CA Bar overview

  • 200 practice questions
  • 32 flashcards
  • 7 study guide topics
  • 36 key terms

What you'll study

  • Civil Procedure15%
  • Constitutional Law15%
  • Contracts14%
  • Criminal Law and Procedure14%
  • Evidence14%
  • Real Property14%
  • Torts14%

The California Bar Examination is the licensing examination administered by the State Bar of California for people seeking admission to practice law in the state - typically law school graduates and attorney applicants who have completed applicant registration and filed a bar exam application through the Applicant Portal. It is offered twice each year, in February and July. The February 2027 administration runs Tuesday, February 23, and Wednesday, February 24, in person at designated test sites across California; the July 2027 administration is scheduled for Tuesday, July 27, and Wednesday, July 28. The examination combines written sessions and multiple-choice testing: for February 2027 the State Bar contracts with ExamSoft as the delivery vendor for the written sessions, which applicants type on personal laptops, and the 200 multiple-choice questions are drawn from the Multistate Bar Examination created by the National Conference of Bar Examiners, answered on a Scantron sheet with a No. 2 pencil. Preparation should start with the State Bar's published scope of the examination and its content instructions by question type, then move to released past exam questions and answers and the MBE preparation guidance, with timed practice under exam-like conditions. Testing accommodations require a separate, earlier request, and applicants are encouraged to file well before the deadline.

Common mistakes

When asked whether a California court can exercise personal jurisdiction over a nonresident, the answer says only that the defendant 'has minimum contacts' and never states the statutory basis (long-arm / consent / presence / domicile), never analyzes purposeful availment or purposeful direction separately, never asks whether the claim arises out of or relates to the contact, and never reaches fair play and substantial justice.

Candidates memorize 'minimum contacts' as a slogan and treat it as the whole test, so once they spot a contact they believe the analysis is finished and spend the remaining time on the next issue.

What to do instead

Use a fixed four-line template every time: (1) statutory/consent hook; (2) purposeful availment or purposeful direction (contract vs. tort); (3) relatedness (specific vs. general, with continuous-and-systematic analysis for general); (4) fair play and substantial justice factors. Write all four headings even when one is quickly resolved, so no prong is skipped under time pressure.

The answer asserts that a Rule 12(b) defense not raised in the first responsive pleading is waived across the board, or conversely asserts that lack of personal jurisdiction or improper venue can be raised for the first time on appeal.

The waiver rules are taught as a single list, so candidates collapse three different categories (never waivable, waivable if not raised in the first response, and subject to a different timing rule) into one.

What to do instead

Memorize three buckets and label them in the outline: (a) lack of subject matter jurisdiction - never waivable, may be raised by any party at any time, including on appeal and sua sponte; (b) lack of personal jurisdiction, improper venue, insufficient process, insufficient service - waived unless raised in the first response (motion or answer), and a Rule 12 motion that omits them waives them; (c) failure to state a claim and failure to join an indispensable party - may be raised in a later pleading or by motion, and failure to state a claim can be raised at trial.

The essay applies a First Amendment, due process, or equal protection right directly to a private actor - a private employer, a private university, a homeowners association, or a private landlord - without first identifying a government actor or a government function.

Trigger words like 'speech,' 'firing,' or 'suspension' make candidates reach immediately for the doctrinal test, and the state action element feels like a formality rather than a threshold that can end the analysis.

What to do instead

Make the first sentence of every constitutional analysis a state-action sentence: name the actor, state whether it is a government entity, and if private, run the exceptions (public function, entanglement, encouragement/federal funding, nominally private entity performing a traditionally exclusive public function). If there is no state action, say so and stop, then redirect to whatever non-constitutional claim (contract, tort, statute) governs.

The answer applies strict scrutiny to every equal protection or due process classification, or applies rational basis to a classification involving a suspect class or a fundamental right, without first classifying the group and the interest.

Candidates remember the tiers abstractly but skip the step of sorting the classification, because the facts usually describe a sympathetic or unsympathetic group rather than naming the tier.

What to do instead

Before writing any scrutiny language, write the classification on the page: 'this classification burdens [group] and implicates [right], which is suspect / quasi-suspect / non-suspect / fundamental / non-fundamental.' Then attach the tier and its burden. For due process, separately state whether the challenge is procedural (Mathews factors) or substantive (fundamental rights), because the tests are not interchangeable.

The essay begins applying common law formation rules (mirror image acceptance, consideration, statute of frauds analysis) to a transaction that is actually a sale of goods, or applies UCC rules to a services or employment contract, without ever classifying the contract.

Under exam time pressure the candidate recognizes 'offer and acceptance' and starts writing the rule block that comes to mind first, treating goods/services as an issue that can be noted later - but every later rule depends on it.

What to do instead

Make the first line of every contracts answer the classification: 'The predominant purpose test classifies this as [goods / services / mixed], so [UCC Article 2 / common law] governs, including [firm offer rule / 2-207 / perfect tender / UCC gap fillers].' If the contract is mixed, state the predominant purpose and note that a different rule could apply to the divisible part.

The answer treats 'malice aforethought' as requiring ill will, hatred, or premeditation, and concludes there is no murder where the defendant acted with reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to life, or where the defendant intended only to injure.

The everyday meaning of 'malice' is spite or intent to harm, and candidates never replace it with the four doctrinal categories, so reckless and intent-to-injure murders get graded down to manslaughter.

What to do instead

Before analyzing the killing, list the four mental states under the common law definition (intent to kill, intent to cause serious bodily injury, reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life, felony murder) and match the facts to at least one, expressly noting that 'malice' does not require ill will. Then analyze whether any mitigation reduces the offense to voluntary manslaughter.

The answer concludes that a search violated the Fourth Amendment because the defendant was charged with a crime, without first asking whether the defendant had a legitimate expectation of privacy in the place searched or the item seized, and without checking the warrant exceptions (search incident to arrest, automobile, consent, plain view, exigency, inventory) before finding a violation.

Candidates read the facts as a list of aggressive police behaviour and reason backward from the outcome, jumping to 'unreasonable' without running standing and the exception checklist.

What to do instead

Answer in a fixed sequence: (1) government action? (2) search or seizure (reasonable expectation of privacy / trespass to chattel)? (3) valid warrant? (4) if no warrant, each applicable exception in turn. Address standing explicitly whenever the search involved another person's property or a passenger in a stopped vehicle.

The response labels every out-of-court statement as inadmissible hearsay, or admits every such statement, without identifying the declarant and the purpose for which the statement is offered, and without separately checking the non-hearsay uses and the exemptions and exceptions.

The hearsay definition is applied as a keyword match ('statement made outside court = hearsay') rather than as a two-part test, and candidates forget that the same statement can be hearsay for one purpose and non-hearsay for another.

What to do instead

Write two lines before the analysis: 'Declarant is X; statement is offered to prove [the fact asserted / something else].' Then classify: non-hearsay use (effect on listener, verbal act, legally operative fact, prior inconsistent statement under oath, impeachment), exemption (party admission, co-conspirator), or exception (FRE list, plus California distinctions if relevant). Only after that reach admissibility questions like the Confrontation Clause.

The answer resolves a competing-deeds priority question without first identifying the recording statute of the jurisdiction, or applies 'first to record wins' in a notice jurisdiction, or treats a purchaser as a bona fide purchaser without checking notice at the time of purchase rather than at the time of recording.

