officer or employee shall not represent a private client in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially, unless the appropriate government agency gives informed consent confirmed in writing. Screening under Rule 1.11(b) addresses the firm's representation, not the personally disqualified lawyer's own.

  75. Question 75Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer who formerly served as a judge may not represent anyone in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially as a judge, unless:

    1. the lawyer's former court approves the representation by written order.
    2. the representation begins more than two years after the lawyer left the bench.
    3. all parties to the proceeding give informed consent, confirmed in writing. Correct answer.
    4. no party to the proceeding is a current client of the lawyer's firm.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.12(a) disqualifies a lawyer from representing anyone in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially as a judge, arbitrator, mediator, or court-appointed neutral, unless all parties to the proceeding give informed consent confirmed in writing. Rule 1.12(c) allows screening to avoid imputation to the lawyer's firm.

  76. Question 76Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer represents several clients in a single matter and receives one lump-sum settlement offer covering all of them. Before the settlement may be accepted, the lawyer must:

    1. allocate the settlement proceeds equally among the clients unless the clients agree otherwise in writing.
    2. obtain the consent of a majority of the clients and disclose the allocation to the dissenting clients.
    3. disclose all settlement terms and the other clients' claims to each client, and obtain each client's informed consent in writing. Correct answer.
    4. obtain the approval of the tribunal for the proposed allocation of the settlement proceeds before presenting the offer to any client.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(g) governs aggregate settlements and requires the lawyer to disclose to each client all the terms of the agreement and the existence and nature of all claims involved, and to obtain each client's informed consent in writing. Majority rule and equal division are not substitutes for each client's informed consent.

  77. Question 77Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer may settle a malpractice claim with a client who is not independently represented by another lawyer only if:

    1. the settlement amount exceeds the client's actual out-of-pocket damages.
    2. the claim arises out of a matter that has already concluded.
    3. the client is advised in writing to seek independent counsel and is given a reasonable opportunity to do so. Correct answer.
    4. the lawyer's malpractice insurer approves the settlement in writing.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(h)(2) prohibits a lawyer from settling a malpractice or other claim with an unrepresented client or former client unless the person is advised in writing to seek independent counsel and is given a reasonable opportunity to do so. Rule 1.8(h)(1) separately bars prospective limits on liability absent independent representation and informed consent.

  78. Question 78Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer agrees to represent a client whose legal fees will be paid by the client's employer. Which condition does Model Rule 1.8(f) impose?

    1. The client gives informed consent, the payor does not interfere with the lawyer's independent judgment, and client information is protected. Correct answer.
    2. The payor must be a party to the same matter so that the fee arrangement is disclosed on the record.
    3. The payor must agree to indemnify the lawyer against any future malpractice claim by the client.
    4. The lawyer's fee must be capped at the payor's published rate schedule for outside counsel.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(f) permits a lawyer to accept compensation from someone other than the client only if the client gives informed consent, there is no interference with the lawyer's independent professional judgment, and information relating to the representation is protected as Rule 1.6 requires. The payor's identity and rate schedules are not the governing conditions.

  79. Question 79Conflicts of Interest

    A person consults a lawyer about a possible claim, does not hire the lawyer, but reveals significant information during the consultation. The lawyer may later represent the opposing party:

    1. only if the first person consents in writing, regardless of what was disclosed or how much harm the new representation would cause.
    2. in any matter, provided the lawyer takes care not to use any of the disclosed information to the first person's disadvantage.
    3. only if the information could not be significantly harmful to the first person, or the affected persons consent in writing. Correct answer.
    4. in any matter, because no attorney-client relationship was ever formed with the first person.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.18 protects prospective clients. A lawyer who received information from a prospective client may not represent a client with materially adverse interests in the same or a substantially related matter if the lawyer received information that could be significantly harmful to the prospective client, unless both affected persons give informed consent confirmed in writing.

  80. Question 80Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer may testify as a witness at the trial of a client's case when:

    1. the lawyer's testimony is expected to be favorable to the client's position.
    2. the client consents in writing after disclosure of the risks of the dual role.
    3. the testimony relates to the value of the lawyer's services in the matter. Correct answer.
    4. the lawyer will testify only on cross-examination rather than direct examination.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.7(a) bars a lawyer from acting as advocate at a trial in which the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness, subject to exceptions for uncontested issues, testimony about the value of the lawyer's services, and cases where disqualification would work a substantial hardship. Client consent does not override the rule.

  81. Question 81Conflicts of Interest

    A client asks a law firm to agree in advance that the firm may later represent parties adverse to the client in unrelated matters. Under the Model Rules, such an advance waiver is:

    1. permissible if the client gives informed consent and reasonably understands the material risks of the arrangement. Correct answer.
    2. void, because a client cannot waive a conflict of interest that has not yet arisen at the time of the waiver.
    3. valid only if it is limited to a single, identified lawsuit that has already been filed in court.
    4. effective only if the firm is a solo practice in which the client deals with one lawyer.

    Explanation

    The comments to Rule 1.7 recognize that a client may consent in advance to future conflicts, including future adversity in unrelated matters, if the client gives informed consent. Open-ended advance waivers are generally ineffective, and the effectiveness of any advance consent depends on the client's sophistication and understanding of the material risks.

  82. Question 82Conflicts of Interest

    Which of the following conflicts of interest may the affected clients not validly consent to?

    1. Representation of one client in asserting a claim against another client in the same litigation before a tribunal. Correct answer.
    2. Representation of two co-defendants in a criminal case whose defenses are consistent and neither of whom will testify against the other.
    3. Representation of a client in a matter to which the lawyer's former client gives informed consent in writing.
    4. Representation of two clients in unrelated matters where one is a plaintiff and the other is merely a witness.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.7(b)(3) makes a conflict nonconsentable when the representation involves the assertion of a claim by one client against another client represented by the lawyer in the same litigation or other proceeding before a tribunal. Other concurrent conflicts are consentable if the lawyer reasonably believes competent and diligent representation is possible.

  83. Question 83Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer who sells her law practice must:

    1. charge the buyer no more than the fair market value of the physical files, furniture, and office equipment being transferred.
    2. give each client written notice of the sale, including the client's right to retain other counsel or take possession of the file. Correct answer.
    3. obtain the approval of the local bar association before the transfer becomes effective.
    4. retain no copies of any client files after the sale has been completed.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.17 permits the sale of a law practice only if, among other things, the seller gives each client written notice of the sale, the proposed new lawyer, and the client's right to retain other counsel or take possession of the file. The fees charged to clients may not be increased because of the sale.

  84. Question 84Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer may use information relating to the representation of a client to the client's disadvantage only if:

    1. the client gives informed consent, or the use is permitted or required by the Rules. Correct answer.
    2. the lawyer's firm has no ongoing business relationship with the client.
    3. the disclosure is limited to other lawyers employed in the same firm.
    4. the information has become a matter of public record since the representation began.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(b) prohibits a lawyer from using information relating to the representation of a client to the client's disadvantage unless the client gives informed consent, except as permitted or required by the Rules. Disclosure within the firm is not a cure; the protection attaches to the information itself.

  85. Question 85Conflicts of Interest

    An insurer retains a lawyer to defend its insured under a reservation of rights that asserts a coverage position adverse to the insured on the very claim being defended. The lawyer should:

    1. defend the insured while reporting all information learned in the defense to the insurer, because the insurer pays the fee.
    2. treat the conflict as one requiring the insured's informed consent, and if consent cannot be obtained, decline or withdraw. Correct answer.
    3. accept the matter without further action, since the reservation of rights eliminates any conflict of interest.
    4. represent the insurer's coverage position and the insured's defense simultaneously, treating both as co-clients in the matter.

    Explanation

    When a reservation of rights creates a significant risk that the lawyer's representation of the insured will be materially limited by the insurer's interests, a concurrent conflict exists under Rule 1.7(a)(2). The insured must give informed consent, and if the conflict is nonconsentable or consent is refused, the lawyer must decline or withdraw rather than favor the payor.

  86. Question 86Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer represents two co-defendants in a criminal case. Before trial, the prosecutor offers one defendant a favorable plea that requires him to testify against the other. The lawyer must:

    1. advise the favored client to reject the plea offer so that the joint representation may continue to trial.
    2. continue the joint representation if both clients reaffirm their consent in writing after full disclosure of the new conflict.
    3. withdraw from representing at least one client, since loyalty to one would be at the other's expense. Correct answer.
    4. negotiate a similar offer for the second client before discussing the plea with either client.

    Explanation

    Joint representation of co-defendants is a concurrent conflict, and it becomes nonconsentable when the lawyer would have to contend for one client's interests at the expense of the other, as with a plea that requires testimony against the co-defendant. The lawyer must withdraw from representing at least one client rather than favor one over the other.

  87. Question 87Conflicts of Interest

    A firm represents Client A in a matter and is then asked to represent Client B in a substantially related matter adverse to Client A. The firm withdraws from representing Client A and accepts Client B. How should the firm's conduct be assessed?

    1. It acted properly, because Client A is now a former client and only the Rule 1.9 standard applies to the matter.
    2. It acted properly, because Client A suffered no measurable financial prejudice as a result of the firm's decision to withdraw in the middle of the matter.
    3. It acted properly if the firm returns Client A's entire fee for the matter.
    4. It probably violated its duty of loyalty to Client A by dropping the client to avoid the concurrent conflict. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A firm may not abandon a current client in order to convert a concurrent conflict into a former-client conflict, a practice often described as dropping the client like a hot potato. The duty of loyalty to a current client prevents the firm from ending the representation so that it can take on a more desirable adverse matter.

  88. Question 88Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer represents a corporation in a derivative suit brought by a minority shareholder against the board. The corporation's CEO asks the lawyer for personal advice about her own exposure in the suit. The lawyer should:

    1. decline personal advice, explain that the lawyer represents the corporation, and refer the CEO to independent counsel. Correct answer.
    2. advise the CEO personally, because the corporation's board has authorized the lawyer to do so.
    3. advise the CEO as a co-client, because her interests and the corporation's interests are aligned in defending the suit.
    4. resign from representing the corporation in the derivative suit and represent the CEO alone.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 1.13 the lawyer represents the organization, not its directors, officers, or shareholders, and when the organization's interests appear adverse to those of a constituent the lawyer must explain the identity of the client. The CEO should be told to obtain her own counsel.

  89. Question 89Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer representing a plaintiff in a personal injury case may acquire a proprietary interest in the client's cause of action:

    1. only to the extent of a lien granted by law to secure the lawyer's fee or expenses. Correct answer.
    2. whenever the client consents in writing after disclosure of the risks of the arrangement.
    3. only if the lawyer also agrees to advance all litigation costs in the matter.
    4. only in a contingent-fee case, because a percentage fee is itself a form of ownership.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(i) prohibits a lawyer from acquiring a proprietary interest in the cause of action or subject matter of litigation the lawyer is conducting for a client. The rule recognizes two exceptions: a lien granted by law to secure the lawyer's fee or expenses, and contracts for a reasonable contingent fee.

  90. Question 90Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer wants to lend a client $40,000 and take a second mortgage on the client's house to secure repayment, at an interest rate above the market rate. Under the Model Rules, the lawyer may enter into this transaction with the client only if:

    1. an independent lawyer reviews the loan documents on the client's behalf and approves the transaction in writing.
    2. the client's accountant certifies in writing that the interest rate does not exceed the maximum rate permitted under state usury law.
    3. the terms are fair to the client and she consents in writing after being urged to get independent advice. Correct answer.
    4. the lawyer discloses all of the terms in a signed writing and gives the client a reasonable chance to review the documents before signing.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(a) allows a lawyer to enter a business transaction with a client only when the terms are fair and fully disclosed in writing, the client is advised in writing of the desirability of seeking independent counsel and given a reasonable opportunity to do so, and the client gives written informed consent to the essential terms and the lawyer's role. Because a mortgage securing the lawyer's own loan is a business transaction, every element must be satisfied.

  91. Question 91Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer's client, who has no close relatives, tells the lawyer that he intends to leave the lawyer a substantial share of his estate and asks the lawyer to draft the will. Under the Model Rules, the lawyer may:

    1. not draft the will, unless the lawyer is related to the client. Correct answer.
    2. draft the will if the client separately confirms the bequest in a signed letter.
    3. draft the will, because the client is free to dispose of his property as he wishes.
    4. draft the will only if a second lawyer reviews the bequest before the client signs.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 1.8(c), a lawyer may not solicit a substantial gift from a client, including a testamentary gift, and may not prepare an instrument giving the lawyer a substantial gift unless the client is a relative of the lawyer. The lawyer may refer the client to independent counsel who can prepare the instrument.

  92. Question 92Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer represents an indigent client in a personal injury action. The client cannot pay rent while the case is pending, and the lawyer also wants to cover the filing fee and the cost of a medical expert. Under the Model Rules, the lawyer may:

    1. advance the litigation expenses only if the client agrees to repay them regardless of the outcome of the case.
    2. lend money for living expenses and advance the litigation expenses, if the client promises to repay both from any recovery.
    3. make the loan for living expenses if the amount is modest, no interest is charged, and the client signs a note.
    4. advance the litigation expenses, contingent on recovery, but not lend money for living expenses. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.8(e) permits a lawyer to advance court costs and litigation expenses, with repayment contingent on the outcome of the matter, and to pay such costs on behalf of an indigent client. The rule does not permit the lawyer to lend the client money for living expenses while the case is pending.

  93. Question 93Conflicts of Interest

    A lawyer representing a plaintiff in a contract dispute begins negotiating for a job with the law firm that represents the defendant. Under the Model Rules, which statement is correct?

    1. The lawyer has a conflict of interest that requires the client's informed consent before she continues. Correct answer.
    2. The lawyer must withdraw from the case because this conflict is not one that a client may validly consent to.
    3. The lawyer has no conflict of interest unless and until she actually accepts an offer of employment from the opposing firm.
    4. The lawyer may continue the representation if she personally believes the job discussions will not affect her handling of the case.

    Explanation

    A lawyer's own interest in obtaining a position with opposing counsel can materially limit her representation, creating a concurrent conflict under Rule 1.7(a)(2). Such a conflict is generally consentable, so the lawyer may continue only if she reasonably believes she can represent the client competently and diligently and the client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing.

  94. Question 94Conflicts of Interest

    For three years, a firm has represented a manufacturer in defending products-liability claims. Another company now asks the firm to bring a large trade-secrets suit against that manufacturer and would pay the firm far more than the manufacturer does. The firm would prefer to take the new client. Under the Model Rules, the firm:

    1. may terminate the manufacturer's representation and then accept the new case, since the manufacturer would then be a former client.
    2. may withdraw from the manufacturer's representation on reasonable notice, because the manufacturer has suffered no prejudice.
    3. may accept the new case if the firm screens every lawyer who worked on the manufacturer's matters from the new matter.
    4. may not take the adverse case without the manufacturer's consent, and may not withdraw to cure the conflict. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    While the manufacturer remains a client, a suit against it is a concurrent conflict under Rule 1.7 that requires the informed consent of both clients. A firm may not drop an existing client for the purpose of converting the concurrent conflict into a former-client conflict and thereby escape Rule 1.7.

  95. Question 95Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    Under the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct, what does the duty of competence require of a lawyer handling a client matter?

    1. At least ten years of practice in the relevant field before accepting the matter.
    2. Legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. Correct answer.
    3. A guarantee that the representation will produce a favorable result for the client.
    4. Complete mastery of every legal specialty that the client's matter could arguably involve.

    Explanation

    Model Rule 1.1 requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. The standard is one of reasonable competence, not perfection or expertise in every field. A lawyer does not guarantee outcomes and need not have a fixed number of years in practice.

  96. Question 96Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    Which of the following best describes how a lawyer satisfies the duty to maintain competence over the course of a career?

    1. By accepting only matters that are identical to ones the lawyer has already handled.
    2. By keeping current in the relevant law and practice. Correct answer.
    3. By delegating all substantive legal research to nonlawyer assistants.
    4. By relying on the legal knowledge acquired in law school for the rest of the lawyer's career.

    Explanation

    A lawyer must keep abreast of changes in the law and its practice, including through continuing legal education. Competence is a continuing obligation, not a credential acquired once. Neither law school training nor delegation relieves the lawyer of this duty.

  97. Question 97Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer is asked to handle a matter in a field in which the lawyer has no experience. What does the Model Rules approach permit?

    1. Accept the matter and learn the necessary law only after the representation has concluded.
    2. Accept the matter and disclose the lack of experience, which alone satisfies the duty.
    3. Decline every matter outside the lawyer's existing practice area because competence is fixed at admission.
    4. Accept the matter after reasonable study, or associate a competent lawyer. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may accept representation in an unfamiliar field if the lawyer can become competent through reasonable study and preparation, or by associating or consulting with a lawyer who has the necessary skill. Disclosure of inexperience does not by itself discharge the duty of competence.

  98. Question 98Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer is the only attorney available when a client faces an immediate deadline in an unfamiliar area of law, and there is no practical opportunity to consult or refer. What may the lawyer properly do?

    1. Give any assistance needed, because emergencies suspend the duty of competence entirely.
    2. Give assistance only after obtaining the client's written waiver of all malpractice claims.
    3. Give limited assistance in an emergency when referral or consultation is impractical. Correct answer.
    4. Give assistance only if the lawyer has handled at least one similar matter before.

    Explanation

    The comments to Rule 1.1 recognize that in an emergency a lawyer may give advice or assistance in a matter requiring greater skill than the lawyer has, where referral or consultation would be impractical. Even then, the assistance should be limited to what is reasonably necessary in the circumstances. A malpractice waiver is not the mechanism the rule contemplates.

  99. Question 99Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A former client sues the lawyer for legal malpractice. Which elements must the client ordinarily prove?

    1. Breach and damages, because an attorney-client relationship always establishes the duty.
    2. Duty, breach, and nominal damages, without proof of causation.
    3. An ethical rule violation alone, because a rule violation automatically creates civil liability.
    4. Duty, breach, causation, and actual damages. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A legal malpractice claim requires proof of the duty owed, a breach of that duty, causation of the harm, and actual damages. Ethical rule violations do not automatically create a civil cause of action for malpractice. The client must connect the lawyer's conduct to a concrete loss.