Candidates remember the phrase 'first in time, first in right' as a general default and never stop to classify the statute, because the classification feels like background rather than the dispositive issue.

What to do instead

State the jurisdiction's statute type first (race, notice, race-notice), then run the elements in order for each claimant: conveyance valid, value paid, and notice (actual, inquiry, record) measured at the moment of conveyance. Do not skip the shelter rule and the effect of a donee heir, who takes subject to prior interests.

The torts answer concludes that there is no proximate cause because the harm was factually caused, without stating the foreseeability analysis, and it treats all duty questions as a generalized reasonable-person standard without identifying the specific duty source (special relationship, undertaking, premises, statute) or its limits.

'But for' causation feels scientific and conclusive, so candidates stop there; and duty is treated as a formality because the conclusion is usually 'duty exists' rather than an actual analysis.

What to do instead

Write the causation analysis in two named steps - cause in fact (but-for or substantial factor, including the alternative-cause rules) and proximate cause (foreseeability, intervening versus superseding, and the thin-skull rule) - and state the zone-of-risk conclusion in one sentence. For duty, name the source and any limit (no duty to rescue absent a special relationship, landowner categories, economic-loss rule, pure emotional distress requirements) before applying breach.

Exam requirements can change. Confirm current details with the exam provider.

CA Bar practice

200 questions. Each one lists the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation. With JavaScript, this list opens one question at a time. The checker at the top of this page saves progress in this browser when it is available.

  1. Question 1Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff, a citizen of Texas, sues Defendant, a citizen of Oklahoma, in federal court for breach of contract. She seeks $80,000 in damages. Defendant moves to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. How should the court rule?

    1. Deny the motion; diversity and the amount requirement are satisfied. Correct answer.
    2. Deny the motion only if both parties consent to federal jurisdiction.
    3. Grant the motion, because federal courts lack jurisdiction over state-law contract claims.
    4. Grant the motion, because the amount in controversy must exceed $100,000.

    Explanation

    Federal diversity jurisdiction requires complete diversity of citizenship and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs. The parties are diverse and the plaintiff seeks $80,000, so subject matter jurisdiction exists.

  2. Question 2Civil Procedure

    A Nevada company sells widgets nationwide through a website. It has no offices or employees in California. A California resident bought a widget through the site, and the widget malfunctioned. The company made 20 such sales into California in the past year. The resident sues in California state court. Does the court have specific personal jurisdiction?

    1. No, because 20 sales are too few to support general jurisdiction.
    2. Yes, but only if the company's California revenue exceeds 10% of total sales.
    3. Yes, because the claim arises out of the company's purposeful sales into California. Correct answer.
    4. No, because the company has no offices or employees in California.

    Explanation

    Specific personal jurisdiction requires purposeful contact with the forum and a claim arising out of or relating to that contact. Purposefully shipping products into California, even in a modest number of sales, can support jurisdiction over a claim caused by those products.

  3. Question 3Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues Defendant in federal court in the District of Nevada. Plaintiff resides in Nevada, Defendant resides in Arizona, and the events occurred in Arizona. Defendant moves to dismiss or transfer for improper venue. How should the court rule?

    1. Deny the motion, because venue is proper wherever the defendant is subject to personal jurisdiction.
    2. Grant the motion, because venue is proper only where the plaintiff resides.
    3. Deny the motion, because the plaintiff's residence establishes venue.
    4. Grant the motion, because venue is improper in Nevada. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    In a federal civil action, venue is proper in a district where any defendant resides if all defendants reside in the same state, where a substantial part of the events occurred, or where property at issue is located. Here the defendant resides in Arizona and the events occurred there, so Nevada is not a proper venue.

  4. Question 4Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff files a removable case in state court and serves Defendant on January 2. Defendant files an answer on February 1. On February 20, Defendant learns for the first time that the case is removable. Defendant files a notice of removal on March 1. Is the removal timely?

    1. No, because the defendant did not obtain the plaintiff's consent to removal.
    2. Yes, because the defendant filed the notice within 30 days of learning the case was removable.
    3. Yes, because filing an answer does not waive the right to remove.
    4. No, because the notice was filed more than 30 days after service. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A notice of removal generally must be filed within 30 days after the defendant receives the initial pleading or is served. Later learning that a case is removable does not extend that deadline unless the defendant receives an amended pleading or other paper showing removability.

  5. Question 5Civil Procedure

    Which of the following must a federal complaint contain?

    1. A verified statement of every fact supporting each element of the claim.
    2. A list of all witnesses and documents the plaintiff will use at trial.
    3. A short and plain statement of the grounds for jurisdiction and the claim for relief. Correct answer.
    4. A legal brief citing the statutes and cases that support the claim.

    Explanation

    Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 8 requires a short and plain statement of the grounds for jurisdiction, the claim showing entitlement to relief, and a demand for the relief sought. Detailed evidence, witness lists, and legal argument are not required in the complaint.

  6. Question 6Civil Procedure

    Defendant files a motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim under Rule 12(b)(6). After the motion is denied, Defendant moves to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction. What is the effect of the earlier motion?

    1. The personal jurisdiction defense remains available because it was raised before trial.
    2. The personal jurisdiction defense is waived because it was omitted from the first Rule 12 motion. Correct answer.
    3. The personal jurisdiction defense is preserved because the first motion was not based on jurisdiction.
    4. The personal jurisdiction defense may be raised only on appeal.

    Explanation

    A motion raising a Rule 12(b) defense must include every available Rule 12(b) defense then available. Omitting the personal jurisdiction defense from the first Rule 12 motion waives it.

  7. Question 7Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues Defendant for breach of a construction contract. Defendant believes Plaintiff also failed to pay for extra work arising from the same contract. If Defendant does not assert that claim in the action, what happens?

    1. The claim may be brought later because it is a permissive counterclaim.
    2. The claim is likely barred as a compulsory counterclaim that had to be asserted. Correct answer.
    3. The claim is barred only if the court expressly dismisses it.
    4. The claim may be brought later only if the amount exceeds $75,000.

    Explanation

    A counterclaim is compulsory if it arises out of the same transaction or occurrence as the opposing party's claim and does not require adding parties over whom the court lacks jurisdiction. A compulsory counterclaim omitted from the action is generally barred in later litigation.

  8. Question 8Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues Defendant in federal court for copyright infringement. Plaintiff also asserts a state-law defamation claim against the same defendant based on unrelated statements made years earlier. The defamation claim does not share any common nucleus of operative fact with the copyright claim. May the court exercise supplemental jurisdiction over the defamation claim?

    1. No, because the state claim is not part of the same case or controversy as the federal claim. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because both claims are between the same parties.
    3. No, because defamation claims are always outside supplemental jurisdiction.
    4. Yes, because the court has federal question jurisdiction over the copyright claim.

    Explanation

    Supplemental jurisdiction extends to claims that are so related to the claim with original jurisdiction that they form part of the same case or controversy. Unrelated state-law claims between the same parties do not qualify.

  9. Question 9Civil Procedure

    An attorney interviews a witness and prepares a memorandum summarizing the interview. The opposing party seeks the memorandum in discovery. What is the best statement of the protection available?

    1. The memorandum must be produced because it contains factual information.
    2. The memorandum is absolutely privileged and can never be discovered.
    3. The memorandum is protected as work product unless the opponent shows substantial need and undue hardship. Correct answer.
    4. The memorandum is discoverable only if the witness is unavailable for trial.

    Explanation

    Documents prepared in anticipation of litigation are generally protected as work product. Opinion work product receives stronger protection, but factual work product may be discoverable upon a showing of substantial need and undue hardship.

  10. Question 10Civil Procedure

    Under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, which item must generally be disclosed in initial disclosures without a discovery request?

    1. The identity of witnesses the disclosing party may use to support its claims or defenses.
    2. Every document in the disclosing party's possession. Correct answer.
    3. The names of all witnesses the opposing party might call.
    4. The complete transcript of every witness interview.

    Explanation

    Rule 26(a)(1) requires initial disclosure of witnesses and documents a party may use to support its claims or defenses, a damages computation, and insurance agreements. It does not require production of every document or the opponent's witness list.

  11. Question 11Civil Procedure

    Defendant moves for summary judgment. Plaintiff responds with evidence that creates a genuine dispute about a fact essential to Plaintiff's claim. How should the court rule?

    1. Grant the motion unless Plaintiff requests a jury trial.
    2. Grant the motion if Defendant's evidence is more persuasive.
    3. Deny the motion because there is a genuine dispute of material fact. Correct answer.
    4. Deny the motion only if Plaintiff has expert testimony.

    Explanation

    Summary judgment is appropriate only when there is no genuine dispute as to any material fact and the movant is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. The court views the evidence in the nonmovant's favor and does not weigh credibility.

  12. Question 12Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff timely files a complaint against an unknown defendant described as "John Doe." After the limitations period expires, Plaintiff seeks leave to amend to name the actual defendant. When may the amendment relate back to the original filing?

    1. Whenever the plaintiff did not know the defendant's name at the time of filing.
    2. Automatically, because the original complaint was timely filed.
    3. Only if the new defendant received notice and knew the action would have been brought against it but for a mistake concerning identity. Correct answer.
    4. Only if the new defendant consents to relation back.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 15(c)(1)(C), an amendment changing or naming a party relates back only if the new party received notice and knew or should have known that the action would have been brought against it but for a mistake concerning identity, within the period for service. Lack of knowledge of the name alone is generally not a mistake concerning identity.

  13. Question 13Civil Procedure

    Which claim is ordinarily entitled to a jury trial in federal court?

    1. A breach of contract claim seeking money damages. Correct answer.
    2. A motion to quash a subpoena.
    3. A petition for a writ of habeas corpus.
    4. A request for an injunction against a continuing trespass.

    Explanation

    The Seventh Amendment preserves the right to a jury trial in suits at common law where the amount in controversy exceeds $20. A breach of contract claim for damages is a classic legal claim.

  14. Question 14Civil Procedure

    After Plaintiff presents her case, Defendant moves for judgment as a matter of law. What standard should the court apply?

    1. Grant the motion if Defendant's evidence is more credible.
    2. Grant the motion only if Plaintiff agrees to dismiss the claim.
    3. Grant the motion if the jury is likely to be confused by the evidence.
    4. Grant the motion only if no reasonable jury could find for Plaintiff on the evidence. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Judgment as a matter of law is granted when, viewing the evidence in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, no reasonable jury could find for that party. The court does not assess credibility.

  15. Question 15Civil Procedure

    A jury returns a verdict that the trial judge believes is against the clear weight of the evidence. What is the judge's most appropriate remedy?

    1. Increase the damages award without a new trial.
    2. Enter judgment for the losing party notwithstanding the verdict.
    3. Dismiss the case with prejudice.
    4. Order a new trial. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A court may grant a new trial when the verdict is against the clear weight of the evidence, when damages are excessive, or when other trial errors affected substantial rights. Judgment as a matter of law requires a stricter legal standard.

  16. Question 16Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues Defendant and the court dismisses the case for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Plaintiff later sues Defendant again on the same claim in a court with jurisdiction. Does claim preclusion bar the second suit?

    1. No, because a dismissal for lack of jurisdiction is not a judgment on the merits. Correct answer.
    2. No, because the first case was dismissed before trial.
    3. Yes, because claim preclusion applies to all dismissals.
    4. Yes, because the first case ended in a final judgment.

    Explanation

    Claim preclusion requires a final judgment on the merits by a court of competent jurisdiction. A dismissal for lack of subject matter jurisdiction is not on the merits and therefore does not bar a later action.

  17. Question 17Civil Procedure

    In an earlier case, B had a full and fair opportunity to litigate whether a contract was enforceable and the court decided that issue against B. In a later case, C sues B on a different claim that depends on the same contract issue. May C use issue preclusion against B?

    1. No, because issue preclusion applies only to the same claim.
    2. Yes, if B had a full and fair opportunity to litigate the issue and using preclusion is not unfair. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, but only if the first case resulted in a jury verdict.
    4. No, because C was not a party to the first case.

    Explanation

    Federal courts permit nonmutual defensive or offensive issue preclusion when the party against whom it is asserted had a full and fair opportunity to litigate the issue and its use is not unfair. The precluding party need not have been a party to the first action.

  18. Question 18Civil Procedure

    A federal court sits in diversity to hear a state-law tort claim. The state's highest court requires clear and convincing evidence before punitive damages may be awarded. The federal rules ordinarily use a preponderance standard for damages. Which evidentiary standard governs punitive damages?

    1. The preponderance standard, because federal courts always apply federal procedural rules.
    2. Neither standard, because the jury decides without instructions.
    3. Clear and convincing evidence, because the state rule is substantive. Correct answer.
    4. The preponderance standard, because punitive damages are discretionary.

    Explanation

    Under Erie, a federal court sitting in diversity applies state substantive law. A state's heightened evidentiary standard for punitive damages is treated as substantive and governs in federal court.

  19. Question 19Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff seeks to certify a class under Rule 23. What must the court find before certification?

    1. That the defendant agrees to class treatment.
    2. That every class member has filed a separate claim.
    3. That the class meets the Rule 23(a) requirements and one Rule 23(b) category. Correct answer.
    4. That the class claims are identical in every respect.

    Explanation

    Class certification requires numerosity, commonality, typicality, and adequacy under Rule 23(a), plus satisfaction of one of the Rule 23(b) categories. The claims need not be identical, and the defendant's consent is not required.

  20. Question 20Civil Procedure

    In federal court, when may a party generally appeal a district court decision as of right?

    1. After any interlocutory order that the party dislikes.
    2. Only after the district court certifies the case for appeal.
    3. After the district court enters a final judgment. Correct answer.
    4. Whenever the district court denies a motion to dismiss.

    Explanation

    The final judgment rule generally permits an appeal only after the district court has entered a final decision disposing of the case. Interlocutory appeals are limited exceptions.

  21. Question 21Civil Procedure

    A district court denies a motion to dismiss on a controlling question of law. What is required for an interlocutory appeal under 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b)?

    1. The district court enters final judgment on all claims.
    2. The district court certifies the order and the court of appeals agrees to hear the appeal. Correct answer.
    3. The parties stipulate that the issue is important.
    4. The losing party files a notice of appeal within 30 days.

    Explanation

    Section 1292(b) permits an interlocutory appeal when the district court certifies that the order involves a controlling question of law, there is substantial ground for difference of opinion, and immediate appeal may materially advance the litigation, and the court of appeals then accepts the appeal.

  22. Question 22Civil Procedure

    Which method is sufficient to serve an individual defendant with process in a federal action?