  100. Question 100Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer's conduct causes losses to a person who never retained the lawyer. What is the general rule governing the lawyer's duty to that person?

    1. A duty is owed to every person who might be affected by the representation.
    2. No duty is owed to a non-client unless an exception applies. Correct answer.
    3. A duty is owed to any person who learns of the lawyer's advice and relies on it.
    4. A duty is owed to the opposing party in every litigated matter.

    Explanation

    As a general rule, a lawyer owes duties to clients, not to third parties, and third-party liability arises only under recognized exceptions. Exceptions include intended beneficiaries of a client's estate plan, persons the lawyer invites to rely on the lawyer's work, and certain fraud or misrepresentation situations. Foreseeability alone does not create a duty.

  101. Question 101Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer with no background in employee benefits law agrees to represent a client in a benefits dispute, planning to research the governing statute and to consult an experienced benefits lawyer. The client understands the lawyer's background. Is the lawyer's acceptance proper?

    1. No, because a lawyer may never accept a matter in an unfamiliar field.
    2. No, unless the lawyer has practiced in the field for at least five years.
    3. Yes, if the lawyer studies and consults as reasonably necessary. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, because the client's consent cures any lack of competence.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.1 permits a lawyer to take on a matter in an unfamiliar area if the lawyer can achieve the necessary competence through reasonable study and preparation or through association with a competent lawyer. Client consent does not substitute for competence. The question is whether the lawyer actually obtains the needed skill.

  102. Question 102Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    Midway through litigation, a lawyer's severe, untreated depression materially impairs the lawyer's ability to represent the client effectively. The client wants the lawyer to continue. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Delegate the matter entirely to a nonlawyer assistant.
    2. Continue the representation if the client consents after disclosure.
    3. Withdraw from the representation. Correct answer.
    4. Continue the representation but disclose the condition to the court.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.16(a)(2) requires a lawyer to withdraw if a physical or mental condition materially impairs the lawyer's ability to represent the client. The client's consent does not override this requirement. Delegation to a nonlawyer would also violate the rules on supervision and the unauthorized practice of law.

  103. Question 103Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    In a legal malpractice trial, the client alleges that the lawyer negligently failed to conduct discovery. What is the general rule about expert testimony on the standard of care?

    1. Expert testimony is never required because jurors know the legal standard of care.
    2. Expert testimony is unnecessary because the Model Rules set the civil standard of care.
    3. Expert testimony is required in every malpractice case, without any exception.
    4. Expert testimony is generally required unless the negligence is obvious. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    In most jurisdictions the plaintiff must present expert testimony to establish the professional standard of care and the lawyer's breach of it. The exception applies where the negligence is so clear that a layperson can recognize it without expert help. The Model Rules provide ethical standards but do not themselves define the civil standard of care.

  104. Question 104Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A client claims that a lawyer's negligent handling of a personal injury case forced a settlement for less than the case was worth. What must the client establish about the underlying case to recover?

    1. That the lawyer made an error of judgment in handling the matter.
    2. That the lawyer charged an unreasonable fee for the representation.
    3. That the client is dissatisfied with the outcome of the underlying matter.
    4. That the client would have obtained a better result but for the lawyer's negligence. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    This is the "case within a case" requirement: the client must show that, but for the lawyer's negligence, the client would have fared better in the underlying matter. Dissatisfaction with the outcome is not enough, and an error of judgment is not negligence unless it falls below the standard of care. The remedy aims to put the client where the client would have been absent the negligence.

  105. Question 105Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer missed a filing deadline, but the court granted an extension and the client's case proceeded with no adverse consequence. The client sues for malpractice, citing worry about the missed deadline. What is the likely result?

    1. The claim succeeds, because emotional distress alone is a recoverable injury.
    2. The claim succeeds, because any missed deadline is malpractice per se.
    3. The claim succeeds, because the lawyer violated a rule of professional conduct.
    4. The claim fails, because the client suffered no actual injury; speculative harm is insufficient. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Malpractice requires actual injury caused by the lawyer's breach. Where the court cured the missed deadline and the client lost nothing, the harm is speculative and the claim cannot succeed. A rule violation or a bare risk of harm does not by itself establish damages.

  106. Question 106Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A firm's paralegal negligently miscalendars a dispositive filing deadline, and the client's claim is dismissed as a result. Who bears responsibility for the missed deadline?

    1. The lawyer is liable only if the client personally hired the assistant.
    2. The lawyer is not liable because nonlawyers are independent contractors as a matter of law.
    3. The lawyer is responsible for the assistant's work and may be liable for the missed deadline. Correct answer.
    4. The lawyer is liable only if the assistant was directly supervised at the moment of the error.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.3 makes a lawyer responsible for the conduct of nonlawyer assistants, and general agency principles make the lawyer answerable for staff negligence in handling client matters. Constant direct supervision is not required, but the lawyer must take reasonable steps to ensure the assistant's conduct is compatible with the lawyer's obligations. The duty runs to the client regardless of who hired the assistant.

  107. Question 107Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer drafts a will that fails because the lawyer negligently omitted the required attestation, and the testator's intended beneficiary loses the bequest. May the beneficiary recover from the lawyer?

    1. No, because only the testator's estate may sue for drafting errors.
    2. No, because the beneficiary was not the lawyer's client and lacked privity.
    3. The intended beneficiary may recover for the loss the testator intended to prevent. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, but only for nominal damages because the beneficiary had no contract with the lawyer.

    Explanation

    Most jurisdictions recognize an exception to the privity rule for intended beneficiaries of an estate plan, because the client's purpose is to benefit them and they are the only parties who can be harmed by defective drafting. Allowing recovery prevents the negligent lawyer from escaping liability entirely. Nominal damages would not reflect the actual loss of the intended bequest.

  108. Question 108Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer for a borrower prepares an opinion letter for a lender, knowing the lender will rely on it to make a loan. The lawyer negligently overstates the borrower's authority, and the lender loses money. What is the likely result?

    1. The lender may not recover because opinion letters are not legal advice.
    2. The lender may not recover because no attorney-client relationship existed.
    3. The lender may recover because the lawyer invited the lender's reliance. Correct answer.
    4. The lender may recover only if the borrower also brings a malpractice claim against the lawyer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer who gives an opinion or other professional information to a third party for the third party's guidance, knowing that it will be relied upon, owes that party a duty of reasonable care. The absence of an attorney-client relationship therefore does not defeat the claim. This is the invited-reliance exception to the general no-duty rule.

  109. Question 109Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer representing a seller negligently misstates the zoning status of property during negotiations with an unrepresented buyer. The buyer relies on the statement and loses money. What is the likely result in the buyer's suit against the lawyer?

    1. The buyer may recover because any negligent statement creates a duty to everyone who hears it.
    2. The buyer likely cannot recover, because the lawyer owed no duty to an adverse party. Correct answer.
    3. The buyer may recover if the statement was made in writing and signed by the lawyer.
    4. The buyer may recover because lawyers owe a duty to third parties in all commercial transactions.

    Explanation

    An opposing party in an arm's-length negotiation ordinarily cannot sue the adversary's lawyer for negligence, because the lawyer owes no duty to the adverse party and reliance on the adversary's position is not reasonable. Exceptions may arise for fraud or for invited reliance, neither of which is present here. Writing and signature do not create a duty that does not otherwise exist.

  110. Question 110Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    In a legal malpractice action, when does the statute of limitations generally begin to run under the discovery rule?

    1. The limitations period begins on the date the lawyer is admitted to practice.
    2. The limitations period generally begins when the client knows or should know of the injury. Correct answer.
    3. The limitations period begins when the lawyer withdraws, regardless of when the client learns of the injury.
    4. The limitations period begins when the lawyer's malpractice insurance policy is renewed.

    Explanation

    Under the discovery rule, the limitations period generally starts when the client knows or reasonably should know of the injury and its cause. Some jurisdictions also apply a continuing-representation rule that postpones accrual until the representation ends. Neither admission to practice nor insurance renewal has any bearing on accrual.

  111. Question 111Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer represents a corporation in a merger. A supplier of the corporation loses business after the merger and sues the lawyer, alleging that the transaction was negligently structured. May the supplier recover?

    1. Yes, because every person foreseeably harmed by a lawyer's negligence may sue.
    2. No, because the supplier was an incidental beneficiary of the representation. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, because the supplier's losses were a foreseeable result of the merger.
    4. No, because only shareholders of a corporate client may ever sue the lawyer.

    Explanation

    Third-party recovery requires more than foreseeable harm; the third party must be an intended beneficiary of the representation or must have been invited to rely on the lawyer's work. A supplier who merely loses business because of a client's transaction is an incidental beneficiary. Foreseeability alone does not create a lawyer's duty to a non-client.

  112. Question 112Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer's negligent delay in a matter ultimately caused the client no out-of-pocket loss, but the client suffered anxiety and lost sleep. The client sues for legal malpractice seeking emotional distress damages. What is the likely result?

    1. The client likely cannot recover, because emotional distress damages generally require tangible harm. Correct answer.
    2. The client may recover because emotional distress is always available in malpractice actions.
    3. The client may recover because emotional distress is presumed from any breach of duty.
    4. The client may recover because a rule violation establishes at least nominal emotional distress damages.

    Explanation

    Damages in legal malpractice are generally limited to actual pecuniary loss, and emotional distress damages ordinarily require accompanying tangible harm or other recognized grounds. A breach of duty without provable loss does not support a damages award. This rule prevents speculative claims untethered from economic injury.

  113. Question 113Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer breaches a fiduciary duty to a client by using confidential information for the lawyer's own benefit, but the client cannot prove any monetary loss. The lawyer collected a substantial fee. What remedy remains available to the client?

    1. The client may recover only the portion of the fee attributable to the misconduct, because forfeiture is unavailable.
    2. The client may recover only if the lawyer's conduct also constituted a crime.
    3. The client may not recover anything without proof of actual damages from the breach.
    4. The client may seek forfeiture of the fee as a remedy for the breach of fiduciary duty. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Fee forfeiture or disgorgement is an equitable remedy for breach of fiduciary duty and does not depend on proof of actual damages. It prevents a lawyer from profiting from disloyal conduct. A malpractice claim may fail for lack of provable loss while a forfeiture claim still succeeds.

  114. Question 114Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

    A lawyer retains an outside attorney to handle a specialized portion of a client's matter and does so negligently, choosing counsel with no experience in the field despite readily available information showing the lack of qualifications. The client is harmed. What is the referring lawyer's liability?

    1. The referring lawyer is liable only if the client paid the associated lawyer directly rather than through the referring firm.
    2. The referring lawyer may be liable for failing to use reasonable care in selecting the associated lawyer. Correct answer.
    3. The referring lawyer is never liable, because only the associated lawyer actually handled the client's matter.
    4. The referring lawyer is liable only if there was a written co-counsel agreement with the associated lawyer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer who associates outside counsel remains responsible to the client for exercising reasonable care in the selection and retention of that counsel. Negligent selection or failure to monitor can support liability even though the associated lawyer performed the work. The form of payment and the existence of a written agreement do not determine the duty.

  115. Question 115Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer is preparing to file a civil complaint. The lawyer believes the client's factual account, but knows that a controlling appellate decision in the jurisdiction squarely forecloses the legal theory on which the claim depends. The client insists the decision was wrongly decided and wants to challenge it. What should the lawyer do?

    1. Decline to file, because any claim foreclosed by controlling precedent is frivolous and must be rejected.
    2. File the claim but omit any reference to the adverse controlling precedent in the complaint and briefs.
    3. File the claim only after the client agrees in writing to pay the opposing party's attorney's fees if the claim fails.
    4. File the claim and argue that the precedent should be overruled. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 3.1, a lawyer may bring a claim that is not frivolous, and a good-faith argument for an extension, modification, or reversal of existing law satisfies that standard. Adverse controlling precedent does not by itself render a claim frivolous.

  116. Question 116Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer representing a defendant in a highly publicized assault case gives a reporter the defendant's prior criminal record, which is not part of any public court file. The lawyer knows the disclosure will create a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing the upcoming trial. How should the lawyer's conduct be evaluated?

    1. It is improper only if a gag order has already been entered in the case.
    2. It is improper because it creates a substantial likelihood of material prejudice. Correct answer.
    3. It is proper because the information is truthful and the lawyer expressed no opinion about guilt.
    4. It is proper because pretrial publicity restrictions apply only to prosecutors, not to defense counsel.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.6(a) bars a lawyer participating in a matter from making extrajudicial statements that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know will be disseminated and will create a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing an adjudicative proceeding. Truthfulness alone does not bring a statement within the safe harbor of Rule 3.6(b).

  117. Question 117Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer at a large firm is handling a contract dispute. The lawyer is the only person who can testify about a contested conversation with the opposing party concerning the contract's terms, and another lawyer at the firm is available to try the case. What does Rule 3.7 permit?

    1. The lawyer may serve as trial advocate if she presents her testimony before the trial begins.
    2. The lawyer may testify but may not serve as trial advocate at the trial. Correct answer.
    3. The firm must withdraw from the representation entirely, because one lawyer's testimony taints the whole firm.
    4. The lawyer may both testify and serve as trial advocate if the client consents after full disclosure.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.7(a) bars a lawyer from acting as advocate at a trial in which the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness unless the testimony is uncontested, concerns the value of legal services, or disqualification would work substantial hardship. None of those exceptions applies here, but Rule 3.7(b) allows another lawyer in the firm to try the case.

  118. Question 118Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer wants a reluctant eyewitness to testify in a personal injury trial. The lawyer offers to pay the witness $500 for each day of testimony, with payment due only if the plaintiff wins the case. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. The offer is proper if the witness is compensated only for lost wages.
    2. The offer is proper if it is disclosed to opposing counsel before trial.
    3. The offer is proper if the court approves the amount as reasonable.
    4. The offer is improper because contingent witness fees are barred. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.4(b) prohibits offering an inducement to a witness that is prohibited by law, and Rule 3.4 cmt. [3] explains that paying a witness a fee contingent on the content of testimony or the outcome of the case is improper. A witness may be paid reasonable, noncontingent compensation for time and expenses.

  119. Question 119Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    In a civil trial, defense counsel knows that a witness's statement about the timing of a delivery is false, yet counsel repeats it in the opening statement and questions witnesses as though it were true. What is the lawyer's duty?

    1. The lawyer need only correct the statement if the opposing party lodges an objection.
    2. The lawyer must withdraw from the representation without further explanation to anyone.
    3. The lawyer may rely on the statement because it originated with a witness rather than with counsel.
    4. The lawyer must correct the false statement of material fact to the tribunal. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(a)(1) forbids a lawyer from knowingly making a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal and from failing to correct a false statement of material fact or law the lawyer previously made. The duty is affirmative and does not depend on the adversary's objection.

  120. Question 120Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A prosecutor learns before trial that a police laboratory report, favorable to the accused, was never turned over to the defense. The evidence is material to guilt. What must the prosecutor do?

    1. Disclose the evidence only if the court orders it after an in camera review.
    2. Wait until the defense files a discovery motion before disclosing.
    3. Disclose the evidence to the defense promptly. Correct answer.
    4. Nothing, because the defense can request the material by subpoena.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.8(d) requires a prosecutor to make timely disclosure to the defense of all evidence or information known to the prosecutor that tends to negate guilt or mitigate the offense. The duty is affirmative and does not await a defense request or a court order.

  121. Question 121Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    Frustrated by an adverse ruling, a lawyer continues to argue loudly after the judge has ruled, ignores the judge's instruction to be seated, and repeatedly interrupts opposing counsel. This conduct is:

    1. Prohibited only if the conduct occurs in the presence of the jury.
    2. Permissible, because the ruling is preserved for appeal regardless of the lawyer's behavior.
    3. Permissible, because a lawyer must zealously advocate for the client at every stage.
    4. Prohibited, because a lawyer may not engage in conduct intended to disrupt the tribunal. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.5(d) prohibits a lawyer from engaging in conduct intended to disrupt a tribunal. Zealous advocacy does not license ignoring a court's directives or interfering with the proceedings.

  122. Question 122Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer's brief argues that a statute is unenforceable but omits a controlling state supreme court decision squarely rejecting that argument, which the lawyer found through research. Opposing counsel has not cited the decision. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. No disclosure is required because the adversary system leaves legal research to opposing counsel.
    2. Disclosure is required only if the client consents to revealing the adverse authority.
    3. The lawyer must disclose the controlling adverse authority to the tribunal. Correct answer.
    4. Disclosure is required only if the court specifically asks about contrary authority.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(a)(2) requires a lawyer to disclose to the tribunal controlling legal authority in the jurisdiction that the lawyer knows is directly adverse to the client's position and that opposing counsel has not disclosed. The duty applies even though disclosing the authority hurts the client's position.

  123. Question 123Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer reasonably believes, but does not know, that a criminal defendant client intends to testify falsely. The client insists on testifying. What is the lawyer's obligation under Rule 3.3?

    1. Withdraw from the representation automatically, without seeking leave of the court.
    2. Present the client's testimony, because a lawyer may not refuse to offer a criminal defendant's testimony on this basis. Correct answer.
    3. Refuse to call the client, because a lawyer may never offer evidence the lawyer believes to be false.
    4. Disclose the lawyer's belief to the judge before the client takes the stand.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(a)(3) allows a lawyer to refuse to offer evidence the lawyer reasonably believes is false, but expressly excepts the testimony of a defendant in a criminal matter. Because the protection for criminal defendants is preserved, a lawyer who merely believes - but does not know - the testimony is false must honor the client's decision to testify.

  124. Question 124Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer learns that a corporate client has been destroying emails relevant to a pending lawsuit and asks the lawyer whether the practice may continue. What does Rule 3.4 require?

    1. The lawyer may permit the destruction to continue if the client instructs it.
    2. The lawyer must withdraw from the case and report the client to the disciplinary authorities.
    3. The lawyer may continue in the case as long as the lawyer personally never touches the emails.
    4. The lawyer must not counsel or assist the client in destroying the emails. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.4(a) prohibits a lawyer from unlawfully obstructing another party's access to evidence or unlawfully altering, destroying, or concealing material having potential evidentiary value. Counseling or assisting a client in destroying relevant documents violates that prohibition.