    1. Mailing the complaint by ordinary first-class mail without any acknowledgment.
    2. Leaving the summons with the defendant's attorney without authorization.
    3. Delivering a copy of the summons and complaint to the defendant personally. Correct answer.
    4. Publishing a notice in a newspaper without a court order.

    Explanation

    Rule 4 permits personal delivery to the individual, leaving copies at the individual's dwelling with a suitable person, or delivery pursuant to state law. Ordinary mail without acknowledgment and unauthorized delivery to counsel are generally insufficient.

  23. Question 23Civil Procedure

    A corporation is incorporated in Delaware, has its principal place of business in Ohio, and operates a large factory in California that generates 30% of its revenue. Plaintiff sues the corporation in California on a claim unrelated to the factory. Is general personal jurisdiction proper in California?

    1. Yes, because the corporation's factory is located in California.
    2. No, because general jurisdiction requires consent from the corporation.
    3. No, because the corporation is not essentially at home in California. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, because the corporation has substantial business operations in California.

    Explanation

    A corporation is generally subject to general jurisdiction only where it is essentially at home, typically its place of incorporation or principal place of business. Substantial in-state business alone does not make it at home in every state where it operates.

  24. Question 24Civil Procedure

    A plaintiff files a federal case in a district that is a proper venue but is inconvenient for the parties and witnesses. The defendant moves to transfer under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a). What must the court consider?

    1. Whether the defendant resides in the proposed district.
    2. Whether the case could have been filed in the proposed district only.
    3. Whether the plaintiff selected the forum in bad faith.
    4. Whether transfer serves convenience and the interest of justice to a district where the case could have been brought. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Section 1404(a) permits transfer to another district where the action could have been brought when transfer is convenient for the parties and witnesses and in the interest of justice. The original venue must be proper.

  25. Question 25Civil Procedure

    In California state court, a defendant believes that the complaint fails to state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. What is the proper procedural device?

    1. A motion for summary judgment.
    2. A motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict.
    3. A demurrer. Correct answer.
    4. A motion to strike the answer.

    Explanation

    In California, a demurrer challenges the legal sufficiency of a pleading, including whether the complaint states a cause of action. A summary judgment motion challenges the evidence, and a motion to strike challenges improper matter in a pleading.

  26. Question 26Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff, a citizen of Nevada, sues Defendant, a citizen of California, in California state court on a state-law negligence claim, seeking $200,000. Defendant would prefer to litigate in federal court and files a notice of removal within 30 days of being served. Is removal proper?

    1. No, because Defendant is a citizen of the forum state and the only basis for federal jurisdiction is diversity. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, provided Defendant files the notice of removal within 30 days after the complaint was filed in state court.
    3. Yes, because the parties are completely diverse and the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000.
    4. No, because only cases presenting a federal question may be removed from state court.

    Explanation

    Under 28 U.S.C. § 1441(b)(2), a case that is removable solely on diversity grounds may not be removed if any defendant is a citizen of the state where the action was filed. Because the sole basis here is diversity and Defendant is a California citizen, removal is barred. The thirty-day clock runs from service of process, not from the filing of the complaint.

  27. Question 27Civil Procedure

    In a federal action, Plaintiff needs documents from a witness who is not a party to the lawsuit. Which discovery device is the proper means of obtaining those documents from the nonparty?

    1. A notice of deposition served under Rule 30 without any subpoena.
    2. A request for admission served under Rule 36.
    3. A subpoena issued under Rule 45 commanding production of the documents. Correct answer.
    4. Interrogatories served under Rule 33.

    Explanation

    Rule 45 authorizes a subpoena directing a nonparty to produce documents or to appear for a deposition and bring documents. Interrogatories and requests for admission are available only against parties. A nonparty's attendance or production is compelled by subpoena, not by mere notice.

  28. Question 28Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff, a citizen of State A, sues Defendant One, a citizen of State B, in federal court on a contract that Defendant One and Defendant Two signed jointly. Defendant Two is a citizen of State A, so joining Defendant Two would destroy complete diversity. What should the court do?

    1. Allow the suit to proceed against Defendant One alone, because a plaintiff may choose whom to sue.
    2. Join Defendant Two and remand the case to state court, since joinder eliminates diversity jurisdiction.
    3. Determine whether Defendant Two is a required party whose joinder is not feasible and, if so, decide under Rule 19(b) whether the action should be dismissed. Correct answer.
    4. Dismiss the action immediately, because complete diversity is a jurisdictional requirement that cannot be satisfied.

    Explanation

    Rule 19(a) asks whether the absent person is required for complete relief or has an interest that would be impaired; if joinder is not feasible because it would destroy diversity, Rule 19(b) governs whether the party is indispensable and the action must be dismissed. The court weighs factors such as prejudice to the absentee and the plaintiff's interest in a forum. Only after that analysis may dismissal follow.

  29. Question 29Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues in federal court for breach of contract, seeking $250,000 in damages that must be proven rather than computed from a fixed sum. Defendant is properly served but neither appears nor answers. Plaintiff applies for default judgment. What is the proper procedure?

    1. The court must ascertain the amount of damages, for example through a hearing, before entering judgment, because the claim is not for a sum certain. Correct answer.
    2. Plaintiff must first demand a jury trial on liability before any default judgment may be entered.
    3. The clerk must enter judgment for $250,000, because the complaint's demand fixes the amount and the defendant has defaulted.
    4. The clerk may enter judgment once Plaintiff files an affidavit stating the amount owed.

    Explanation

    Rule 55(a) permits the clerk to enter default, but under Rule 55(b)(1) the clerk may enter a default judgment only when the claim is for a sum certain or can be made certain by computation. When the damages must be proven, the plaintiff must apply to the court, which may hold a hearing to determine the amount. The defendant's default admits liability but not the amount of unliquidated damages.

  30. Question 30Civil Procedure

    Plaintiff sues Defendant, a resident of State B who has no home, business, or property in State A, over an accident that occurred entirely in State B. While Defendant is changing planes at a State A airport during a layover, a process server personally hands her the summons and complaint. Does the State A federal court have personal jurisdiction over Defendant?

    1. Yes, but only if Defendant owns property located in State A.
    2. No, because merely transiting through a state does not amount to purposeful availment of that state's laws.
    3. Yes, because personal service on an individual physically present in the forum state supports general jurisdiction, even over claims unrelated to the forum. Correct answer.
    4. No, because the claim does not arise out of or relate to any contact Defendant has with State A.

    Explanation

    In-state personal service on an individual who is voluntarily present in the forum supports general jurisdiction, permitting suit on claims having no connection to the forum; the Supreme Court upheld this traditional transient-presence rule in Burnham v. Superior Court. Purposeful availment analysis is a substitute for presence, not an additional hurdle when the defendant is served while physically in the state. Property ownership is not required.

  31. Question 31Constitutional Law

    Which case established the principle that the Supreme Court may declare an act of Congress unconstitutional?

    1. Gibbons v. Ogden
    2. McCulloch v. Maryland
    3. Barron v. Baltimore
    4. Marbury v. Madison Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Marbury v. Madison established judicial review, the power of federal courts to invalidate legislative or executive acts that conflict with the Constitution. The other cases addressed implied powers, commerce, and incorporation, not the origin of judicial review.

  32. Question 32Constitutional Law

    Under the Commerce Clause, Congress may regulate intrastate activity that substantially affects interstate commerce, even if the effect is indirect. Which case best illustrates this principle?

    1. Printz v. United States
    2. Wickard v. Filburn Correct answer.
    3. New York v. United States
    4. United States v. Lopez

    Explanation

    Wickard v. Filburn allowed Congress to regulate wheat grown for home consumption because the aggregated effect on interstate commerce was substantial. Lopez limited Commerce Clause power over noneconomic activity, while Printz and New York addressed commandeering of state officials.

  33. Question 33Constitutional Law

    When a federal statute conflicts with a state law, and Congress has validly acted within its constitutional powers, the state law is:

    1. Remanded to state court for balancing
    2. Invalid under the Supremacy Clause Correct answer.
    3. Upheld if the state law was enacted later
    4. Upheld if the state law serves a local police power

    Explanation

    The Supremacy Clause makes federal law supreme when Congress acts within its constitutional authority, so a conflicting state law is invalid. Neither a later enactment nor a state police-power purpose saves a state law that conflicts with valid federal law.

  34. Question 34Constitutional Law

    The doctrine of selective incorporation holds that:

    1. Most Bill of Rights protections apply to the states via the Fourteenth Amendment Correct answer.
    2. Only the First Amendment's protections apply to the states; the other amendments do not
    3. Every provision of the Bill of Rights applies to the states in exactly the same manner as to the federal government
    4. No provision of the Bill of Rights applies to the states unless the state constitution adopts it

    Explanation

    Selective incorporation applies most, but not all, Bill of Rights protections to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause. Provisions such as the grand jury indictment requirement and civil jury trial right have not been incorporated.

  35. Question 35Constitutional Law

    Which classification receives strict scrutiny under the Equal Protection Clause?

    1. Race Correct answer.
    2. Age
    3. Gender
    4. Wealth

    Explanation

    Race is a suspect classification, so government action using race must serve a compelling interest and be narrowly tailored. Gender receives intermediate scrutiny, while age and wealth generally receive rational basis review.

  36. Question 36Constitutional Law

    A licensing scheme that requires a permit before a parade may be held is a prior restraint. Such a scheme is generally:

    1. Presumptively unconstitutional unless it has objective standards and safeguards Correct answer.
    2. Valid without any standards because parades are a traditional use of public streets
    3. Valid because parades are public events that the state may regulate however it chooses
    4. Unconstitutional only if applied to the press

    Explanation

    Prior restraints are presumptively unconstitutional and must contain narrow, objective standards and procedural safeguards to prevent censorship. A licensing scheme without such limits gives officials undue discretion over speech.

  37. Question 37Constitutional Law

    The Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination protects:

    1. Only statements made in open court under oath
    2. Only written statements signed by the suspect
    3. All physical evidence, such as documents and blood samples, in a suspect's possession
    4. Compelled testimonial communication that is incriminating Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The privilege protects compelled testimonial communication that is incriminating, such as requiring a suspect to reveal knowledge. It does not protect nontestimonial physical evidence like blood samples or fingerprints.

  38. Question 38Constitutional Law

    Under the Sixth Amendment, an indigent criminal defendant has the right to appointed counsel:

    1. Only on direct appeal after conviction and sentencing
    2. Only if the defendant requests counsel in writing before trial
    3. Only in capital cases where the death penalty is sought and the defendant is indigent
    4. In felony prosecutions and in misdemeanor cases where imprisonment is imposed Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Gideon v. Wainwright guarantees appointed counsel in felony prosecutions, and Argersinger v. Hamlin extends the right to misdemeanor cases where imprisonment is actually imposed. The right does not depend on a written request or limit itself to capital cases.

  39. Question 39Constitutional Law

    A plaintiff sues to challenge a federal statute that funds a program she opposes. She alleges only that the statute is unconstitutional and that she is a taxpayer. Under Article III standing doctrine, her suit is most likely:

    1. Allowed, because an allegation that a statute is unconstitutional alone confers standing
    2. Dismissed, because federal courts never hear constitutional claims challenging spending
    3. Allowed, because any federal taxpayer may challenge any federal spending measure
    4. Dismissed, because a generalized taxpayer grievance is insufficient Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Article III standing requires a concrete injury, and a taxpayer's generalized grievance about federal spending is ordinarily insufficient. A narrow exception exists for Establishment Clause challenges to congressional spending, but it does not apply to generalized constitutional objections.

  40. Question 40Constitutional Law

    A state law allows a 16-year-old to be tried as an adult, but the trial is completed before appellate review. A challenge to the law is likely:

    1. Reviewable only if the state expressly consents to appellate review of the issue
    2. Reviewable under the capable-of-repetition-yet-evading-review exception Correct answer.
    3. Barred because the plaintiff is no longer in custody and has no live stake
    4. Barred as moot in all circumstances, even when the challenged action is short in duration

    Explanation

    The capable-of-repetition-yet-evading-review exception allows courts to hear cases that are too short in duration to be fully litigated before becoming moot. Challenges to short-term juvenile transfer or trial procedures often fit this exception.

  41. Question 41Constitutional Law

    A state imposes a tax on out-of-state wineries that is higher than the tax on in-state wineries. This law is most likely:

    1. Invalid because states may not tax alcohol at all under the Commerce Clause
    2. Valid under the Twenty-First Amendment because alcohol is a unique local concern
    3. Invalid because it discriminates against interstate commerce Correct answer.
    4. Valid because alcohol regulation is a traditional local concern

    Explanation

    Under the dormant Commerce Clause, state laws that discriminate against interstate commerce are generally invalid unless the state can show a legitimate local purpose that cannot be served by reasonable nondiscriminatory alternatives. The Twenty-First Amendment does not authorize economic protectionism against out-of-state alcohol producers.

  42. Question 42Constitutional Law

    Congress conditions receipt of federal highway funds on a state's raising its drinking age to 21. The condition is generally valid if it:

    1. Is coercive regardless of amount
    2. Is unrelated to the federal interest Congress seeks to advance
    3. Requires the state to surrender a core sovereign function to the federal government
    4. Is related to the federal interest and not coercive Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under South Dakota v. Dole, conditional spending is valid if it promotes the general welfare, the condition is unambiguous, it is related to the federal interest, and it does not cross the line from pressure to coercion. A small percentage of highway funds was upheld as noncoercive.

  43. Question 43Constitutional Law

    A private club excludes members based on race. The club receives no government funds and performs no public function. The Equal Protection Clause:

    1. Applies, because the club has a liquor license
    2. Does not apply, because there is no state action Correct answer.
    3. Applies, because clubs are public accommodations
    4. Applies, because discrimination is always unconstitutional

    Explanation

    The Equal Protection Clause constrains government action, so private discrimination is not directly actionable unless there is sufficient state action. Receiving no government funds and performing no public function means the club's conduct is private.

  44. Question 44Constitutional Law

    A state terminates welfare benefits without a hearing. Under Mathews v. Eldridge, the court balances:

    1. The state's police power against the contract clause
    2. Only whether the benefit is a property right
    3. Only the cost to the state
    4. Private interest, risk of error, and government interest Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Mathews v. Eldridge balances the private interest affected, the risk of erroneous deprivation under the current procedures and the value of additional safeguards, and the government's interest, including administrative burden. No single factor controls.

  45. Question 45Constitutional Law

    A state law provides that only men may serve as administrators of estates. The law is subject to:

    1. Strict scrutiny
    2. Intermediate scrutiny Correct answer.
    3. Rational basis review
    4. No review because probate is a local matter

    Explanation

    Gender classifications are quasi-suspect and receive intermediate scrutiny, so the state must show an exceedingly persuasive justification. The law cannot rest on stereotyped assumptions about men's and women's abilities.