  125. Question 125Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A prosecutor is asked about a pending criminal case by a reporter. Which statement is permitted under Rule 3.6?

    1. The defendant is obviously guilty and the jury will see through his fabricated story.
    2. The defendant confessed to the crime and has a long history of violence against strangers.
    3. The defendant has been charged with armed robbery and will be arraigned tomorrow morning. Correct answer.
    4. The defendant's prior convictions demonstrate that he is the person who committed this crime.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.6(b)(1) and (2) permit a lawyer to state the claim, offense, or defense involved and the identity of the parties, and to give information about the scheduling of the matter. Statements about confessions, prior records, and the accused's guilt fall outside the safe harbor.

  126. Question 126Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer in a pending civil case wants to discuss a scheduling conflict with the judge. What is the proper approach under Rule 3.5?

    1. Communicate only through a filing served on all parties, unless the judge authorizes otherwise. Correct answer.
    2. Ask the judge's law clerk to relay the request privately to the judge.
    3. Send the judge a letter explaining the conflict without copying opposing counsel.
    4. Call the judge's chambers privately, since the matter is merely procedural and not substantive.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.5(b) prohibits a lawyer from communicating ex parte with a judge or other official during a proceeding unless authorized to do so by law or court order. Scheduling is a matter in the case, and the communication should be made on notice to all parties absent authorization.

  127. Question 127Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    After reviewing the file, a prosecutor concludes that the evidence is insufficient to support a charge against a defendant and that no further evidence is obtainable. What does Rule 3.8 require?

    1. Refrain from prosecuting the charge. Correct answer.
    2. Refer the matter to the grand jury without any recommendation.
    3. Proceed only if the alleged victim asks the prosecutor to pursue the case.
    4. Proceed with the charge and let the jury decide the weight of the evidence.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.8(a) provides that a prosecutor shall refrain from prosecuting a charge that the prosecutor knows is not supported by probable cause. The prosecutor's obligation runs to the justice system as a whole, not merely to the victim or the complainant.

  128. Question 128Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    Opposing counsel proposes a routine discovery schedule that would resolve the case months sooner than the client's preferred aggressive approach. The client wants maximum delay and instructs the lawyer to resist. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Follow the client's instruction, because scheduling decisions belong solely to the client.
    2. Make reasonable efforts to expedite the litigation consistent with the client's interests. Correct answer.
    3. Delay as long as the rules of procedure technically permit.
    4. Delay only if the delay can be attributed to the opposing party's conduct.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.2 requires a lawyer to make reasonable efforts to expedite litigation consistent with the interests of the client. Tactics that serve no purpose other than delay are inconsistent with that duty and with the lawyer's role as an officer of the court.

  129. Question 129Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    In a civil trial, a lawyer knows that the court excluded evidence of the opposing party's prior bad acts. In closing argument, the lawyer refers to a 'pattern of misconduct' that 'everyone in this room knows about.' What is this conduct?

    1. Improper, because the lawyer alluded to inadmissible evidence the lawyer knew was not supported by the record. Correct answer.
    2. Improper only if the opposing party objected contemporaneously to the remark.
    3. Proper, because closing argument is not evidence and therefore cannot mislead the jury.
    4. Proper, because the lawyer never stated the excluded facts explicitly.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.4(e) prohibits a lawyer at trial from alluding to any matter that the lawyer does not reasonably believe is relevant or supported by admissible evidence. Winking references to excluded facts violate the rule as much as explicit statements.

  130. Question 130Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer in a firm is likely to be a necessary witness at an upcoming trial. Another lawyer at the firm is fully available to try the case. Under Rule 3.7(b), may the firm continue the representation?

    1. No, unless the client waives the conflict in writing and the court approves the arrangement.
    2. No, because a lawyer's disqualification as a witness disqualifies every lawyer in the firm.
    3. Yes, unless another rule, such as Rule 1.7 or Rule 1.9, precludes the representation. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, but only if the testifying lawyer is screened from all participation in the case.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.7(b) permits a lawyer to act as advocate in a trial in which another lawyer in the firm is likely to be called as a witness, unless the representation is precluded by Rule 1.7 or Rule 1.9. The firm is therefore not automatically disqualified.

  131. Question 131Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    In a pending civil case, a lawyer asks a former employee of the opposing corporate party to sign a statement promising not to speak with the plaintiff's counsel. The former employee is not a client of the lawyer. Under Rule 3.4(f), the lawyer's request is:

    1. Permitted, because the request did not involve a threat of any kind.
    2. Prohibited, because the lawyer may not ask a nonclient to withhold information voluntarily. Correct answer.
    3. Permitted, because the lawyer did not offer the person anything of value.
    4. Permitted, because the person is not a client of the lawyer and owes the lawyer no duty.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.4(f) prohibits a lawyer from requesting a person other than a client to refrain from voluntarily giving relevant information to another party, unless the person is a relative, employee, or other agent of a client and the lawyer reasonably believes the person's interests will not be adversely affected. A former employee of an opposing corporate party falls outside that narrow exception.

  132. Question 132Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    During a jury trial, a lawyer wants to ask one of the empaneled jurors a question about the case outside the courtroom. Under Rule 3.5(b), this communication is:

    1. Prohibited unless the lawyer is authorized by law or court order to communicate ex parte. Correct answer.
    2. Prohibited only if the lawyer's purpose is to influence the juror's vote on the verdict.
    3. Permitted, because the lawyer does not represent a party to the juror.
    4. Permitted if the conversation takes place outside the presence of the rest of the jury panel.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.5(b) bars a lawyer from communicating ex parte with a juror or prospective juror during the proceeding unless authorized to do so by law or court order. The prohibition protects the integrity of the adjudicative process and does not depend on showing an improper purpose.

  133. Question 133Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer appears on behalf of a client at a zoning board hearing, a nonadjudicative proceeding. Which statement best describes the lawyer's duties under Rule 3.9?

    1. The lawyer owes candor only to the client and to opposing counsel, not to the board.
    2. No duty of candor applies, because a zoning board is not a court.
    3. The lawyer must volunteer every fact favorable to the opposing side before presenting the client's position.
    4. The lawyer must comply with Rules 3.3(a) through (c) and state that the appearance is in a representative capacity. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.9 requires a lawyer representing a client before a legislative body or administrative agency in a nonadjudicative proceeding to disclose that the appearance is in a representative capacity and to conform to Rules 3.3(a) through (c), 3.4(a) through (c), and 3.5. The duty of candor therefore continues, though the ex parte disclosure rule of Rule 3.3(d) does not apply.

  134. Question 134Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    In a civil case, a lawyer's client has submitted an affidavit that the lawyer now knows to be false in a material respect. Efforts to persuade the client to correct it have failed, and withdrawal will not cure the falsehood. Under Rule 3.3(b), what must the lawyer do?

    1. Nothing further, because the lawyer owes confidentiality to the client and has already tried to persuade the client to correct the affidavit.
    2. Withdraw from the representation and remain silent about the affidavit in order to protect the client.
    3. Take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure to the tribunal if necessary. Correct answer.
    4. Resign from the case and notify the disciplinary authority, but not the court, of the client's conduct.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(b) requires a lawyer who knows that a person has engaged in criminal or fraudulent conduct related to the proceeding to take reasonable remedial measures, including, if necessary, disclosure to the tribunal. The duty continues to the conclusion of the proceeding, and withdrawal alone does not remedy a false statement already before the court.

  135. Question 135Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A prosecutor wants to subpoena a defense attorney to testify before a grand jury about a fee payment the attorney received from a former client who is a target of the investigation. Under Rule 3.8(e), the subpoena is permissible only if the prosecutor reasonably believes that:

    1. The attorney's testimony would relate to an uncontested issue in the criminal case.
    2. The information is unprivileged, the evidence is essential, and no feasible alternative exists. Correct answer.
    3. The grand jury has requested the testimony by a majority vote of its members.
    4. The attorney consents to testifying and waives any privilege on the client's behalf.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.8(e) prohibits a prosecutor from subpoenaing a lawyer to present evidence about a past or present client in a grand jury or other criminal proceeding unless the prosecutor reasonably believes the information is not privileged, the evidence is essential to the successful completion of an ongoing investigation or prosecution, and there is no other feasible alternative to obtain the information.

  136. Question 136Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    In a civil case, a lawyer reasonably believes that a witness the client wants to call will testify falsely, but the lawyer does not know for certain that the testimony is false. Under Rule 3.3(a)(3), the lawyer may:

    1. Offer the testimony in narrative form and disclose the lawyer's doubts to the jury.
    2. Neither offer the testimony nor inform the client, because the belief is only reasonable rather than certain.
    3. Refuse to offer the evidence, because it is not the testimony of a criminal defendant. Correct answer.
    4. Offer the testimony only if the client signs a written waiver of any later malpractice claim.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.3(a)(3) permits a lawyer to refuse to offer evidence, other than the testimony of a defendant in a criminal matter, that the lawyer reasonably believes is false. A reasonable belief, not certainty, is enough to justify declining to present the evidence.

  137. Question 137Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A lawyer believes that a pretrial discovery order is invalid and that compliance would harm the client. Under Rule 3.4(c), the lawyer may resist the order without violating the rule by:

    1. Disregarding the order quietly and raising the objection only if sanctions are later sought.
    2. Directing the client, rather than the lawyer, to refuse compliance in order to avoid discipline.
    3. Refusing compliance only after the court has held the lawyer in contempt.
    4. Openly refusing compliance based on an assertion that no valid obligation exists. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.4(c) prohibits a lawyer from knowingly disobeying an obligation under the rules of a tribunal, except for an open refusal based on an assertion that no valid obligation exists. The refusal must be open, and the lawyer must be prepared to accept the consequences of the position.

  138. Question 138Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

    A prosecutor learns of new, credible, and material evidence creating a reasonable likelihood that a defendant convicted in her jurisdiction did not commit the crime. Under Rule 3.8(g), the prosecutor must:

    1. Take no action until the defendant files a postconviction petition and obtains new counsel.
    2. Notify only the trial judge and await further instructions from the court.
    3. Reopen the investigation only if the defendant can afford to retain new counsel.
    4. Disclose the evidence to the court and the defendant, and investigate further. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 3.8(g) requires a prosecutor who knows of new, credible, and material evidence creating a reasonable likelihood that a convicted defendant did not commit the offense to disclose it promptly to an appropriate court or authority and, where the conviction was obtained in the prosecutor's jurisdiction, to disclose it to the defendant and to undertake further investigation or cause one to be made.

  139. Question 139Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer represents the plaintiff in a breach of contract action. The lawyer knows that the defendant is represented by counsel. The lawyer wants to call the defendant directly to discuss settlement. How should the lawyer proceed?

    1. The lawyer may call the defendant directly because the defendant is an adverse party who has notice of the claim.
    2. The lawyer may call the defendant directly so long as the lawyer identifies himself and states the purpose of the call.
    3. The lawyer may not call the defendant absent the consent of defense counsel or authorization by law or court order. Correct answer.
    4. The lawyer may call the defendant directly if the lawyer mails a copy of the conversation summary to defense counsel.

    Explanation

    Under the no-contact rule, a lawyer may not communicate about the subject of a representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented by another lawyer in that matter. The prohibition applies regardless of the client's consent or the adversary's willingness to talk. The exceptions are the consent of the other lawyer, authorization by law, or a court order.

  140. Question 140Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    Defense counsel in a personal injury case tells the plaintiff's lawyer, "You may contact my client directly to discuss settlement; I consent." The plaintiff's lawyer then telephones the defendant. Is the call proper?

    1. No, unless the defendant personally signs a written waiver of the right to have counsel present at the conversation.
    2. Yes, but only if a judge approves the proposed settlement discussion in advance of the call.
    3. Yes, because the defendant's lawyer consented to the communication. Correct answer.
    4. No, because a person who is represented by counsel may never be contacted directly by opposing counsel.

    Explanation

    The no-contact rule bars communication with a represented person only when the other lawyer has not consented. Consent from the represented person's own lawyer removes the prohibition, and settlement is the classic subject for which such consent is given. No writing, judicial approval, or personal waiver by the party is required by the rule.

  141. Question 141Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A defendant who is represented by counsel telephones the plaintiff's lawyer at home and says, "I want to talk to you about settling this case myself." What is the plaintiff's lawyer required to do?

    1. Continue the conversation only if the lawyer records it and sends the recording to defense counsel.
    2. Continue the conversation, because the defendant initiated the contact and thereby waived the protection of the rule.
    3. Continue the conversation after reading the defendant the warnings that the rule requires before such contacts.
    4. Decline to discuss the case with the defendant and end the conversation. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The no-contact rule applies even when the represented person initiates the contact or says he is willing to talk. A lawyer who learns that a person is represented must terminate the communication and may proceed only through that person's counsel. Any information obtained in the improper conversation also may not be used.

  142. Question 142Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A corporation is a defendant in a products liability suit and is represented by counsel. Plaintiff's lawyer wants to interview a janitor who witnessed the accident, has no supervisory role, and whose conduct is not at issue. May the lawyer conduct the interview without the corporation's lawyer's consent?

    1. Yes, because the janitor is not an employee whose acts bind the company or who directs its litigation. Correct answer.
    2. No, unless the plaintiff's lawyer first obtains a court order permitting the interview to go forward.
    3. No, because every employee of a corporation that is represented by counsel is covered by the no-contact rule.
    4. Yes, but only if the interview is conducted in the presence of the corporation's lawyer or another corporate representative.

    Explanation

    When an organization is represented, the no-contact rule protects only its constituents: employees who supervise, direct, or regularly consult with the organization's lawyer about the matter, or whose acts or omissions may be imputed to the organization, or whose statements may bind it as admissions. An ordinary employee who merely witnessed events and has no role in the litigation is not a constituent. Contact with such a person does not require the organization's lawyer's consent.

  143. Question 143Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A company that is a party to a lawsuit is represented by counsel. Plaintiff's lawyer wants to interview a person who left the company's employ two years ago about events that occurred while she worked there. Does the no-contact rule bar the interview?

    1. No, because the no-contact rule does not cover former employees of the organization. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because former employees remain constituents of the organization for purposes of the no-contact rule.
    3. Yes, unless the former employee signs a written waiver approved by the corporation's lawyer.
    4. No, but only if the corporation's lawyer is given advance notice and an opportunity to attend.

    Explanation

    Former employees are not constituents of a represented organization, so the no-contact rule does not forbid speaking with them. The lawyer must still avoid soliciting information protected by the organization's attorney-client privilege. No notice to or consent from corporate counsel is required.

  144. Question 144Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer represents a plaintiff suing a city police department. The department is a party and is represented in the litigation by the city attorney. The lawyer wants to interview a police officer about the events at issue. What does the no-contact rule require?

    1. The lawyer may interview the officer because the officer is not a named party to the lawsuit personally.
    2. The lawyer may interview the officer because government employees are completely exempt from the no-contact rule.
    3. The lawyer may interview the officer only if the officer agrees in writing to speak in his individual capacity.
    4. The lawyer may not interview the officer without the city attorney's consent unless authorized by law. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The no-contact rule applies to communications with government officials and employees whose conduct is at issue in a matter in which the government is represented. The consent of the government's lawyer is required unless a statute, regulation, or court order authorizes the contact. The officer's personal agreement to speak does not substitute for that consent.

  145. Question 145Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer knows that the opposing party is represented by counsel in pending litigation. The lawyer asks the opposing party's business partner to convey a settlement proposal to the opposing party. Is this proper?

    1. Yes, because the business partner is not a party to the litigation and owes no duty to the court.
    2. Yes, because settlement offers in litigation need not be routed through the opposing party's counsel.
    3. No, because a lawyer may not do indirectly what the rule forbids doing directly. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, because the lawyer did not communicate with the opposing party directly and used an intermediary.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not circumvent the no-contact rule by using a third person to convey a message to a represented party. Settlement is a subject of the representation, and proposals must be directed to the party's lawyer. The intermediary's nonparty status does not change the analysis.

  146. Question 146Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer representing a landlord writes to an unrepresented tenant on letterhead describing the lawyer as an "impartial claims investigator for the property." The lawyer is in fact the landlord's advocate. Which statement is correct?

    1. The lawyer did not violate the rule because unrepresented persons are presumed to know a lawyer's role.
    2. The lawyer did not violate the rule because the letter also disclosed the landlord's identity.
    3. The lawyer violated the rule by implying that the lawyer was a disinterested investigator. Correct answer.
    4. The lawyer violated the rule only if the tenant actually relied on the description to her detriment.

    Explanation

    When dealing with an unrepresented person, a lawyer must not state or imply that the lawyer is disinterested in the matter. The duty is breached by the misleading implication itself, regardless of reliance or harm. Disclosing the client's identity does not cure a description that presents the lawyer as neutral.

  147. Question 147Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer representing a landlord contacts an unrepresented tenant about ending a lease. The tenant asks the lawyer, "Should I sign the termination agreement?" How must the lawyer respond?

    1. The lawyer may not give the tenant legal advice other than to get her own lawyer. Correct answer.
    2. The lawyer may advise the tenant if the advice is put in writing and signed by the lawyer and the client.
    3. The lawyer may advise the tenant to sign because the termination agreement is lawful and fair to both sides.
    4. The lawyer may advise the tenant if the lawyer explains the tenant's interests fairly and accurately.

    Explanation

    When a lawyer knows or reasonably should know that an unrepresented person's interests are adverse to the client's, the lawyer may not give that person legal advice other than advice to obtain counsel. The lawyer may explain the lawyer's own role and the client's position but may not advise on the merits. Putting the advice in writing does not make it permissible.

  148. Question 148Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    During settlement talks, a lawyer tells opposing counsel that the client has "an airtight alibi" even though the lawyer knows the alibi witness has recanted. How should this be evaluated?