  46. Question 46Constitutional Law

    A city ordinance bans all signs on public property but allows signs for political candidates. The ordinance is:

    1. Valid because the city owns the property
    2. Content-based and subject to strict scrutiny Correct answer.
    3. Invalid only if applied to religious signs
    4. Valid as a reasonable time, place, and manner restriction on speech

    Explanation

    A law that distinguishes among signs based on their subject matter is content-based and must satisfy strict scrutiny. A blanket ban with an exception for political candidate signs favors particular speech and is not a neutral time, place, and manner rule.

  47. Question 47Constitutional Law

    Burning a draft card as a form of political protest is:

    1. Protected unless the government's interest is unrelated to suppressing speech Correct answer.
    2. Always protected without any need to consider the government's interest
    3. Never protected
    4. Protected only if the protest occurs on private property with the owner's consent

    Explanation

    Under United States v. O'Brien, symbolic speech may be regulated if the regulation is within constitutional power, furthers an important or substantial government interest unrelated to suppression of expression, and burdens no more speech than necessary. Burning a draft card can be punished because the government's interest in the selective service system is unrelated to suppressing the message.

  48. Question 48Constitutional Law

    Under Lemon v. Kurtzman, a government action involving religion is valid if it:

    1. Is neutral only as to Christianity and not other religions
    2. Advances any religion, as long as the advancement is incidental
    3. Has a secular purpose, is neutral toward religion, and avoids entanglement Correct answer.
    4. Is approved by a majority of taxpayers in a referendum

    Explanation

    The Lemon test requires a secular legislative purpose, a principal effect that neither advances nor inhibits religion, and no excessive entanglement with religion. Government action need not be approved by voters to satisfy the Establishment Clause.

  49. Question 49Constitutional Law

    Police may search a car without a warrant if they have probable cause to believe it contains contraband, because:

    1. Of the automobile exception Correct answer.
    2. The driver consents by having a license
    3. Of the good faith exception
    4. Cars are always subject to search

    Explanation

    The automobile exception permits a warrantless search of a vehicle when police have probable cause to believe it contains contraband or evidence. The reduced expectation of privacy and the vehicle's mobility justify the exception.

  50. Question 50Constitutional Law

    The Privileges and Immunities Clause of Article IV prohibits states from discriminating against nonresidents with respect to:

    1. Voting in state and local elections
    2. Welfare benefits and other public assistance
    3. Fundamental commercial rights and livelihood Correct answer.
    4. Public employment in state government

    Explanation

    Article IV's Privileges and Immunities Clause protects nonresidents from discrimination in fundamental rights involving commercial activity and livelihood, such as pursuing a trade or profession. It does not generally cover voting, welfare benefits, or public employment.

  51. Question 51Constitutional Law

    A neutral law of general applicability requires employers to provide a minimum wage. A religious employer claims the law burdens its religious practice. Under Employment Division v. Smith, the claim:

    1. Succeeds under strict scrutiny
    2. Succeeds because the Free Exercise Clause always trumps economic regulation
    3. Fails, because the law is neutral and generally applicable Correct answer.
    4. Fails only if the employer receives federal funds

    Explanation

    Smith holds that neutral laws of general applicability do not violate the Free Exercise Clause even if they burden religious practice. Strict scrutiny applies only when the law targets religion or involves individualized exemptions.

  52. Question 52Constitutional Law

    A state passes a law retroactively reducing the interest rate on existing private mortgages. The law is most likely:

    1. Valid under the police power because states have broad authority to regulate contracts without any judicial scrutiny
    2. Invalid because states may never alter existing contracts
    3. Valid because states may regulate contracts
    4. Invalid unless it serves a significant public purpose and is reasonable Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The Contracts Clause prohibits states from impairing existing contractual obligations, but a state law may survive if it serves a significant and legitimate public purpose and the means are reasonable and appropriate. A retroactive reduction of mortgage interest substantially impairs private contracts and requires justification.

  53. Question 53Constitutional Law

    A state requires a landowner to dedicate a public bike path across her property as a condition of a building permit. Under Nollan and Dolan, the condition is valid only if:

    1. The landowner is compensated at fair market value for the dedicated path at the time of the permit's issuance
    2. There is an essential nexus and rough proportionality to the development's impact Correct answer.
    3. The state declares a public emergency
    4. The condition is generally applicable to all permits issued by the state in the same jurisdiction

    Explanation

    Nollan and Dolan require an essential nexus between the condition and a legitimate state interest, plus rough proportionality between the condition and the proposed development's impact. A bike path unrelated to the development's effects would be an unconstitutional exaction.

  54. Question 54Constitutional Law

    Which issue is most likely a nonjusticiable political question?

    1. Whether a state law places an undue burden on interstate commerce
    2. Whether a federal statute violates the Equal Protection Clause by classifying persons by race
    3. Whether a police search violated the Fourth Amendment's reasonableness requirement
    4. Whether the Senate properly followed its own impeachment trial procedures Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The Constitution commits impeachment trial procedures to the Senate, and courts treat such questions as political questions. Equal protection, Fourth Amendment, and dormant Commerce Clause issues are routinely adjudicated by courts.

  55. Question 55Constitutional Law

    Congress seeks to subject a state to suit in federal court for violations of a federal statute enacted under the Commerce Clause. The suit is:

    1. Barred unless the state consents or Congress validly abrogates under Section 5 Correct answer.
    2. Allowed because states are not immune from suit in federal court when Congress has enacted a federal statute
    3. Allowed because Congress may abrogate state sovereign immunity under any Article I power, including the Commerce Clause
    4. Barred only if the state appears in court and raises the immunity defense before answering the complaint

    Explanation

    State sovereign immunity generally bars suit in federal court unless the state consents or Congress validly abrogates the immunity. Under Seminole Tribe, Congress may not abrogate state sovereign immunity using Article I powers such as the Commerce Clause; valid abrogation generally requires Section 5 of the Fourteenth Amendment.

  56. Question 56Constitutional Law

    To establish standing under Article III, a plaintiff suing in federal court must show, as the injury-in-fact element, that she has suffered:

    1. an interest shared with the general public in seeing that federal law is faithfully followed
    2. a showing that a favorable ruling would substantially redress the harm she alleges
    3. a showing that the defendant's conduct was the but-for and proximate cause of her harm
    4. a concrete, particularized, actual or imminent invasion of a legally protected interest Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Article III standing requires three elements: injury in fact, causation, and redressability. Injury in fact means an invasion of a legally protected interest that is concrete and particularized and actual or imminent, not abstract or generalized. Causation and redressability are separate elements, and a generalized grievance shared with the public at large does not qualify.

  57. Question 57Constitutional Law

    Congress enacts a statute establishing uniform national emission standards for new automobiles and expressly provides that no state may adopt a standard for new automobiles that differs from the federal standard. A state nevertheless enacts a stricter emission standard for new automobiles sold within its borders. The state standard is most likely:

    1. valid, because the federal statute does not directly regulate the states as states
    2. valid, because Congress may not compel a state legislature to enact federal policy
    3. invalid, because it conflicts with a federal statute that expressly preempts it Correct answer.
    4. valid, because states retain traditional police power over health and safety within their borders

    Explanation

    Under the Supremacy Clause, valid federal law displaces conflicting state law, and Congress may preempt state law either expressly or by occupying the field. Where a statute contains an express preemption clause barring differing state standards, a state standard that differs is invalid. General police power does not save a state law that conflicts with an express federal command.

  58. Question 58Constitutional Law

    After a nationwide labor dispute halts steel production, the President issues an executive order directing the Secretary of Commerce to seize and operate the affected private steel mills, citing national security. Congress had considered and declined to authorize such seizures, though it had enacted detailed statutes regulating labor disputes in the industry. The order is most likely:

    1. invalid, because only Congress may regulate private industry under the Commerce Clause
    2. valid, because presidential power is at its height when Congress has not expressly forbidden the action
    3. invalid, because the order is incompatible with the express or implied will of Congress Correct answer.
    4. valid, because the President has inherent constitutional authority over national security matters

    Explanation

    When the President acts contrary to the express or implied will of Congress, his power is at its lowest ebb and the action is valid only if the Constitution itself grants the authority. A seizure order in an area Congress has regulated and declined to expand is measured against that standard and generally fails. Justice Jackson's framework thus turns on the relationship between the presidential act and congressional action.

  59. Question 59Constitutional Law

    A city ordinance caps amplified sound at all rallies in its downtown public park at 70 decibels, applying the cap without regard to the rally's message. The city shows that amplified sound above that level has repeatedly disrupted patients at an adjacent hospital and that rallies may obtain amplification permits at several other nearby public sites. A group denied amplification challenges the ordinance. The ordinance is most likely:

    1. valid, because the government may prohibit all amplified sound in public parks
    2. invalid, because it restricts speech in a traditional public forum without a compelling interest
    3. valid, as a content-neutral time, place, and manner restriction Correct answer.
    4. invalid, because it gives officials discretion to decide which rallies may use amplification

    Explanation

    A content-neutral regulation of the time, place, or manner of speech in a public forum is valid if it is narrowly tailored to serve a significant government interest and leaves open ample alternative channels of communication. Protecting hospital patients from noise is a significant interest, and other amplified sites remain available. Strict scrutiny applies only to content-based or viewpoint-based restrictions.

  60. Question 60Constitutional Law

    A coastal state enacts a law barring permanent structures on beachfront lots within a zone drawn to preserve the public beach from erosion. A landowner's vacant lot lies entirely within the zone; before the law, the lot could have been developed with a house, and it now has no economically beneficial use. The landowner sues for compensation. The regulation is most likely:

    1. not a taking, because the landowner retains the right to exclude others from the lot
    2. a taking, because it deprives the lot of all economically beneficial use Correct answer.
    3. not a taking, because the state may regulate land for the public welfare without paying
    4. a taking only if the landowner shows the law fails to substantially advance a legitimate state interest

    Explanation

    A regulation that denies all economically beneficial or productive use of land is a per se taking requiring compensation unless the limitation inheres in background principles of the state's property and nuisance law. General land-use regulation that leaves some economic use is instead analyzed under the multi-factor Penn Central test. A total wipeout of value is the narrow circumstance that triggers the per se rule.

  61. Question 61Contracts

    On May 1, Offeror mails a written offer to Offeree. On May 4, Offeree mails an acceptance. On May 5, Offeror telephones Offeree and revokes the offer; Offeree receives the revocation that same day. Offeree's acceptance reaches Offeror on May 7. When was the contract formed?

    1. May 1, when Offeror mailed the offer.
    2. May 4, when Offeree mailed the acceptance. Correct answer.
    3. May 5, when Offeree received the revocation.
    4. May 7, when Offeror received the acceptance.

    Explanation

    Under the mailbox rule, an acceptance is effective on dispatch unless the offer is an option contract or the offer provides otherwise. A revocation is effective only on receipt, so a revocation received after acceptance has been dispatched comes too late. The offer itself is effective only on receipt, but that does not delay formation once acceptance is properly dispatched.

  62. Question 62Contracts

    Builder contracts to build a house for Owner for $300,000. Midway through, Builder threatens to walk off the job unless Owner promises an extra $20,000, and Owner agrees. Builder completes the house using the same plans and materials. Owner refuses to pay the extra $20,000. May Builder recover it under the common law?

    1. No, unless the work exceeded the contract specifications.
    2. No, because Builder gave no new consideration for the promise. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, because Owner's promise was made in good faith.
    4. Yes, because Owner agreed to the extra payment in a signed writing.

    Explanation

    A promise to perform an obligation already owed to the same promisor is not consideration, so a mid-contract promise of extra payment is generally unenforceable. A writing or good faith does not supply the missing bargained-for exchange. Only where the performing party undertakes something genuinely beyond the existing duty does new consideration arise.

  63. Question 63Contracts

    Employee orally agrees to work for Employer for 18 months beginning immediately. After six months, Employer discharges Employee without cause. Is the oral agreement enforceable by Employee?

    1. No, because the agreement cannot be performed within one year of its making. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because Employee began performance immediately.
    3. Yes, because Employee fully performed six months of the term.
    4. No, because every employment contract must be in writing.

    Explanation

    The one-year provision of the Statute of Frauds requires a writing for any agreement that, by its terms, cannot be completed within one year of making. An 18-month term cannot possibly be completed within a year, so the oral agreement is unenforceable. The test is theoretical possibility of completion, not the likelihood of early termination.

  64. Question 64Contracts

    Buyer, a merchant, sends a purchase order for 500 widgets that states on its face that acceptance is expressly limited to the terms of the purchase order. Seller, also a merchant, ships the widgets with an acknowledgment containing a disclaimer of the implied warranty of merchantability. Buyer accepts the goods and later discovers the disclaimer. Is the disclaimer part of the contract?

    1. No, because the offer expressly limited acceptance to its own terms. Correct answer.
    2. No, because warranty disclaimers are per se unconscionable under the UCC.
    3. Yes, because Seller's acknowledgment was the operative offer that Buyer accepted by taking the goods.
    4. Yes, because both parties are merchants and merchants are bound by terms customary in the trade.

    Explanation

    Under UCC 2-207, additional terms in a merchant's acceptance become part of the contract only if they do not materially alter it, the offer did not expressly limit acceptance to its terms, and there is no objection. Because Buyer's offer expressly limited acceptance, the disclaimer never enters the contract regardless of materiality.

  65. Question 65Contracts

    Uncle promises to pay Nephew $50,000 so that Nephew can quit his job and attend medical school. Nephew quits his job and enrolls, incurring moving costs, and Uncle then refuses to pay. Which theory best supports Nephew's claim?

    1. Quasi-contract, because Nephew conferred a benefit on Uncle.
    2. Promissory estoppel, because Nephew reasonably relied to his detriment. Correct answer.
    3. Breach of contract, because Uncle's promise was supported by consideration.
    4. Restitution, because Uncle was unjustly enriched by Nephew's decision.

    Explanation

    A promise lacking consideration may still be enforced to prevent injustice where the promisor should reasonably expect reliance and reliance in fact occurs. Nephew's quitting his job and enrolling in reliance makes enforcement appropriate to the extent of the reliance. The other theories fail because there was no bargained-for exchange and no benefit conferred on Uncle.

  66. Question 66Contracts

    Landlord and Tenant sign a written lease containing a merger clause stating that the writing is the entire agreement. The lease sets rent at $2,000 per month and says nothing about utilities. Tenant offers testimony that Landlord orally promised before signing to pay all utilities. Is the testimony admissible?