    1. There is a violation only if the client authorized the lawyer to make the statement.
    2. There is no violation, because opposing counsel could have investigated the alibi independently.
    3. There is a violation, because the lawyer stated a material fact known to be false. Correct answer.
    4. There is no violation, because statements made during settlement negotiations are never treated as statements of fact.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not knowingly make a false statement of material fact to a third person, and this duty applies fully in negotiation. The existence and reliability of an alibi witness is a material fact, not mere puffery. The opposing lawyer's ability to investigate independently does not excuse a knowing falsehood.

  149. Question 149Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    In a negotiation, a lawyer says, "In my opinion, this case is worth about $1 million." The lawyer has no objective basis for that figure. How is the statement treated under the rules?

    1. It is improper unless the lawyer also discloses to opposing counsel the client's actual settlement authority.
    2. It is prohibited unless the client has authorized that exact figure in advance and in writing.
    3. It is prohibited, because any statement of value in negotiation is a statement of material fact.
    4. It is generally permitted, because an estimate of value is opinion rather than fact. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The duty of candor reaches statements of material fact, not statements of opinion or estimates of the price or value placed on a matter in dispute. A lawyer's characterization of what a case is worth is a classic estimate of value. The rule does not require client authorization of a figure or disclosure of settlement authority.

  150. Question 150Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer serves 40 interrogatories and notices 20 depositions in a routine contract dispute. The lawyer's only reason is to exhaust the opponent's resources. How should this be evaluated?

    1. The lawyer did not violate the rule because such discovery is authorized by the rules of procedure.
    2. The lawyer did not violate the rule because the client approved the discovery strategy.
    3. The lawyer violated the rule only if the opponent can prove actual financial harm.
    4. The lawyer violated the rule by using means with no substantial purpose other than to burden. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not use means that have no substantial purpose other than to delay, burden, or embarrass a third person. The availability of a discovery device under procedural rules does not authorize its use for an improper purpose. Client approval does not excuse tactics whose only aim is to exhaust the opponent.

  151. Question 151Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    Opposing counsel emails a lawyer a document that plainly appears to be a privileged internal memo sent by mistake. What must the receiving lawyer do?

    1. Read and use the memo at trial, because opposing counsel sent it voluntarily.
    2. Delete the memo without notifying anyone, to avoid being tainted by it.
    3. Use the memo at trial if the client directs the lawyer to do so after review.
    4. Promptly notify the sender so the sender can take protective steps. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    When a lawyer knows or reasonably should know that a document was inadvertently sent, the lawyer must promptly notify the sender. Notification lets the sender take protective measures such as seeking judicial relief. The rule leaves the question of returning or destroying the document to other law but mandates notice.

  152. Question 152Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer has a motion pending before a judge. The lawyer emails the judge directly to ask how the judge intends to rule. Is this proper?

    1. No, because a lawyer may not communicate ex parte with a judge about a pending matter. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because a lawyer may always communicate with the judge in writing about a pending case.
    3. No, unless the lawyer sends a copy of the email to opposing counsel at the same time.
    4. Yes, because the email asks only about the judge's intentions and does not argue the merits.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not seek to influence a judge by means prohibited by law, and ex parte communications with a judge about a pending matter are prohibited unless authorized by law or court order. Asking how the judge will rule is a communication about the merits. Filing motions and serving all parties through ordinary procedures is the proper route.

  153. Question 153Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    During a trial, a lawyer sees a juror at a grocery store and wants to ask how the juror feels about the testimony so far. May the lawyer do so?

    1. Yes, if the lawyer discloses the conversation to the court immediately afterward.
    2. Yes, because the encounter occurs outside the courtroom and away from other jurors.
    3. No, because the lawyer may not communicate with a juror during the proceeding. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, because the lawyer may speak with jurors about subjects unrelated to the case.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not communicate ex parte with a juror or prospective juror during a proceeding unless authorized by law or court order. The prohibition follows the juror outside the courthouse. Later disclosure to the court does not cure the improper contact.

  154. Question 154Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    After the jury is discharged, a lawyer wants to interview a juror about the deliberations to prepare a motion for a new trial. Is the interview permitted?

    1. Yes, unless a law or court order prohibits the contact. Correct answer.
    2. No, unless the lawyer first obtains the trial judge's written permission.
    3. No, because jurors may never be questioned about their deliberations after a verdict.
    4. Yes, but only if the lawyer represents the party that prevailed at trial.

    Explanation

    The prohibition on communicating with jurors ends when the jury is discharged, subject to any applicable law or court order that forbids post-verdict contact. The lawyer also may not communicate with a former juror to harass or influence that person. No judicial permission is required in the absence of a court order.

  155. Question 155Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    Before trial in a fraud case, a lawyer holds a press conference and tells reporters that the opposing party "has a history of fraud and will lie on the witness stand." How is the statement evaluated?

    1. The statement is prohibited if it creates a substantial likelihood of material prejudice. Correct answer.
    2. The statement is permitted because the lawyer did not disclose any specific item of evidence.
    3. The statement is permitted because the press conference took place before the trial began.
    4. The statement is protected because everything the lawyer said about the opposing party is true.

    Explanation

    A lawyer participating in a matter may not make an extrajudicial statement that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know will be disseminated and will have a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing an adjudicative proceeding. The test looks to the risk of prejudice, not merely to truth or the absence of specific evidence. The rule applies to statements made at any stage, including before trial.

  156. Question 156Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    Opposing counsel holds a press conference making inflammatory and highly prejudicial statements about the lawyer's client. The lawyer wants to respond to the press. What does the publicity rule allow?

    1. The lawyer may never respond to publicity generated by the opposing party.
    2. The lawyer may respond only with a statement needed to mitigate substantial prejudice already caused. Correct answer.
    3. The lawyer may respond with any truthful information about the case, without regard to prejudice.
    4. The lawyer may respond only after obtaining the client's written consent to the statement.

    Explanation

    The publicity rule contains a mitigation exception: a lawyer may make a statement that a reasonable lawyer would believe is required to protect the client from the substantial undue prejudicial effect of recent publicity not initiated by the lawyer or the client. The responsive statement must be limited to what is necessary to mitigate the prejudice. Client consent does not expand that narrow allowance.

  157. Question 157Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer represents a client in a divorce. The opposing spouse is represented by counsel in the divorce. The lawyer wants to contact the spouse about an unrelated landscaping contract dispute between the client and the spouse. May the lawyer do so?

    1. No, unless the divorce lawyer gives written consent to the contact in advance.
    2. No, unless the client is present during the conversation with the spouse.
    3. Yes, because the conversation does not concern the subject of the divorce representation. Correct answer.
    4. No, because once a person is represented by counsel, all contact with that person is prohibited.

    Explanation

    The no-contact rule bars communication only about the subject of the representation in which the person is represented. A matter outside the scope of that representation is not protected, so contact about the unrelated landscaping dispute is permitted. Consent, client presence, and writing are not required for such unrelated contact.

  158. Question 158Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

    A lawyer representing a criminal defendant wants to ask a co-defendant, who is represented by his own lawyer, whether he will testify for the defense. May the lawyer make the request directly?

    1. Yes, so long as the co-defendant's lawyer is informed about the contact afterward.
    2. Yes, because the client has a constitutional right to investigate and prepare a defense.
    3. No, the lawyer must obtain the consent of the co-defendant's lawyer first. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, but only by serving a formal subpoena requiring the co-defendant to testify.

    Explanation

    A co-defendant represented by counsel in a related matter is protected by the no-contact rule, and the lawyer's own client's need to investigate does not override it. The lawyer must seek consent from the co-defendant's lawyer, or proceed through formal process where appropriate. Notice after the fact does not substitute for consent.

  159. Question 159The Profession and the Public

    An attorney wants to state in her advertisements that she is a 'certified specialist in family law.' Under the ABA Model Rules, what must be true before she may make that statement?

    1. She must avoid the word 'specialist' entirely, because the Model Rules forbid any claim that a lawyer specializes.
    2. She must have devoted at least ten years of practice exclusively to the field and must maintain a paid listing in a nationally recognized directory of specialists.
    3. She must submit the text of every advertisement to the state disciplinary board and obtain its written approval before publication.
    4. An organization approved by an appropriate state authority must have certified her, and the advertisement must identify that organization. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may state that she is certified as a specialist only if she has been certified by an organization approved by an appropriate state authority or accredited by the ABA, and the communication must clearly identify the certifying organization. Length of practice and directory listings do not substitute for board-recognized certification. Blanket prohibitions on the word 'specialist' misstate the rule, which regulates rather than forbids such claims.

  160. Question 160The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer has no family, close personal, or prior professional relationship with a particular prospective client. Which contact with that person does the Model Rules prohibit?

    1. A truthful listing of the lawyer's office address and telephone number in a public business directory.
    2. A letter mailed to a person known to need legal services in a specific matter, with 'Advertising Material' printed on the envelope.
    3. A general newspaper advertisement describing the lawyer's practice areas and office hours.
    4. A live telephone call to a person known to need legal services in that matter, made in order to obtain the fee. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 7.3 bars solicitation by in-person, live telephone, or real-time electronic contact when a significant motive is the lawyer's pecuniary gain, unless the person contacted is a lawyer or has a family, close personal, or prior professional relationship with the lawyer. Written communications and general advertising are not categorically forbidden, though written solicitations must carry the required label. Directory listings are a form of permissible advertising.

  161. Question 161The Profession and the Public

    In which matter is a lawyer barred from charging a fee contingent on the outcome?

    1. A divorce action in which the fee depends on the size of the property settlement. Correct answer.
    2. A patent infringement suit brought on behalf of an inventor seeking an injunction and damages.
    3. A products liability action brought on behalf of an injured consumer seeking compensatory damages.
    4. A collection action brought by a small business to recover an unpaid invoice.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.5(d) forbids contingency fees in criminal matters and in domestic relations matters where the fee is contingent on securing a divorce or on the amount of alimony, support, or property settlement. The concern is that such fees would give the lawyer an interest in promoting family dissolution or inflating a settlement. Contingency fees remain permissible in most civil disputes, including tort, collection, and patent litigation.

  162. Question 162The Profession and the Public

    Model Rule 6.1 addresses a lawyer's professional obligation to provide legal services to those unable to pay. What does the Rule set as the annual aspirational goal?

    1. At least fifty hours of pro bono publico legal services. Correct answer.
    2. Ten hours of pro bono publico legal services.
    3. Twenty hours of pro bono publico legal services.
    4. No number at all, because the Rule contains only a general exhortation.

    Explanation

    Rule 6.1 states that a lawyer should aspire to render at least fifty hours of pro bono publico legal services per year, with the majority of those hours normally provided without fee to persons of limited means or to organizations serving them. The obligation is aspirational rather than subject to discipline. It also encourages financial support of legal aid organizations.

  163. Question 163The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer generally may not share legal fees with a nonlawyer. Which arrangement falls within a recognized exception?

    1. A payment, under a preexisting agreement, to a deceased lawyer's estate. Correct answer.
    2. A payment to an independent marketing consultant of a percentage of the fees generated by clients the consultant recruits.
    3. A share of the firm's profits paid to a nonlawyer who owns a small equity stake in the practice.
    4. A payment to a paralegal equal to a fixed percentage of every fee the firm earns on the paralegal's cases.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.4(a) prohibits fee sharing with nonlawyers but carves out narrow exceptions, one of which is paying a deceased lawyer's estate or specified beneficiaries over a reasonable period under a preexisting agreement. Other exceptions cover employee compensation, buyouts of a deceased or disabled lawyer's practice, and qualified pension or profit-sharing plans. Percentage-based compensation tied to specific fees, payments for client recruitment, and nonlawyer ownership all fall outside those exceptions.

  164. Question 164The Profession and the Public

    A firm's advertisement states: 'We are the most aggressive and effective law firm in the state.' The firm has no data supporting the claim. How should the advertisement be evaluated under the Model Rules?

    1. Permitted, because truthful commercial speech about legal services receives full constitutional protection.
    2. Impermissible, because an unverifiable claim of superiority over other lawyers is misleading. Correct answer.
    3. Permitted, because figurative claims of superiority are not statements of fact.
    4. Permitted, so long as the advertisement does not identify a competing firm by name.

    Explanation

    Rule 7.1 prohibits false or misleading communications about a lawyer's services, and a comparison with other lawyers that cannot be factually substantiated is misleading. Commercial speech about legal services is protected but remains subject to reasonable regulation, including the prohibition on deceptive content. Omitting competitors' names does not cure an unsupported claim of being the best.

  165. Question 165The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer obtains a police report identifying a person injured in a collision and mails that person a brochure describing the lawyer's practice and urging the recipient to call. What additional step does the Model Rule require?

    1. The envelope must be labeled 'Advertising Material.' Correct answer.
    2. The lawyer must file a copy of the mailing with the clerk of court in the recipient's county.
    3. The lawyer must obtain advance approval of the mailing from the state disciplinary authority.
    4. Nothing further is required, because a truthful mailed brochure is not restricted by the Rules.

    Explanation

    Rule 7.3(c) requires that each written or electronic solicitation include the words 'Advertising Material' on the outside envelope, if there is one, and at the beginning and end of any recorded or electronic communication. The label lets the recipient know at a glance that the communication is a solicitation. No advance approval or court filing is required.

  166. Question 166The Profession and the Public

    Lawyer A, a solo practitioner, refers a personal injury client to Lawyer B and they agree that A will receive one-third of the total fee. A does no work on the matter and does not assume joint responsibility for the representation. What must occur for the division to be proper?

    1. Lawyer B must reduce the total fee by the amount that will be paid to Lawyer A so the client pays no more.
    2. Lawyer A must personally perform work proportional to the share of the fee that he receives and must document those hours.
    3. The client must agree in writing to the arrangement, including each lawyer's share, and the total fee must be reasonable. Correct answer.
    4. The court in which the case is pending must approve the division before judgment is entered.

    Explanation

    Rule 1.5(e) permits a division of fees between lawyers who are not in the same firm only if the division is proportional to the services performed or each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation, the client agrees in writing to the arrangement including each lawyer's share, and the total fee is reasonable. Because A neither worked on the matter nor assumed joint responsibility, this particular division would also fail the first requirement. Court approval and fee reduction are not the governing conditions.

  167. Question 167The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer admitted only in State A is retained to represent a client in a commercial arbitration conducted in State B, where the forum does not require pro hac vice admission. The lawyer travels to State B for the hearing and keeps no office there. The arbitration is closely related to her State A practice. How should her conduct be assessed?

    1. Permitted, because temporary practice in an arbitration related to her home-state practice falls within a safe harbor. Correct answer.
    2. Permitted only if the highest court of State B admits her pro hac vice for the arbitration before the hearing begins.
    3. Permitted only if she associates a State B lawyer who actively participates in the arbitration.
    4. Prohibited, because she is not admitted to practice in State B and may not appear there.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.5(c) allows a lawyer admitted in another United States jurisdiction to provide legal services on a temporary basis where the services are in or reasonably related to an arbitration, mediation, or other alternative dispute resolution proceeding and arise out of or are reasonably related to the lawyer's practice in a jurisdiction where she is admitted. No local counsel and no pro hac vice admission are needed when the forum does not require it. Out-of-state admission alone therefore does not bar the appearance.

  168. Question 168The Profession and the Public

    At a law firm, a paralegal meets alone with a client, advises the client how to respond to a complaint, and quotes the fee. The supervising lawyer later reviews the file. Which statement is correct?

    1. The firm may bill the client for the paralegal's advice, because the lawyer supervised the work.
    2. The conduct was proper, because the paralegal was acting as the firm's employee.
    3. The conduct was proper, because the paralegal holds a national paralegal certification.
    4. The lawyer violated the rules by allowing the paralegal to give legal advice to a client. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer must make reasonable efforts to ensure that the firm has measures in place giving reasonable assurance that a nonlawyer's conduct is compatible with the lawyer's professional obligations, and a nonlawyer employee may not give legal advice to a client. Delegating advice-giving to a paralegal is a failure of that supervisory duty. Later review does not cure advice that should never have been given.

  169. Question 169The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer admitted only in State A opens a full-service office in State B, where she regularly handles State B real estate closings and drafts State B wills for State B residents. She is not admitted in State B and does not associate local counsel. Her conduct is:

    1. Proper, provided her letterhead identifies her as licensed only in State A.
    2. Prohibited only if she also appears in a State B court on behalf of a client.
    3. Proper, because she holds a valid law license in at least one state.
    4. Prohibited, because she has established a systematic and continuous presence in State B without admission. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.5(b) bars a lawyer who is not admitted in a jurisdiction from establishing an office or other systematic and continuous presence there, or from holding out to the public as authorized to practice there. A full-service local office handling local matters is the paradigm of unauthorized practice. The absence of courtroom appearances does not save the arrangement.

  170. Question 170The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer agrees to pay a for-profit commercial matching service a flat fee for each client the service sends to the lawyer. The service is not approved by any state authority and is not a nonprofit lawyer referral service. How should the arrangement be assessed?

    1. Improper, because paying for referrals is barred except to certain approved or qualified referral services. Correct answer.
    2. Proper, if the fee paid is reasonable in relation to the value of the referral.
    3. Proper, if the fee is disclosed to the client in a signed writing.
    4. Proper, because the client remains free to decline the referral and hire someone else.

    Explanation

    Rule 7.2(b) prohibits a lawyer from giving anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer's services, subject to narrow exceptions such as paying the reasonable costs of permissible advertising and paying the usual charges of a legal service plan or a not-for-profit or qualified lawyer referral service. A for-profit matching service that is neither approved nor qualified falls outside those exceptions. Disclosure to the client and reasonableness of the amount do not cure the violation.

  171. Question 171The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer receives a $10,000 advance fee to handle a matter, deposits it into the firm's business operating account, and performs two hours of work before the client discharges her and asks for the balance back. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. She may keep the entire amount if the retainer agreement stated that the fee was nonrefundable.
    2. She must refund the unearned balance, which was client property that had to be held in trust. Correct answer.
    3. She must refund the entire amount, because a client may discharge a lawyer at any time and for any reason.
    4. She may keep the entire amount, because the fee was earned at the moment it was paid.

    Explanation

    Funds paid in advance for services not yet performed belong to the client and must be deposited in a trust account, with the lawyer withdrawing amounts only as they are earned. On discharge, the lawyer must promptly account for and refund the unearned portion. A label of 'nonrefundable' does not entitle the lawyer to retain payment for work never done.

  172. Question 172The Profession and the Public

    A lawyer's own client confidentially tells the lawyer that the client, also a lawyer, embezzled funds from a former client. Must the lawyer report the misconduct to the disciplinary authorities under Model Rule 8.3?

    1. Yes, because every lawyer must report misconduct that raises a substantial question as to honesty or fitness.
    2. No, because a lawyer never has a duty to report another lawyer's misconduct.
    3. No, because Rule 8.3 does not reach information protected by the duty of confidentiality. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, unless the client consents to the disclosure after full consultation.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.3 requires a lawyer who knows of another lawyer's violation raising a substantial question as to that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness to inform the appropriate professional authority. The Rule, however, expressly does not require disclosure of information otherwise protected by Rule 1.6. Information learned in a confidential client communication therefore need not be reported.

  173. Question 173The Profession and the Public

    To generate business, a lawyer contracts with a marketing company that cold-calls accident victims and, when someone expresses interest, connects the call to the lawyer, who then discusses representation. None of the people called has any prior relationship with the lawyer. Which assessment is correct?

    1. Proper, because the lawyer did not personally place any of the telephone calls.
    2. Proper, provided the marketing company's script is truthful and not misleading.
    3. Proper, if the lawyer discloses the financial arrangement before discussing representation.
    4. Improper, because a lawyer may not do through an agent what she could not do directly. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A lawyer may not accomplish through the acts of another what she is forbidden to do herself, and live telephone solicitation of strangers known to need legal services for pecuniary gain is prohibited. The lawyer also remains responsible for the conduct of nonlawyer agents she uses. A truthful script or a disclosure statement does not convert prohibited solicitation into permissible advertising.

  174. Question 174The Profession and the Public

    The power to regulate the practice of law and to determine who may be admitted to the bar rests primarily with:

    1. The highest court of each state, under its inherent power to regulate the bar. Correct answer.
    2. The American Bar Association, through its accreditation of law schools and its Model Rules.
    3. The National Conference of Bar Examiners, through the uniform bar examination.
    4. The state legislature, through statutes that set eligibility requirements for bar admission.

    Explanation

    Courts exercise inherent judicial authority over the admission and discipline of lawyers, and the state supreme court is the ultimate regulator of the profession in most jurisdictions. Legislatures may enact related statutes and bar associations may propose rules, but neither displaces the court's ultimate authority. The ABA and the National Conference of Bar Examiners are voluntary or testing bodies whose work has no independent regulatory force.

  175. Question 175Judicial Conduct

    A sitting trial judge is invited to speak at a rally supporting a candidate for the state senate. Under the Model Code of Judicial Conduct, what should the judge do?

    1. Refuse, unless the judge is running for that same office.
    2. Attend, provided the judge says nothing about pending cases.
    3. Attend, because a state senate seat is a nonjudicial office.
    4. Refuse, because judges may not publicly endorse candidates for public office. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A judge or judicial candidate may not publicly endorse or publicly oppose a candidate for public office, whether the office is judicial or not. The prohibition covers speeches made on behalf of a political candidate and does not depend on whether the judge discusses pending cases. The rule protects the judiciary's apparent independence from partisan politics.

  176. Question 176Judicial Conduct

    A judge presiding over a personal injury case drives past the intersection where the collision occurred in order to see how the roads are laid out. This conduct is:

    1. Proper, because a judge may take notice of any facts the judge learns.
    2. Proper, if the judge discloses the visit to the parties.
    3. Improper, unless both parties accompany the judge.
    4. Improper, because a judge may not independently investigate facts. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A judge must not independently investigate facts in a case and must consider only the evidence presented by the parties. A personal view of the scene amounts to gathering extra-record evidence outside the adversary process. Disclosure afterwards does not convert the judge into a witness or investigator.

  177. Question 177Judicial Conduct

    A judge's spouse owns stock in a corporation that is a party to a case pending before the judge. What must the judge do?

    1. Disqualify, but only if the spouse bought the stock recently.
    2. Preside, if the judge discloses the holding on the record.
    3. Disqualify; the spouse has a financial interest in a party. Correct answer.
    4. Preside, because the spouse's holdings are not the judge's own.

    Explanation

    A judge must disqualify when the judge or the judge's spouse or domestic partner has more than a de minimis financial interest in a party or in the subject matter of the proceeding. The interest is imputed to the judge regardless of whether it belongs to the judge personally. Disclosure alone does not substitute for disqualification.

  178. Question 178Judicial Conduct

    Which of the following gifts may a judge accept under the Model Code of Judicial Conduct?

    1. A cash gift from a lawyer who frequently appears before the judge.
    2. A birthday present from a close personal friend. Correct answer.
    3. An interest-free loan from a party in a pending case.
    4. A free club membership offered by a group seeking favorable rulings.

    Explanation

    The Code bars judges from accepting gifts, loans, bequests, or benefits that a reasonable person would believe were intended to influence the judge. It expressly permits gifts from relatives or friends commemorating a special occasion such as a birthday or holiday. Gifts from lawyers practicing before the judge and from litigants are not permitted.

  179. Question 179Judicial Conduct

    Under the Model Code, a judge must disqualify when the judge's impartiality "might reasonably be questioned." This standard is met when:

    1. a reasonable person could doubt the judge's fairness. Correct answer.
    2. the judge's ruling is later reversed by an appellate court.
    3. the judge subjectively intended to favor one of the parties.
    4. one of the parties has filed a sworn affidavit demanding recusal.

    Explanation

    The disqualification standard is objective: it asks whether a reasonable, disinterested observer with knowledge of the facts could reasonably question the judge's impartiality. The judge's subjective good faith does not defeat disqualification, and neither the filing of a motion nor an appellate reversal creates the duty.

  180. Question 180Judicial Conduct

    A judge receives a subpoena commanding the judge to testify as a character witness for a longtime friend at a criminal trial. What should the judge do?

    1. Refuse, because judges may never testify as character witnesses.
    2. Testify only if the friend signs a confidentiality waiver.
    3. Testify, because a subpoena compels the testimony. Correct answer.
    4. Refuse, unless the presiding judge grants permission.

    Explanation

    A judge may not testify voluntarily as a character witness, because doing so lends the prestige of judicial office to advance a private interest. When the judge is subpoenaed, the judge's duty to give evidence as any other citizen would applies, and the judge may testify. The Code's concern is with voluntary testimony offered at a litigant's request.

  181. Question 181Judicial Conduct

    A judge serves on the board of a local food bank. In what way may the judge participate in the charity's annual fundraising drive?

    1. Signing letters that solicit donations from the public.
    2. Telephoning lawyers to ask each of them for a donation.
    3. Planning the drive and making a personal contribution. Correct answer.
    4. Asking courtroom staff to pledge a portion of their pay.

    Explanation

    A judge may serve a charitable or civic organization and may assist in planning and organizing its fundraising, and may personally contribute. The judge may not personally solicit funds or otherwise use the judge's position to pressure others to give. Soliciting lawyers or court staff is especially problematic because of the judge's authority over them.

  182. Question 182Judicial Conduct

    A judge's clerk discovers that two hearings are set for the same hour and a scheduling conflict must be resolved. The judge may:

    1. discuss the merits of the underlying motion with the moving party's lawyer.
    2. confer separately with counsel about scheduling conflicts. Correct answer.
    3. ask one side's lawyer to summarize the opponent's position on the phone.
    4. accept a written settlement proposal from one party without notifying the others.

    Explanation

    Ex parte communications are prohibited except in narrow circumstances, and communications made solely to schedule or administer a case are among the recognized exceptions. A judge may speak separately with counsel about calendars, deadlines, and similar logistics. The exception does not extend to the substance of the dispute or to settlement negotiations.

  183. Question 183Judicial Conduct

    A judge is assigned a controversial case. Newspaper editorials demand a harsh ruling, and the judge privately worries about criticism. The judge should:

    1. decide the case on the law and facts, regardless of criticism. Correct answer.
    2. treat the editorials as evidence of community standards.
    3. recuse, because public passion makes a fair ruling impossible.
    4. delay the ruling until public attention moves elsewhere.

    Explanation

    A judge must decide cases impartially and promptly, free from partisan interests, public clamor, and fear of criticism. Neither popular demand nor anticipated disapproval is a permissible influence on the outcome. Delay to avoid controversy is itself a failure of the duty to decide.

  184. Question 184Judicial Conduct

    Under the Model Code, how does a judicial candidate handle money for a campaign?

    1. The candidate may personally solicit contributions from lawyers who practice in the court.
    2. The candidate may spend unlimited personal funds without any reporting.
    3. A campaign committee may solicit and accept contributions for the candidate. Correct answer.
    4. The candidate may personally accept contributions of any size.

    Explanation

    Judicial candidates are barred from personally soliciting or accepting campaign contributions, but they may establish committees to do so on their behalf. The committee's activity remains subject to contribution limits and public reporting requirements. Personal solicitation, especially of lawyers appearing before the judge, is prohibited.

  185. Question 185Judicial Conduct

    After taking the bench, a judge is asked by a former client to handle a residential real estate closing. What is the judge's obligation?

    1. Decline, because a judge may not practice law in any form. Correct answer.
    2. Handle the closing, if no court appearance will be required.
    3. Handle the closing, because it is a simple transactional matter.
    4. Decline, unless the former client consents in writing.

    Explanation

    A judge may not practice law, and the prohibition covers transactional work as well as litigation. The Code permits only narrow exceptions, such as acting pro se in the judge's own affairs or giving advice to family members. Client consent does not create an exception.

  186. Question 186Judicial Conduct

    While preparing for sentencing, a judge reads a confidential presentence report indicating that a publicly traded company will soon be indicted. The judge may:

    1. use the information only in performing the judge's judicial duties. Correct answer.
    2. warn the company's lawyer as a professional courtesy.
    3. tell a relative who owns stock in the company to sell before the news breaks.
    4. disclose the information to a reporter once the grand jury has acted.

    Explanation

    Nonpublic information acquired in a judicial capacity may not be disclosed or used for any purpose unrelated to the judge's official duties. The restriction applies regardless of whether the information later becomes public and regardless of the recipient's relationship to the judge. Trading on or leaking such information would also expose the judge to serious civil and criminal liability.

  187. Question 187Judicial Conduct

    A judge holds membership in a private club that excludes members on the basis of race. Under the Model Code, the judge must:

    1. remain, if the judge joined before the policy was adopted.
    2. resign only if the club's policy violates state law.
    3. remain, if the judge does not personally support the policy.
    4. resign from the club. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A judge may not hold membership in any organization that practices invidious discrimination on the basis of race, sex, gender, religion, national origin, ethnicity, or sexual orientation. The duty is to withdraw from the organization; it does not depend on the judge's personal attitude or on state law. A judge's continued membership would undermine public confidence in the judiciary's commitment to equal treatment.

  188. Question 188Judicial Conduct

    A judge learns that another judge in the same district has repeatedly presided over hearings while intoxicated. What does the Model Code require of the judge who learned of it?

    1. Report the matter only after a litigant files a formal complaint.
    2. Take appropriate action, such as informing the chief judge. Correct answer.
    3. Immediately file criminal charges against the other judge.
    4. Nothing, because a judge has no duty regarding another judge's conduct.

    Explanation

    A judge who receives information indicating a substantial likelihood that another judge has violated the Code must take appropriate action. Depending on the seriousness, appropriate action may include speaking directly with the other judge, notifying the chief judge, or reporting to a disciplinary authority. Where the conduct poses an immediate risk to litigants and to public confidence, escalating the matter is expected.

  189. Question 189Judicial Conduct

    At a public forum, a candidate for judicial office is asked how she would rule on a pending challenge to a state statute. Under the Model Code, she should:

    1. announce how she would vote if the case reached her court.
    2. decline to pledge how she would rule in the case. Correct answer.
    3. promise to rule the way most voters in her district favor.
    4. state her personal view, since voters deserve to know it.

    Explanation

    Judicial candidates may discuss their views on legal and political issues, but they may not make pledges or promises about how they would decide specific cases or controversies likely to come before them. Committing to a result in a pending matter compromises the independence and impartiality the office requires. Declining to make such a pledge is the correct response.

  190. Question 190Judicial Conduct

    A full-time judge is asked to serve as the arbitrator in a commercial dispute between two companies. May the judge serve?

    1. Yes, if the dispute involves no case pending in court.
    2. Yes, if the parties waive any objection in writing.
    3. No, unless a statute authorizes judges to do so. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, if the judge receives no compensation for the service.

    Explanation

    A judge may not act as an arbitrator or mediator, or otherwise perform judicial functions in a private capacity, unless expressly authorized by law. The prohibition is not about compensation or the consent of the parties; it rests on the incompatibility of private adjudication with judicial office. Where a statute expressly permits it, the judge may serve.

  191. Question 191Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer discovers that another lawyer in her firm has been taking money from the firm's client trust account for personal use. The lawyer confirms the facts and there is no doubt about what happened. What must the lawyer do?

    1. Keep silent, because client confidences forbid any disclosure of the conduct.
    2. Resign from the firm and write a letter to the affected client describing the conversion.
    3. Report the matter to the firm's managing partner and take no further action.
    4. Report the misconduct to the appropriate professional disciplinary authority. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.3 requires a lawyer who knows that another lawyer has committed a violation raising a substantial question as to honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness to inform the appropriate professional authority. Misappropriation of trust funds plainly meets that standard, and the rule expressly permits disclosure of information that would otherwise be protected by the duty of confidentiality to the extent necessary to report. Telling only a supervisor or quietly resigning does not satisfy the duty.

  192. Question 192Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    An applicant for bar admission knowingly leaves a 2019 misdemeanor arrest off his application. The arrest would not have disqualified him from admission had he disclosed it. If the omission comes to light, what is the proper conclusion?

    1. No violation, because statements on bar applications are outside the disciplinary rules.
    2. No violation, because the arrest would not have disqualified him from admission.
    3. A violation only if the bar later discovers the arrest on its own initiative.
    4. A violation, for failing to disclose a fact necessary to correct a misapprehension. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.1 makes it misconduct for a lawyer or applicant to knowingly make a false statement of material fact or to fail to disclose a fact necessary to correct a misapprehension known to have arisen in connection with a bar admission application. The materiality of the omission does not turn on whether the underlying arrest would have barred admission; candor in the application process is itself the duty.

  193. Question 193Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer sends a settlement demand stating that the plaintiff's medical bills total $85,000 when the lawyer knows the bills total $65,000. The opposing counsel has not yet seen the records. How should this statement be characterized?

    1. Permissible, because opposing counsel is expected to verify claims independently.
    2. Misconduct, because it is a knowingly false statement of material fact. Correct answer.
    3. Permissible, because settlement demands are not statements of fact.
    4. Misconduct, but only if the case goes to trial and the figure is repeated there.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.4(c) prohibits a lawyer from engaging in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, and Rule 4.1 forbids knowingly making a false statement of material fact to a third person. The amount of documented medical expense is a verifiable fact, not the kind of negotiable puffery about value that the rules tolerate. The violation occurs when the false statement is made, not only if it is later repeated at trial.

  194. Question 194Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A partner in a law firm repeatedly makes unwelcome sexual comments to a paralegal and hints that her assignments depend on how she responds to his advances. The paralegal does not quit. How should the partner's conduct be evaluated under the Model Rules?

    1. No violation, because the conduct occurred inside a private law firm.
    2. No violation, because the paralegal is an employee rather than a client.
    3. A violation, because it is knowingly harassing conduct related to the practice of law. Correct answer.
    4. A violation only if the paralegal leaves the firm as a result of the conduct.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.4(g) makes it misconduct for a lawyer to engage in conduct related to the practice of law that the lawyer knows or reasonably should know is harassment or discrimination on the basis of sex and other listed characteristics. A law firm's own personnel decisions and working conditions are conduct related to the practice of law. The violation does not depend on whether the target resigns.

  195. Question 195Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer pleads guilty to misdemeanor shoplifting at a local store. The offense had nothing to do with any client matter and no jail sentence is imposed. May the lawyer be disciplined?

    1. Yes, because the offense reflects adversely on the lawyer's honesty and fitness. Correct answer.
    2. No, because the offense was a misdemeanor rather than a felony.
    3. Yes, but only if a court imposes a jail sentence as part of the disposition.
    4. No, because the conduct was unrelated to any representation of a client.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.4(b) provides that it is misconduct for a lawyer to commit a criminal act that reflects adversely on the lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer. Theft offenses bear directly on honesty, and the rule applies whether the crime is a felony or a misdemeanor. Discipline does not depend on the conduct occurring in the course of representing a client.

  196. Question 196Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer licensed only in State A moves to State B, opens an office there, and systematically represents State B clients on State B matters without associating a State B lawyer or seeking admission pro hac vice. How should this practice be evaluated?

    1. Improper, because it constitutes unauthorized practice of law in State B. Correct answer.
    2. Proper, as long as each client consents in writing after full disclosure.
    3. Proper, because lawyers licensed in any state may practice throughout the country.
    4. Improper, unless the lawyer limits the practice to matters of federal law.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.5(a) prohibits a lawyer from practicing law in a jurisdiction in violation of that jurisdiction's regulation of the legal profession. Establishing a systematic and continuous office practice in a state where the lawyer is not admitted, without any recognized temporary-practice or pro hac vice basis, is unauthorized practice. Client consent cannot cure the absence of licensure.

  197. Question 197Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer learns that her paralegal has been giving legal advice directly to clients and setting fees without any lawyer review. What is the lawyer's obligation?

    1. The lawyer must take reasonable steps to remedy the conduct and ensure future compliance. Correct answer.
    2. Nothing, because the paralegal acted without the lawyer's knowledge.
    3. Nothing, because nonlawyer misconduct is never attributed to a lawyer.
    4. The lawyer must fire the paralegal and report her to the disciplinary authority.

    Explanation

    Rule 5.3 requires a lawyer with managerial authority to make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures in place giving reasonable assurance that nonlawyer conduct is compatible with the professional obligations of a lawyer, and to take reasonable remedial action for conduct the lawyer knows about. The remedy is corrective supervision, not automatic dismissal and reporting. A nonlawyer's misconduct is not imputed to the lawyer, but the duty to remediate is personal.

  198. Question 198Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A senior associate learns that another associate has been billing clients for hours she did not work. The senior associate says nothing and the conduct continues for months. Is the senior associate subject to discipline?

    1. Yes, but only if she personally shared in the improper fees that were billed.
    2. Yes, because a lawyer who knows of misconduct must take reasonable remedial action. Correct answer.
    3. No, because only the firm's managing partner bears responsibility for billing practices.
    4. No, because she was only an associate and had no supervisory role over the other lawyer.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 5.1(c), a lawyer is responsible for another lawyer's violation of the rules if the lawyer orders or ratifies the conduct, or knows of the conduct and fails to take reasonable remedial action in the circumstances. The duty is not confined to formal supervisors or managing partners; knowledge plus inaction suffices. The associate need not have profited from the overbilling.

  199. Question 199Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    A lawyer receives a lawful written demand for information from the state disciplinary authority about a pending grievance. The lawyer tells his assistant to say he is unavailable, and he never responds. How should this be evaluated?

    1. Misconduct, because it is a failure to respond to a lawful demand. Correct answer.
    2. Misconduct, but only if the underlying grievance later proves to be well founded.
    3. Proper, because the demand was not a court subpoena.
    4. Proper, if the lawyer invokes his privilege against self-incrimination.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.1(b) makes it misconduct for a lawyer to knowingly fail to respond to a lawful demand for information from a disciplinary authority, subject only to a claim of privilege or confidentiality protected by Rule 1.6. Disciplinary investigations do not require a court subpoena, and the duty to cooperate does not turn on the merits of the underlying grievance.

  200. Question 200Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

    During a contentious negotiation, a lawyer tells opposing counsel, "I have the judge in my pocket, so you should settle now." The lawyer has no such influence. How should the statement be evaluated?

    1. Misconduct, because it implies an ability to influence the judge improperly. Correct answer.
    2. Proper, unless the lawyer actually has influence over the judge's decisions.
    3. Proper, because the statement was made to opposing counsel rather than to a client or the judge.
    4. Misconduct, but only if the statement was made in open court.

    Explanation

    Rule 8.4(e) prohibits a lawyer from stating or implying an ability to influence improperly a government agency or official. Claiming to control a judge's ruling is precisely the kind of statement the rule targets, and it violates the rule even when the claim is empty boasting. The rule applies to private communications, not just statements in court.

MPRE flashcards

32 cards. Read the term and the definition here. The deck at the top of this page is optional.

Reciprocal discipline
A state may impose discipline on a lawyer already disciplined elsewhere, usually the same sanction, unless the lawyer shows a due-process violation or other reason for different treatment.
Unauthorized practice of law
A lawyer may not practice in a jurisdiction where not admitted, establish an office there, or assist a nonlawyer in activities that constitute the practice of law.
Bar admission candor
An applicant for admission must disclose requested information and may not make a false statement of material fact or omit facts necessary to make a statement not misleading.
Client-lawyer relationship
It arises when a person manifests an intent for a lawyer to provide legal services and the lawyer knows or reasonably should know of that intent; a formal retainer or fee is not required.
Contingent fee writing
A contingent-fee agreement must be in writing and signed by the client, state the percentage or method of calculation, and explain expenses and whether they are deducted before or after the fee.
Contingent fee prohibition
A lawyer may not charge a contingent fee in a criminal matter or in a domestic-relations matter if the fee is contingent on securing a divorce, the amount of alimony, or a property settlement.
Trust account commingling
Client funds must be held in a separate trust account, kept separate from the lawyer's own funds, with records preserving client funds and prompt notice and delivery to the client.
Confidentiality Rule 1.6
A lawyer may not reveal information relating to the representation of a client without informed consent, except as impliedly authorized or as a specific exception permits.
Privilege versus confidentiality
Evidentiary privilege protects confidential client-lawyer communications made for legal advice; ethical confidentiality is broader and covers all information relating to the representation, whether or not privileged.
Crime-fraud exception
Privilege does not protect client-lawyer communications made to enable or further a crime or fraud, and a lawyer may reveal information to prevent or mitigate certain client financial crimes.
Former client confidentiality
The duty not to reveal information relating to a representation continues after the client-lawyer relationship ends and applies to information learned during the former representation.
Current client conflict
A lawyer may represent a client despite a conflict only if the lawyer reasonably believes competent and diligent representation is possible, the law does not prohibit it, and each affected client gives informed consent in writing.
Directly adverse clients
A lawyer ordinarily may not represent two clients in the same matter whose interests are directly adverse, even if the matters are unrelated, without informed consent confirmed in writing from each client.
Former client substantially related
A lawyer may not represent a person materially adverse to a former client in the same or a substantially related matter without informed consent, and may not use the former client's confidential information.
Prospective client screening
A lawyer who learns information from a prospective client may be screened to avoid disqualifying the firm if the lawyer took reasonable measures to avoid exposure and discloses no confidential information.
Competence
Competence requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation, including inquiry into and analysis of the relevant facts and law.
Legal malpractice elements
A malpractice plaintiff must prove the lawyer owed a duty, breached the standard of care, the breach caused harm, and actual damages resulted; expert testimony is often required.
Third-party liability
A lawyer generally owes no malpractice duty to a nonclient, but may be liable when the nonclient is an intended beneficiary or the lawyer commits fraud or negligent misrepresentation.
Frivolous claim
A lawyer may not bring or defend a proceeding without a basis in law and fact that is not frivolous, and must disclose controlling adverse authority not disclosed by opposing counsel.
Candor to tribunal
A lawyer may not make a false statement of fact or law to a tribunal, offer false evidence, or fail to correct a false statement of material fact or law previously made.
Ex parte communication
A lawyer may not communicate ex parte with a judge, juror, or court official about a pending matter except as authorized by law or court order.
Represented person contact
A lawyer may not communicate about the subject of a representation with a person the lawyer knows is represented by another lawyer, unless that lawyer consents or law authorizes the communication.
Unrepresented person
When dealing with an unrepresented person, a lawyer may not state or imply that the lawyer is disinterested and must correct any misunderstanding about the lawyer's role in the matter.
Witness compensation
A lawyer may pay a witness reasonable expenses but may not pay compensation contingent on the content of testimony or on the outcome of the case.
Duty to report misconduct
A lawyer who knows another lawyer violated a rule raising a substantial question about honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness must report it, except for information learned in an approved lawyer assistance program.
Pro bono service
Model Rule 6.1 states that every lawyer should aspire to provide at least fifty hours of pro bono legal services per year, primarily to persons of limited means or organizations serving them.
Discriminatory conduct
Model Rule 8.4(g) prohibits a lawyer from engaging in conduct related to the practice of law that constitutes discrimination or harassment based on protected characteristics.
Judicial disqualification
A judge must disqualify when the judge's impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including personal bias, a financial interest, or a family member's involvement as party or lawyer.
Judicial gifts
A judge may not accept gifts, loans, favors, or other things of value if they would appear to influence the judge, subject to narrow exceptions such as ordinary social hospitality and de minimis items.
Judicial political activity
A judge may not hold office in a political organization, make speeches on behalf of a political organization, or publicly endorse or oppose a candidate for public office, subject to limited exceptions.
Rule 8.4 misconduct
It is professional misconduct to violate the rules, commit a criminal act reflecting adversely on fitness, engage in dishonesty or fraud, or engage in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.
Firm supervisory duty
Partners and lawyers with managerial authority must make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures giving reasonable assurance that all lawyers conform to the professional conduct rules.

MPRE study guide

Regulation of the Legal Profession

Sources of authority

MPRE questions here test who regulates lawyers and how far a license reaches. The ABA Model Rules bind only as adopted by a jurisdiction's highest court; numbering and text vary by state, and discipline is administered by the court through bar authorities. Under Model Rule 8.5, a lawyer is subject to the ethics rules of the jurisdiction where the conduct occurs, and to the tribunal's rules for conduct connected with a matter pending before it.

Rule 5.5 - unauthorized practice

A lawyer admitted in one state may not establish an office, hold out as admitted, or practice law in another. The recognized exceptions:

  • Pro hac vice: temporary admission for a particular case, usually with local counsel.
  • Temporary practice under 5.5(c): services arising out of or reasonably related to the lawyer's practice where admitted; services with an admitted lawyer in a matter pending before a tribunal; ADR proceedings; and other temporary services per local rule.
  • Registered in-house counsel: a lawyer employed by a single corporate employer may practice if registered with the local bar.

A lawyer also may not assist a nonlawyer in the unauthorized practice of law (5.5(b)) - think of a partnership with a nonlawyer-owned document-preparation service.

Traps

Candidates assume the Model Rules are self-executing, assume a lawyer may never work across state lines, and assume in-house counsel need no registration. Rule 5.5 binds lawyers, not only nonlawyers.

Worked example

A lawyer admitted only in State A, practicing there, travels to State B to negotiate one contract for a State A client. That is permitted temporary practice under 5.5(c)(1). Opening a State B office and advertising for State B clients would violate 5.5(a).

Rule of thumb: ask three questions - where is the lawyer admitted, where is the conduct, and does an exception fit?

The Client-Lawyer Relationship

Formation and scope

No writing or fee is needed to create a client relationship; a person who reasonably believes the lawyer is representing her may be a client. Rule 1.2 allocates authority: the client sets the objectives, the lawyer controls the means. Decisions reserved to the client include whether to settle, what plea to enter, whether to testify, whether to waive a jury, and whether to appeal. Scope may be limited (unbundled representation) if the client gives informed consent and the limited matter can still be handled competently.

Fees and property

Rule 1.5 requires fees to be reasonable and explained, preferably in writing and mandatorily so for contingent fees. Contingent fees are barred in criminal cases and in domestic-relations matters where the fee depends on securing a divorce, alimony, or child support. Under Rule 1.15, client and third-party funds go into a trust account, are not commingled with the lawyer's money (small bank charges aside), and disputed portions stay put until the dispute is resolved. Client papers and property must be returned on request.

Ending the relationship

Rule 1.16 makes withdrawal mandatory when continuing would violate a rule or law or when the lawyer is discharged; it is permissive for good cause, such as nonpayment or the client's crime or fraud, but not if withdrawal would materially prejudice the client, and court leave is required during litigation.

Traps

Labels like "nonrefundable retainer" do not defeat the duty to refund unearned fees; a client may discharge the lawyer at any time, for any reason or none; and a lawyer cannot settle a case over the client's objection simply because the offer is good.

Worked example

A client insists on accepting a modest settlement the lawyer considers inadequate. The client decides; the lawyer may advise and document the file, but cannot refuse to settle.

Client Confidentiality

The duty and its breadth

Rule 1.6 bars revealing information relating to the representation. It is broader than the attorney-client privilege: it covers all information gained in the professional relationship, whatever its source, and it survives the end of the representation. Privilege protects only confidential communications made to obtain legal advice and can be waived; confidentiality is an ongoing ethical duty owed to the client. Related obligations: Rule 1.9(c) (former clients), Rule 1.8(b) (no use of client information to the client's disadvantage), and Rule 4.4(b) (notify the sender of inadvertently produced documents).

Exceptions are permissive

The lawyer may reveal information, limited to what is necessary, to:

  • prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm;
  • prevent a client's crime or fraud reasonably certain to cause substantial financial injury to another, in furtherance of which the lawyer's services were used;
  • prevent, mitigate, or rectify such financial injury;
  • obtain ethics advice;
  • establish a claim or defense in a dispute with the client, or respond to allegations;
  • comply with law or a court order.

Disclosure is generally permitted, not required. The exception is when another rule commands candor, chiefly Rule 3.3, which overrides 1.6.

Traps

Candidates assume disclosure of a future crime is mandatory; forget that the crime-fraud exception requires that the lawyer's services were used in the fraud; assume the duty ends with the representation; or confuse privilege with confidentiality.

Worked example

A client admits she shredded documents before hiring the lawyer for an unrelated matter. The lawyer's services were not used in the fraud, and no rule requires disclosure; she may not reveal the information. If she later discovers the client intends to testify falsely, Rule 3.3 governs and can require remedial steps.

Conflicts of Interest

Concurrent versus former clients

Rule 1.7(a) defines a concurrent conflict two ways: representation of one client will be directly adverse to another client, or there is a significant risk the representation will be materially limited by responsibilities to another client, a former client, a third person, or a personal interest. A concurrent conflict is curable by informed consent, confirmed in writing, if the lawyer reasonably believes she can provide competent and diligent representation, the representation is not prohibited by law, the clients are not asserting claims against each other in the same litigation, and no client is represented by another lawyer in the matter as a result.

Rule 1.9 governs former clients: no representation in the same or a substantially related matter in which the new client's interests are materially adverse to the former client without that client's informed written consent, and no use of the former client's confidences to her disadvantage.

Imputation

Rule 1.10 imputes a lawyer's disqualification to the entire firm, but screening with written notice may cure a lateral hire's former-client conflict where the lawyer was not substantially involved. Government lawyers (1.11) and judges, arbitrators, and mediators (1.12) are screened rather than imputed.

Rule 1.8 highlights

Business transactions with a client require terms fair and fully disclosed in writing, informed written consent, and a reasonable chance to seek independent counsel; no gifts procured by undue influence and no drafting an instrument giving the lawyer a gift; third-party payers and aggregate settlements require consent; malpractice liability may be limited only with independent counsel for the client.

Traps

Oral consent is not enough; dropping a client mid-matter to convert a concurrent conflict into a former-client conflict ("hot potato") fails; screening does not cure every conflict.

Worked example

Two long-standing corporate clients ask the firm to litigate against each other. Consent in writing from both is necessary, and unavailable if consent would be unreasonable.

Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

The competence standard

Rule 1.1 requires legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation - not perfection or specialization. A general practitioner may accept an unfamiliar matter by studying the law or associating experienced counsel. Rules 1.3 (diligence) and 1.4 (communication) supply companion duties.

Malpractice

Legal malpractice is a civil claim; a disciplinary violation is a separate matter. Malpractice requires duty, breach, actual and proximate causation, and damages. The client must show that but for the error the outcome would have been better - in litigation, a "case within a case" proving the underlying claim would have succeeded and produced a collectible judgment. Expert testimony is generally required to establish the standard of care, unless the error is plain enough for lay jurors to recognize.

Liability to nonclients

Absent privity, a nonclient may recover for fraud or negligent misrepresentation when the lawyer supplies information for the guidance of others in their business transactions and the plaintiff justifiably relies (Restatement 552). Classic fact patterns: opinion letters, title work, and estate plans that fail the intended beneficiary. Rule 4.1 bars false statements of material fact or law to third persons, and Rule 8.4(c) bars dishonesty - discipline needs no damages, while civil liability does.

Traps

Equating negligence with discipline (discipline normally requires gross negligence, recklessness, or intentional misconduct); ignoring reliance as an element; assuming a lawyer is answerable to every person her work touches. Rule 1.8(h) permits limiting prospective malpractice liability only if the client is independently represented.

Rule of thumb

For any malpractice fact pattern, ask: what was the duty, what did the lawyer do, would the outcome have differed, and who was entitled to rely?

Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

Meritorious claims and candor

Rule 3.1 bars frivolous claims, but a lawyer may advocate in good faith for extending or reversing existing law. Rule 3.2 requires reasonable efforts to expedite litigation consistent with the client's interests. Rule 3.3 is the heart of this domain: no false statements of fact or law, a duty to correct a false statement the lawyer previously made, and a duty to disclose directly adverse controlling authority in the governing jurisdiction that opposing counsel has not disclosed. In ex parte proceedings the lawyer must disclose all material facts known that might affect the tribunal's decision.

If the lawyer discovers she has offered material evidence she knows is false, she must take reasonable remedial measures, including disclosure to the tribunal if necessary - even if that requires revealing confidential information. Rules 3.3 overrides 1.6 and continues to the conclusion of the proceeding, so withdrawal alone does not cure it.

Fairness and decorum

Rule 3.4 prohibits unlawfully obstructing access to evidence, falsifying or destroying evidence, counseling perjury, frivolous discovery, and asking a nonclient to withhold relevant information voluntarily. Rule 3.5 preserves impartiality and decorum and bars ex parte contact with judges and jurors. Rule 3.6 bans extrajudicial statements the lawyer knows or should know will be publicly disseminated and create a substantial likelihood of material prejudice; safe-harbor statements about the record, scheduling, and the like are allowed. Rule 3.7 bars acting as advocate at trial when the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness, with narrow exceptions such as uncontested issues or substantial hardship.

Traps

Assuming withdrawal erases a candor problem; assuming confidentiality shields false testimony; missing the rule that adverse authority must be disclosed even when opposing counsel is silent.

Worked example

A client insists he will testify falsely. The lawyer must try to persuade him, may seek to withdraw, and may disclose the perjury to the tribunal only to the extent necessary.

Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

Truthfulness

Rule 4.1 forbids false statements of material fact or law to a third person and forbids failing to disclose a material fact when disclosure is necessary to avoid assisting a client's criminal or fraudulent act (unless Rule 1.6 forbids it). There is no duty to help the adversary: negotiating positions and puffery are permissible, but misstating facts, law, or the lawyer's authority to settle is not.

Represented persons

Rule 4.2 bars communicating about the subject of the representation with a person the lawyer knows to be represented, unless the other lawyer consents or the law or a court order authorizes it - service of process and legally authorized investigations are examples. The rule covers persons the lawyer reasonably should know are represented. In organizations, contact with employees is restricted when the employee's acts may bind the entity or the employee's statements may be admissions, or when the employee may possess privileged information.

Unrepresented persons

Rule 4.3 requires the lawyer to correct any misunderstanding that the lawyer is disinterested, to avoid giving legal advice other than to obtain counsel, and to make clear the lawyer's role. Negotiating and drafting documents for an unrepresented person remains permissible, but fairness demands clarity about whose interests the lawyer serves.

Third persons generally

Rule 4.4 prohibits means having no substantial purpose other than to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person, and prohibits obtaining evidence by violating a legal privilege. If a lawyer receives a document she knows was inadvertently sent, she must promptly notify the sender.

Traps

Accepting a represented party's own "consent" to talk; assuming every corporate employee is off limits; failing to send the inadvertent-disclosure notice; believing that a truthful statement can never violate 4.1.

Worked example

An opposing party who is represented telephones the lawyer to discuss the case. The lawyer must decline to discuss the matter and should tell the party to contact her own lawyer.

The Profession and the Public

Advertising

Rule 7.1 prohibits false or misleading communications, including true statements that create a misleading impression through omission, unverifiable comparisons, or implied specialization outside certified fields (see Rule 7.4). Rule 7.2 permits advertising but bars giving anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer or for a referral. Exceptions include nominal gifts, bona fide employees, giving the client a copy of the file, paying for advertising, and payments to qualified nonprofit lawyer referral services that do not charge fees based on amounts recovered.

Solicitation

Rule 7.3 bars in-person, live telephone, and real-time electronic solicitation of a specific person when a significant motive is pecuniary gain, unless the person solicited is a lawyer or has a family or prior professional relationship with the lawyer. Written and recorded solicitations targeted at a person known to need legal services must be labeled "Advertising Material" on the outside. Soliciting persons known to be incapacitated or vulnerable is prohibited.

Names, letterhead, and public service

Rule 7.5 permits trade names but bars misleading firm names, including names implying a partnership that does not exist or implying a lawyer is admitted in a jurisdiction where she is not. Rule 6.1 sets an aspirational goal of at least 50 hours of pro bono service yearly, with most of it without fee and a portion to persons of limited means; Rule 6.2 discourages seeking to avoid court appointments except for good cause. Rules 5.1 to 5.3 require reasonable supervision of subordinate lawyers and nonlawyer staff, on whose conduct a lawyer may be disciplined if she orders or ratifies it.

Traps

A communication can be literally true and still violate 7.1; paying a marketing consultant per signed client is a referral payment; only live, real-time solicitation with a pecuniary motive is banned, not all outreach.

Worked example

A firm promises a chiropractor $500 per client referred. That is an impermissible payment for recommendation under 7.2(b).

Judicial Conduct

The framework

Judicial ethics questions are governed by the canons of judicial conduct: independence, impartiality, integrity, and the avoidance of impropriety and its appearance in all activities. A judge must uphold the law, perform duties competently and diligently, be patient and courteous, and maintain order and decorum in proceedings. A judge may not practice law, may not use the judicial office to advance private interests, and may not belong to organizations that practice invidious discrimination.

Ex parte contacts and recusal

Rule 2.9 restricts ex parte communications, allowing only ministerial, scheduling, or emergency matters, and requires the judge to disclose such communications and give the other side an opportunity to respond. A judge must disqualify herself when she has a personal bias or prejudice concerning a party or a party's lawyer, personal knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts, prior involvement as a lawyer or material witness, or a financial interest in the subject matter or a party. Remittal of disqualification by the parties' agreement is available in some circumstances; the judge need not step aside merely because a party moves for recusal.

Extrajudicial and political activity

A judge may write, speak, teach, and serve as a fiduciary in limited circumstances, but may not personally participate in fundraising, may accept only gifts that do not create an appearance problem, and is restricted in partisan political activity. Campaign committees may solicit contributions; the judge may not personally solicit or accept them, and may not make pledges inconsistent with impartiality.

Traps

Assuming every motion to recuse must be granted; forgetting that disclosure plus an opportunity to respond can cure an inadvertent ex parte contact; assuming judicial candidates may campaign like other politicians.

Worked example

A party mails the judge an unsolicited letter about the merits. The judge should not rely on it, must disclose it to the other side, and should allow a response.

Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

Reporting misconduct

Rule 8.3 requires a lawyer who knows of another lawyer's violation raising a substantial question as to honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness to inform the appropriate professional authority. There is no duty for minor violations, and Rule 8.3(c) forbids disclosing information protected by Rule 1.6 without the client's consent - so a client's confidences cannot be reported. A lawyer also may not use the reporting process to gain litigation advantage.

Bar admission and misconduct

Rule 8.1 requires candor in bar admission and disciplinary matters: no false statements of material fact, no knowing failure to respond to a lawful demand, and no misuse of the process. Rule 8.4 defines misconduct: violating or attempting to violate a rule, knowingly assisting another to do so, committing a criminal act reflecting adversely on honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness, engaging in dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, engaging in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice, knowingly assisting a judge or public officer in violating judicial rules, and conduct the lawyer knows or should know is harassment or discrimination on protected grounds.

Supervision

Rule 5.1 requires partners and managers to establish measures giving reasonable assurance of firm-wide conformity. Rule 5.3 requires lawyers to instruct and supervise nonlawyers and makes a lawyer responsible for a nonlawyer's conduct when she orders or ratifies it. Rule 5.2 makes clear a subordinate lawyer must follow the rules even when a supervisor directs otherwise.

Traps

Assuming the disciplinary system will catch misconduct without a report; assuming an impaired colleague must always be reported (impairment alone, without dishonesty, is generally handled through assistance programs); assuming Rule 8.4(c) requires that someone relied on the lie or suffered loss - it does not.

Worked example

A lawyer discovers a partner notarized a signature he did not witness, in order to close a deal. That raises a substantial question about honesty, so reporting is required if the lawyer can do so without revealing client confidences.

MPRE cheat sheet

Quick reference

Regulation of the Legal Profession

  • A lawyer admitted in another U.S. jurisdiction may provide legal services on a temporary basis in a jurisdiction where not admitted if the services arise out of or are reasonably related to the lawyer's practice in a jurisdiction where admitted, or are associated with a lawyer admitted in the host jurisdiction.

  • A lawyer may not establish an office in a jurisdiction where not admitted or hold out to the public as admitted there; doing so constitutes unauthorized practice.

  • Discipline may include disbarment, suspension, reprimand, probation, restitution, and required CLE; it is separate from civil liability and criminal prosecution.

  • Reciprocal discipline: a state may impose the same discipline imposed elsewhere unless the lawyer shows a due-process violation or other ground; it may impose different discipline if warranted.

  • An admission applicant must disclose requested information and may not make false statements of material fact or omit facts necessary to correct a misleading statement.

  • A lawyer may not form a partnership with a nonlawyer if any partnership activity consists of practicing law, and may not share legal fees with a nonlawyer except for permitted arrangements such as death payments, referral services, and profit-sharing with employees.

  • A lawyer must not assist a nonlawyer in activities constituting unauthorized practice of law.

  • A lawyer may be disciplined for conduct outside the practice of law if it involves dishonesty, fraud, deceit, misrepresentation, or conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.

Quick reference

The Client-Lawyer Relationship

  • A client-lawyer relationship arises when a person manifests intent for a lawyer to provide legal services and the lawyer knows or reasonably should know of that intent; no formal retainer or fee is required.

  • A fee agreement must be communicated before or within a reasonable time after commencing representation; a contingent fee must be in a writing signed by the client.

  • A contingent fee is prohibited in criminal matters and in domestic-relations matters when the fee is contingent on securing a divorce, alimony amount, or property settlement.

  • Fee reasonableness considers time and labor, novelty and difficulty, skill required, customary fee, amount at stake, results obtained, time limits, experience, and whether the fee is fixed or contingent.

  • A client may discharge a lawyer at any time, subject to payment for services already rendered; the lawyer must withdraw if continued representation violates a rule or the lawyer is physically or mentally unable to continue.

  • A lawyer may withdraw only if it can be accomplished without material adverse effect on the client's interests, or for good cause such as client crime or fraud, failure to pay, or unreasonable burden.

  • Client funds must be held in a trust account separate from the lawyer's funds; commingling is prohibited, and the lawyer must keep records and promptly notify and deliver client funds.

  • A lawyer may limit the scope of representation if the client gives informed consent, but may not limit the lawyer's duty of competence or the client's rights to the extent the limitation is unreasonable.

Quick reference

Client Confidentiality

  • Rule 1.6 prohibits revealing information relating to the representation without informed consent, except when impliedly authorized or an exception applies.

  • Permitted disclosures include preventing reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm, preventing a client crime or fraud reasonably certain to cause substantial financial injury, and mitigating such injury.

  • Other exceptions include defending against a legal claim or disciplinary charge, complying with law or court order, seeking advice about compliance, and resolving conflicts in certain limited circumstances.

  • Confidentiality is broader than attorney-client privilege: it covers all information relating to the representation, while privilege protects confidential communications made for legal advice.

  • Privilege does not protect communications made to enable or further a crime or fraud, or information the client already knows or discloses to third parties.

  • A disclosure permitted by an exception must be no broader than reasonably necessary to accomplish the purpose.

  • The duty of confidentiality continues after the representation ends and applies to former clients.

  • A lawyer may not use confidential information to the disadvantage of the client or for the lawyer's own benefit without informed consent.

Quick reference

Conflicts of Interest

  • For a concurrent conflict, the lawyer must reasonably believe competent and diligent representation is possible, the representation is not prohibited by law, the representation does not involve asserting a claim by one client against another in the same litigation, and each affected client gives informed consent confirmed in writing.

  • Directly adverse representation of two clients in the same matter requires informed consent confirmed in writing even if the matters are unrelated.

  • Former client: no representation materially adverse in the same or a substantially related matter without informed consent, and no use of confidential information.

  • Prospective client: if information was received, the lawyer may not represent a materially adverse party in the same or a substantially related matter; the firm may avoid imputation by timely screening and nondisclosure.

  • A business transaction with a client requires terms that are fair and reasonable, full disclosure in writing, written advice to seek independent counsel, and informed consent confirmed in writing.

  • A lawyer may not prepare an instrument giving the lawyer or a person related to the lawyer a substantial gift, except for a lawyer related to the client as parent, child, sibling, or spouse.

  • A lawyer may not acquire a proprietary interest in the cause of action or subject of litigation, except a lien to secure fees and expenses and a reasonable contingent fee.

  • A lawyer may accept payment from a third party if the client gives informed consent, the payer does not interfere with professional judgment, and client information remains protected.

  • A lawyer may not have a sexual relationship with a current client unless a consensual relationship existed before the representation began.

Quick reference

Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties

  • Competence requires legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary, including inquiry into the relevant facts and law.

  • Diligence requires reasonable promptness and commitment to the matter.

  • Malpractice elements are duty, breach of the standard of care, causation, and actual damages.

  • Expert testimony on the standard of care is generally required except when the lawyer's conduct is so obviously negligent that a layperson can evaluate it.

  • A lawyer generally owes no duty to nonclients, but liability may arise for intended beneficiaries of estate planning, fraud, or negligent misrepresentation.

  • A violation of an ethics rule does not by itself create civil liability, but it may be evidence of the standard of care.

  • Supervisory lawyers must make reasonable efforts to ensure subordinate conduct conforms to the rules; a subordinate who acts at a supervisor's reasonable direction is not disciplined.

  • A lawyer must keep the client reasonably informed and promptly communicate settlement offers and significant developments.

Quick reference

Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

  • A lawyer may not assert or defend a claim without a basis in law and fact that is not frivolous.

  • A lawyer must disclose controlling legal authority known to the lawyer that is directly adverse and not disclosed by opposing counsel.

  • Candor requires correcting false statements of material fact or law previously made to the tribunal and taking reasonable remedial measures for client fraud.

  • A lawyer may not communicate ex parte with a judge or juror about a pending matter except as authorized by law or court order.

  • A lawyer may not communicate about the subject of a representation with a represented person without the consent of that person's lawyer, unless law authorizes the communication.

  • A lawyer may not communicate with a juror after trial to harass or influence; permitted communications must comply with court orders and law.

  • Trial publicity that creates a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing an adjudicative proceeding is prohibited; statements about evidence, credibility, and guilt may constitute prejudice.

  • A lawyer may not act as advocate at trial when the lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness, except when testimony is uncontested, about legal services, or hardship would result.

  • A prosecutor must disclose exculpatory evidence and may not prosecute without probable cause.

Quick reference

Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

  • A lawyer may not communicate about the subject of a representation with a represented person without consent of that person's lawyer, unless law or a court order authorizes.

  • When dealing with an unrepresented person, a lawyer may not state or imply disinterest and must correct misunderstandings about the lawyer's role.

  • A lawyer may pay a witness reasonable expenses but may not pay contingent compensation for testimony.

  • A lawyer may not engage in dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation in dealings with third persons.

  • In-person or real-time electronic solicitation is prohibited when the lawyer's motive is pecuniary gain, unless the target is a lawyer or has a prior professional relationship with the lawyer.

  • Written or recorded advertising must be labeled as advertising material if it is targeted solicitation and must not be false or misleading.

  • A lawyer may not give anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer's services, except permitted referral-service fees, nominal gifts, and certain employee arrangements.

  • A law firm name may not be false or misleading, and a firm may not imply that it is a partnership with a nonlawyer.

Quick reference

The Profession and the Public

  • Model Rule 6.1 sets an aspirational target of at least 50 hours of pro bono legal services per year, primarily for persons of limited means.

  • A lawyer must report another lawyer's violation that raises a substantial question about honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness, unless the information is learned in an approved lawyer assistance program.

  • A lawyer may not engage in conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, misrepresentation, or conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.

  • A lawyer may not engage in conduct related to the practice of law that constitutes discrimination or harassment based on protected characteristics.

  • A lawyer may not use means having no substantial purpose other than to embarrass, delay, or burden a third person.

  • A lawyer may not commit a criminal act that reflects adversely on honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer.

  • The legal profession is largely self-regulating, and lawyers have duties to improve the legal system and ensure access to justice.

Quick reference

Judicial Conduct

  • A judge must uphold the integrity and independence of the judiciary and avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety.

  • A judge must perform judicial duties impartially, competently, promptly, and without bias or prejudice.

  • A judge must disqualify when impartiality might reasonably be questioned, including personal bias, knowledge of disputed facts, financial interest, or family involvement.

  • A judge may not accept gifts, loans, favors, or things of value that would appear to influence the judge, subject to narrow exceptions.

  • A judge may engage in extrajudicial activities that do not conflict with judicial duties, but may not practice law or serve as a fiduciary for a business.

  • A judge may not hold office in a political organization or publicly endorse or oppose candidates for public office, subject to limited exceptions.

  • A judge may not make public comments about pending or impending proceedings that might affect the outcome or impair impartiality.

  • Judicial campaign conduct must be consistent with judicial independence and impartiality, and candidates may not solicit or accept certain contributions.

Quick reference

Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

  • Rule 8.4 defines misconduct to include violating the rules, committing a criminal act reflecting adversely on fitness, dishonesty or fraud, and conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.

  • A lawyer may not assist a judge or public officer in conduct the lawyer knows violates the judge's or officer's rules.

  • A lawyer may not state or imply an ability to influence improperly a government agency or official or to achieve results by improper means.

  • A lawyer who knows of another lawyer's misconduct raising a substantial question about honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness must report it, with exceptions for approved assistance programs.

  • Partners and managers must make reasonable efforts to ensure the firm has measures giving reasonable assurance of conformity with the rules.

  • A law practice may be sold only with a written agreement, notice to clients, and compliance with fee and conflict rules; the buyer must be authorized to practice law.

  • A lawyer may not practice law in a firm with a nonlawyer if the firm's activities include practicing law, and may not assist unauthorized practice.

MPRE key terms

Inherent powers doctrine

The principle that courts, rather than legislatures, hold ultimate authority to regulate the practice of law, including admitting and disciplining lawyers, because such regulation is inherent in the judicial function.

Related: Unauthorized practice of law, Model Rules of Professional Conduct
Unauthorized practice of law

Practicing law without a license, or a lawyer helping a nonlawyer do what only a licensed lawyer may do, such as giving legal advice or appearing in court for another person.

Related: Multijurisdictional practice, Inherent powers doctrine
Multijurisdictional practice

A lawyer's temporary or occasional practice of law in a jurisdiction where the lawyer is not admitted, permitted only in limited circumstances such as association with local counsel, arbitration, or work reasonably related to the home practice.

Related: Unauthorized practice of law
Model Rules of Professional Conduct

The American Bar Association's model ethical rules that most states adopt in some form; they govern lawyer conduct and are enforced through state bar disciplinary systems and, in some states, as standards of care.

Related: Inherent powers doctrine, Misconduct under Rule 8.4
Character and fitness review

The bar admission inquiry into an applicant's honesty, financial responsibility, and past conduct, including criminal, academic, and employment history, used to predict whether the applicant can practice law ethically.

Related: Reporting misconduct
Supervisory responsibility

A lawyer's duty to make reasonable efforts to ensure that subordinate lawyers and nonlawyer assistants in the firm comply with the rules of professional conduct.

Related: Reporting misconduct, Misconduct under Rule 8.4
Attorney-client relationship

The fiduciary relationship formed when a person reasonably relies on a lawyer to provide legal services; it can arise by express agreement or by implication and triggers duties of competence, loyalty, and confidentiality.

Related: Scope of representation, Confidential information
Contingent fee

A fee paid only if the representation produces a recovery, usually a percentage of the amount recovered; it must be in writing, reasonable, and is barred in criminal cases and most domestic relations matters.

Related: Advance fee
Trust account

A separate account, often an IOLTA account, where a lawyer holds client or third-party funds; the lawyer must keep individual client records and may not use the money for personal purposes.

Related: Commingling, Advance fee
Commingling

Mixing client funds with the lawyer's own money or with other clients' money in a trust account, which is prohibited except for small amounts needed to cover bank charges.

Related: Trust account
Advance fee

Money paid to a lawyer before work is performed; an advance fee for future services is generally client property that must be held in trust, while a true retainer is earned on receipt.

Related: Trust account, Contingent fee
Mandatory withdrawal

Withdrawal required when continuing representation would violate the rules or other law, for example when the client uses the lawyer's services to commit a crime or fraud.

Related: Scope of representation, Confidential information
Scope of representation

The agreed boundaries of what the lawyer will do for the client; lawyer and client may limit the objectives, and the client normally controls decisions about the goals of the representation.

Related: Allocation of authority, Attorney-client relationship
Allocation of authority

The division of decision-making power: the client decides objectives such as settlement, plea, and whether to testify, while the lawyer decides technical and tactical means after consulting the client.

Related: Scope of representation
Confidential information

All information relating to the representation, whatever its source, that the lawyer may not reveal without informed consent or an applicable exception; it is broader than information protected by privilege.

Related: Attorney-client privilege, Informed consent
Attorney-client privilege

An evidentiary rule, held by the client, that protects confidential communications between client and lawyer made to obtain legal advice from compelled disclosure in legal proceedings.

Related: Confidential information, Work-product doctrine, Crime-fraud exception
Work-product doctrine

A protection for materials a lawyer prepares in anticipation of litigation, disclosable only on a showing of substantial need and undue hardship, with the lawyer's mental impressions receiving nearly absolute protection.

Related: Attorney-client privilege
Crime-fraud exception

The rule that communications otherwise privileged lose protection when the client seeks or uses the lawyer's advice to commit or further a crime or fraud.

Related: Attorney-client privilege
Informed consent

The client's agreement to a course of conduct after the lawyer has communicated adequate information about the material risks and reasonably available alternatives, often required to be confirmed in writing.

Related: Concurrent conflict of interest, Business transaction with client
Concurrent conflict of interest

A conflict between a current client's interests and those of another current client, the lawyer, or a third party; the lawyer may proceed only if representation will not be materially limited and affected clients give informed consent.

Related: Informed consent, Imputed disqualification
Former-client conflict

A conflict arising after representation ends; the lawyer may not represent a new client in the same or a substantially related matter where the former client's confidential information could be used against it, absent informed consent.

Related: Imputed disqualification, Screening
Imputed disqualification

The rule that a conflict of one lawyer in a firm is generally imputed to every lawyer in the firm, disqualifying the entire firm unless the conflict is cured by screening or informed consent.

Related: Screening, Concurrent conflict of interest
Screening

Isolating a conflicted lawyer from a matter, typically by denying access to files and fees, which can prevent imputation of certain conflicts, mainly those involving former government lawyers or lateral hires.

Related: Imputed disqualification
Business transaction with client

A transaction, other than a standard commercial loan or routine fee arrangement, between lawyer and client that requires terms fair to the client, full written disclosure, and the client's informed consent confirmed in writing.

Related: Informed consent
Competence

The duty to provide legal services with the knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary, including keeping up with changes in the law and relevant technology.

Related: Legal malpractice
Legal malpractice

A civil claim that a lawyer failed to use reasonable care and skill, causing the client harm; the client must prove a duty, breach, causation, and actual damages.

Related: Competence, Vicarious liability
Vicarious liability

The principle that a law firm may be held liable for a lawyer's negligent or wrongful acts committed within the scope of the firm's practice, even if other lawyers were not personally at fault.

Related: Legal malpractice
Candor toward the tribunal

The duty not to make false statements of fact or law to a court, to correct prior false statements, and to disclose controlling adverse legal authority, subject to limits protecting confidentiality.

Related: Frivolous claim, Confidential information
Frivolous claim

A claim, defense, or argument that lacks any reasonable basis in law or fact, or is asserted for an improper purpose; presenting one can subject the lawyer to discipline and court sanctions.

Related: Candor toward the tribunal
Trial publicity

The rule limiting a lawyer's extrajudicial statements that a reasonable person would expect to be disseminated and that create a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing an adjudicative proceeding.

Related: Candor toward the tribunal
Communication with represented person

The prohibition on contacting a person the lawyer knows is represented by another lawyer in the matter, absent that other lawyer's consent or authorization by law or court order.

Related: Communication with unrepresented person, Truthfulness to third persons
Communication with unrepresented person

The duty not to state or imply that the lawyer is disinterested, and to correct any misunderstanding about the lawyer's role, when dealing with an unrepresented person whose interests may conflict with the client's.

Related: Communication with represented person
Truthfulness to third persons

The duty not to knowingly make false statements of material fact or law to others, and not to fail to disclose a material fact when disclosure is necessary to avoid assisting a client's crime or fraud.

Related: Communication with unrepresented person, Misconduct under Rule 8.4
Pro bono publico service

Uncompensated legal service to persons of limited means or to organizations addressing their needs; the rules encourage roughly fifty hours per year but do not make such service mandatory.

Related: Solicitation
Solicitation

A lawyer's in-person, live telephone, or real-time electronic contact with a prospective client for pecuniary gain, prohibited when the person has no prior relationship and the contact involves coercion, duress, or harassment.

Related: Pro bono publico service
Judicial disqualification

A judge's duty to step aside when the judge's impartiality might reasonably be questioned, or when the judge has a personal bias, financial interest, or prior involvement in the matter.

Related: Reporting misconduct
Reporting misconduct

A lawyer's duty to inform the appropriate disciplinary authority when the lawyer knows of another lawyer's violation that raises a substantial question about that lawyer's honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness.

Related: Misconduct under Rule 8.4, Supervisory responsibility
Misconduct under Rule 8.4

The catch-all disciplinary rule prohibiting conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation, conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice, and conduct that seriously interferes with the practice of law.

Related: Reporting misconduct, Truthfulness to third persons

MPRE study plan

8 weeks · About 8 hours per week

Week 1

Conflicts of Interest & The Client-Lawyer Relationship

  • Build a written decision tree that sorts any stated conflict into one of three outcomes: prohibited, consentable with informed consent confirmed in writing, or consentable only after written confirmation from each affected client (Rule 1.7).

  • Tabulate the difference between current-client conflicts (Rule 1.7) and former-client conflicts (Rule 1.9) using the 'materially adverse' plus 'substantially related' test, and apply the table to three hypothetical fact patterns you write yourself.

  • Separate decisions reserved to the client (plea, settlement, testimony, objectives of representation under Rule 1.2) from tactical decisions the lawyer may make, and list two consequences of settling without authority.

  • Identify when a personal-interest, business-transaction, or third-party-payor conflict (Rule 1.8, including 1.8(f) and 1.8(j)) bars representation outright rather than merely requiring consent.

  • Explain in your own words the elements and purpose of the lawyer's communication duty under Rule 1.4, including the duty to report a settlement offer.

Your checkpoint

Complete a 30-question timed set (35 minutes) drawn only from Domains 2 and 4, score at least 70%, and rewrite every missed question as a single-sentence rule statement in your error log.

Week 2

Conflicts of Interest & Client Confidentiality

  • Apply Rule 1.10 imputation to at least five scenarios and state precisely when screening or client consent cures an imputed conflict.

  • Distinguish a prospective client's limited protection (Rule 1.18) from a former client's protection (Rule 1.9) in a one-page comparison.

  • List every exception to Rule 1.6 confidentiality and give one fresh, original example of each exception in writing.

  • Contrast the evidentiary attorney-client privilege with the broader ethical duty of confidentiality, naming two disclosures that are ethically permitted but not privileged.

  • Determine when disclosure is permitted to prevent a client's crime involving financial harm or to respond to a lawyer's own legal exposure under Rule 1.6(b).

Your checkpoint

Produce a one-page exceptions chart for Rules 1.6, 1.9(c), and 1.18 with a self-written example per exception, then pass a 25-question confidentiality/conflict quiz at 75% or better.

Week 3

Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy & Regulation of the Legal Profession

  • Apply Rule 3.3 candor obligations to three scenarios involving false testimony, adverse legal authority, and a client's perjury, and state the required remedial step in each.

  • Distinguish conduct barred by Rule 3.4 (fairness to the opposing party) from conduct permitted in adversarial discovery practice.

  • Apply Rules 3.5, 3.6, and 3.7 to fact patterns on ex parte contact with the tribunal, trial publicity, and lawyer-as-witness disqualification.

  • Outline the attorney-disciplinary process from grievance through sanction, and state the reporting duties under Rules 8.1 and 8.3.

  • Identify unauthorized-practice and multijurisdictional-practice limits under Rule 5.5 and the requirements for dividing fees between lawyers under Rule 1.5(e).

Your checkpoint

Complete a 40-question timed set covering Domains 6 and 1, score at least 70%, and categorize every error by rule number in the error log.

Week 4

Competence, Legal Malpractice, and Liability to Third Parties & Transactions and Communications with Persons Other Than Clients

  • State the four elements of a legal-malpractice claim and explain how an ethics violation differs from civil liability.

  • Apply Rules 5.1, 5.2, and 5.3 to assign responsibility among supervising lawyers, subordinate lawyers, and nonlawyer assistants.

  • Analyze a communication with a represented person under Rule 4.2 and an unrepresented person under Rule 4.3, and identify the exact point at which each contact becomes improper.

  • Apply Rule 4.1 truthfulness to negotiations and to disclosures required to avoid assisting a client's fraud.

  • Classify advertisement, solicitation, and live solicitation problems under Rules 7.1 through 7.3, including the targeted-mail and 30-day waiting-period rules.

Your checkpoint

Sit one full-length 60-question timed practice exam (60 minutes) covering mixed domains, score at least 65%, and write a ranked list of your three weakest rule areas.

Week 5

The Profession and the Public & Maintaining the Integrity of the Profession

  • Explain Rule 8.4 misconduct categories, distinguishing conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice from conduct involving dishonesty, fraud, deceit, or misrepresentation.

  • Determine when a lawyer has a mandatory duty to report another lawyer's misconduct under Rule 8.3 and when reporting is discretionary.

  • Apply Rule 6.1 pro bono aspirations, Rule 6.2 appointed-counsel obligations, and Rule 6.3 limitations on accepting third-party evaluations.

  • Re-work the ten items you most often missed in Weeks 1 through 4 until you can state the governing rule without notes.

  • Draft a five-question self-test on Rules 8.1 and 8.3 and answer it closed-book.

Your checkpoint

Write a one-page 'professionalism and integrity' summary sheet covering Rules 8.1, 8.3, 8.4, 6.1, 6.2, 5.1, and 5.2, then pass a 20-question quiz on Domains 8 and 10 at 80% or better.

Week 6

Judicial Conduct & Regulation of the Legal Profession

  • Apply the judicial canons on independence and impartiality to three scenarios on ex parte communications and improper influence.

  • Build a disqualification checklist from the judicial rules on personal bias, financial interest, prior representation, and campaign contributions.

  • Distinguish permissible extrajudicial activities, including business and charitable involvement, from prohibited political activity by a judge or judicial candidate.

  • Re-test your weakest Domain 1 subtopic, chosen from your error log, and confirm mastery with a fresh set of questions.

  • Compare the sanctions available to a judge through the judicial-conduct commission with those available to a lawyer through the disciplinary board.

Your checkpoint

Complete a 30-question judicial-conduct set at 75% or better and finalize a one-page judge-disqualification checklist you can review in five minutes.

Week 7

Conflicts of Interest & Litigation and Other Forms of Advocacy

  • Sit a second full-length 60-question timed exam under strict time pressure (one minute per question) and record a score for every domain.

  • Re-study your two lowest-scoring domains from Week 1 through Week 6, using only the rule text and your error log.

  • Practice 20 'best answer' questions in which two choices are defensible, and articulate why the wrong one fails.

  • Recite from memory the consent requirements for rules that require written confirmation, and check the list against the rule text for gaps.

Your checkpoint

Second full-length timed exam scored at 75% or better, plus a revised error log in which every prior miss is now marked 'resolved' or assigned to a Week 8 review slot.

Week 8

The Client-Lawyer Relationship & Client Confidentiality

  • Run a 60-question timed exam in 60 minutes and score at least 85%.

  • Review the master one-page rule sheet covering all ten domains and fill any remaining gaps identified by the error log.

  • Drill rule-identification speed by naming the governing rule for 30 short fact patterns in under 15 minutes.

  • Rehearse the confidentiality, conflicts, and candor rules one final time, since they carry the most exam weight.

Your checkpoint

A final full-length timed exam at 85% or better, a complete error log with zero unresolved entries, and a single-page master rule sheet used for the final review.

Milestones

Week 2: Both Week 1 and Week 2 quizzes are scored and logged, with an average of at least 72% across Domains 2, 3, and 4.

Week 4: First full-length timed exam completed at 65% or better, with a written ranked list of your three weakest rule areas.

Week 6: Every domain has been drilled at least once; average score across all domain quizzes is 75% or better and the error log contains no repeated rule.

Week 8: Final full-length timed exam scored at 85% or better with all 60 questions answered inside 60 minutes.

MPRE exam day

Your checklist

Government-issued photo ID with your signature

The name on the ID must match your registration exactly. Check that it is unexpired before test day. Confirm the specific acceptable ID forms with your test provider, since rules on expired IDs, paper IDs, and name discrepancies vary.

Appointment confirmation / authorization to test

Bring your scheduling confirmation from the test vendor (and your NCBE registration confirmation). Confirm with the provider whether a printed copy is required or whether an electronic copy on a phone shown at check-in is acceptable before you rely on your phone.

Know your exact test center address and arrival instructions

Look up the address, building entrance, parking or transit options, and the vendor's recommended arrival time. Test centers in office buildings often have confusing lobbies; do a map check the night before.

Plan to arrive early

A common recommendation is to arrive roughly 30 minutes before your appointment to allow for check-in and identity verification. Confirm the exact window with your provider; arriving after the appointment time can result in being turned away.

Know your jurisdiction's passing score

The MPRE scaled score range is 50-150, and each jurisdiction sets its own passing score (commonly in the mid-80s, but some differ). Look up your state's requirement on the jurisdiction's board of law examiners site, not a third-party summary.

Know how and when your score will be released

Scores are released through your NCBE account and reported to jurisdictions you designated. Confirm the current release timeline and whether you can designate additional jurisdictions after the test with the provider.

Leave prohibited items behind

Phones, smartwatches, notes, bags, and study materials are not allowed in the testing room. Most centers provide a small locker; confirm what the locker can hold so you do not bring a large bag.

Confirm any approved testing accommodations

If you requested accommodations, verify in advance that they were approved and how they will be delivered on test day. Accommodation requests generally must be made well before the exam date.

Review the vendor's and NCBE's candidate rules

Read the current candidate/security rules once in the final week so nothing at check-in surprises you (identity verification steps, sign-in procedures, permitted items).

Practice the real format once

Sit a full 60-question, 2-hour timed practice set at least once in the final 72 hours so the pacing (about 2 minutes per question) feels routine.

Know your NCBE account login

You will need it to view your score after the exam. Confirm your credentials work before test day rather than resetting a password weeks later.

Simple comfort items for before the test

Eat a normal meal and hydrate before check-in; food and drink are typically not allowed in the testing room. Confirm the center's policy on water and snacks during check-in.

Plan the day

Final 72 hours

Confirm your appointment date, time, and location with the test vendor, and verify your ID is unexpired with a name that matches your registration. Re-read the candidate rules. Do one full timed 60-question practice set, then spend remaining study time only on your weakest areas (conflicts of interest, confidentiality, fees and division of fees, candor to the tribunal, and prosecutor/defense-obligation rules are common weak spots). Stop adding new outlines by the end of this window.

Final 24 hours

Light review only: your own condensed outline, rule statements, and any error log from practice questions. No new practice exams. Pack your ID and confirmation in the same place you keep your keys. Confirm the route, parking, and transit schedule, and check the weather. Set two alarms. Go to bed at a normal hour rather than cramming.

Morning of the test

Eat a real meal and use the restroom before check-in. Arrive at the center roughly 30 minutes early. Leave your phone and study materials in the car or locker before entering the check-in area. Follow the administrator's identity verification and sign-in steps, then take a breath and settle in.

During the test

You have 2 hours for 60 questions, about 2 minutes each. Read the call of the question first, then the facts, and watch for words like 'may,' 'must,' 'should,' and 'subject to discipline.' Do not let one hard question consume four minutes: pick the best answer, flag it if the interface allows, and move on. There is no penalty for guessing, so never leave a blank. Treat every question as scored even though some are unscored pretest items.

Rules to check

  • Bring only permitted items into the testing room. Phones, smartwatches, notes, bags, and study materials are prohibited; unauthorized items can lead to removal from the test or cancellation of your score. Confirm the current permitted-items list with your provider.

  • Your ID must be government-issued, unexpired, and bear a photo and your signature, with a name matching your registration. Name discrepancies are a common check-in failure; resolve them with the provider before test day.

  • There is no scheduled break during the 2-hour exam session, so plan hydration and restroom use around check-in. Confirm the break policy with the test administrator, since unscheduled breaks may not be permitted.

  • Do not discuss, reproduce, or share exam content with anyone. You agree to confidentiality terms when you register, and violating them can jeopardize your score and your character-and-fitness standing.

  • Scoring is scaled from 50 to 150, with each jurisdiction setting its own passing score. Your score is reported to the jurisdictions you designate; confirm how to designate or add jurisdictions with NCBE.

  • Answer every question. Unanswered questions are scored as incorrect and there is no penalty for guessing, so a reasoned guess is always better than a blank.

  • Follow all instructions from test center staff, including identity verification procedures, which may include a digital photograph and other biometric steps. Confirm the exact procedure with your provider if you have concerns.

  • If you arrive after your appointment time or without acceptable ID, you may be denied entry and forfeit your fee. Contact the vendor immediately if something goes wrong rather than assuming you can be admitted late.

MPRE FAQ

How many MPRE practice questions are available?

The practice set has 200 MPRE questions. Each one includes the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation, and the set is free to read with no signup.

How many MPRE flashcards are available?

The flashcard set has 32 MPRE cards. Each card shows the term and its definition.

Which topics does the MPRE study material cover?

The MPRE study material has 10 sections, including Regulation of the Legal Profession, The Client-Lawyer Relationship, and Client Confidentiality.

What format facts does the catalog list for the MPRE exam?

The catalog lists these item types: multiple choice for the MPRE exam.