    1. Yes, because evidence of prior negotiations is always admissible.
    2. No, because the parol evidence rule forbids testimony about any oral statement made before signing.
    3. Yes, because the oral promise does not contradict any term of the lease.
    4. No, because the lease contains a merger clause and is fully integrated. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    When a writing is intended as a complete integration, the parol evidence rule excludes evidence of consistent additional terms as well as contradictory ones. A merger clause is strong evidence of full integration. Evidence of prior oral promises may still be admitted for purposes such as fraud, mistake, or interpreting an ambiguity, but not to add a term to the deal.

  67. Question 67Contracts

    On June 1, Seller agrees to deliver goods to Buyer on August 1. On July 1, Seller unequivocally tells Buyer it will not perform. On July 10, Buyer files suit for damages. On July 15, Seller notifies Buyer that it will perform after all. Which statement is correct?

    1. Buyer's suit is premature because the time for performance had not yet arrived.
    2. Seller's retraction is effective because the time for performance had not yet arrived.
    3. Seller's retraction is ineffective because Buyer had already sued, and Buyer may recover damages. Correct answer.
    4. Seller's retraction is effective unless Buyer had already paid for the goods.

    Explanation

    An anticipatory repudiation gives the aggrieved party an immediate right to treat the contract as breached and sue for damages. The repudiating party may retract only if the aggrieved party has not canceled the contract, materially changed position, or indicated that the repudiation is final. Filing suit constitutes such an indication, so the retraction comes too late.

  68. Question 68Contracts

    Contractor agrees to build a garage for $40,000 using a specified brand of shingles. Contractor completes the garage but installs a different brand of equal quality and price. Owner refuses to pay anything, claiming breach. What must Owner pay?

    1. The contract price minus any damages caused by the substitution. Correct answer.
    2. Nothing, because any deviation from the specifications is a material breach.
    3. The contract price minus the cost of replacing the shingles with the specified brand.
    4. Nothing, unless Contractor replaces the shingles with the specified brand.

    Explanation

    A party who substantially performs is entitled to the contract price less damages caused by any non-material deviation. Substituting an equivalent product at the same price is a minor breach that does not excuse the owner's duty to pay. The measure of the offset is the loss in value, which here is likely zero, rather than the cost of needless replacement.

  69. Question 69Contracts

    Contractor agrees to excavate a site for $100,000. After signing, Contractor discovers a previously unknown rock formation that makes excavation cost five times the contract price. Contractor stops work and claims excuse. Which argument is strongest?

    1. Mutual mistake, because both parties were mistaken about the difficulty of the job.
    2. Frustration of purpose, because Contractor's principal purpose in making the contract was substantially defeated.
    3. Impossibility, because the rock formation made the promised work physically impossible.
    4. Impracticability, if the risk was unallocated and performance became commercially impracticable. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Impracticability discharges a duty where an unforeseen event, the non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption, makes performance impracticable, and extreme and unreasonable cost increases can qualify. The contractor must also show the risk was not allocated to it by the contract or by custom.

  70. Question 70Contracts

    Owner rents a hall to Renter for $5,000 so that Renter can hold a wedding reception. After signing and before the event, the state bans all indoor gatherings of more than ten people. Renter cancels and refuses to pay. What result?

    1. Renter is excused, because a supervening event frustrated the principal purpose of the contract. Correct answer.
    2. Renter is excused, but only if the hall itself was destroyed by fire.
    3. Renter must pay, because the regulation affected only Renter and not Owner.
    4. Renter must pay, because the contract did not expressly condition payment on the reception occurring.

    Explanation

    Frustration of purpose discharges a duty where a supervening event, the non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption, substantially defeats the purpose of the contract for one party. Owner knew the hall was rented for a reception, and the gathering ban destroys that purpose. Both parties are excused from their remaining duties.

  71. Question 71Contracts

    Father owes Daughter $10,000 from an earlier loan. Father and Son agree that Son will pay Daughter $10,000 in exchange for Father's transferring a car to Son. Son later refuses to pay Daughter. May Daughter sue Son?

    1. Yes, but only if Daughter accepts the benefit in a signed writing.
    2. No, because Daughter gave no consideration for Son's promise.
    3. No, because Daughter is only an incidental beneficiary of the agreement.
    4. Yes, because Daughter is an intended third-party beneficiary of Son's promise. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A third party intended by the contracting parties to receive the benefit of a promise may enforce it, and the consideration supporting the promise runs between the original parties. Daughter is a creditor beneficiary because the agreement was designed to satisfy Father's debt to her. No acceptance or writing is required for her rights to vest.

  72. Question 72Contracts

    A and B have a contract containing the clause: 'Neither party may assign this contract without the other's written consent.' A assigns to C, for value, its right to receive payments from B, without obtaining consent. B refuses to pay C. What is the result?

    1. B need not pay C, because C knew of the clause when the assignment was made.
    2. B must pay C, although A's assignment gave B a claim against A for breach. Correct answer.
    3. B must pay C, but only after C obtains B's written consent to the assignment.
    4. B need not pay C, because the clause rendered the assignment void.

    Explanation

    A clause that merely prohibits assignment generally makes the assignment a breach of contract but does not invalidate it, unless the clause states that assignments are void or that the power to assign is eliminated. The assignee therefore takes the right and may enforce it against the obligor. The obligor's remedy is a damages claim against the assigning party.

  73. Question 73Contracts

    A software company contracts to deliver a custom system for $200,000, and the contract provides $50,000 in damages for each day of delay. Delivery is ten days late, and the buyer seeks $500,000. What is the likely result?

    1. Unenforceable as a penalty, because the amount is unreasonably large relative to any anticipated harm. Correct answer.
    2. Unenforceable, because liquidated damages clauses are disfavored and presumptively void unless reviewed by a court.
    3. Enforceable, because damages from delay are difficult to estimate.
    4. Enforceable, because the parties agreed to the amount in advance.

    Explanation

    A liquidated damages clause is enforceable only if the harm was difficult to estimate when the contract was made and the stipulated amount is a reasonable forecast of that harm rather than a penalty. An amount that vastly exceeds any conceivable loss is a penalty and is struck, leaving the injured party to prove actual damages.

  74. Question 74Contracts

    Buyer contracts to buy 100 widgets from Seller at $10 each. Seller fails to deliver. Buyer promptly buys 100 similar widgets from another supplier at $13 each. What may Buyer recover from Seller?

    1. $1,000, the full cover price, because Seller breached the contract.
    2. Nothing, because Buyer has not yet resold the goods.
    3. $300, the difference between the cover price and the contract price. Correct answer.
    4. $300, but only if Buyer gave Seller notice of the cover purchase.

    Explanation

    Under the UCC a buyer who covers in good faith after a seller's breach may recover the difference between the cost of cover and the contract price, plus incidental and consequential damages less expenses saved. Here the difference is $3 per unit for 100 units. Notice to the seller is not a condition of the cover remedy.

  75. Question 75Contracts

    Employee has a two-year employment contract at $5,000 per month. After six months, Employer discharges Employee without cause. Employee makes no effort to find other work and remains unemployed for the rest of the term. In a suit for damages, what can Employee recover?

    1. The full remaining salary of $90,000.
    2. Nominal damages only.
    3. Nothing, because Employee failed to make any effort to find comparable employment.
    4. The remaining salary minus what Employee could have earned with reasonable diligence. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    An employee wrongfully discharged must use reasonable efforts to mitigate, and the recovery is reduced by the amount that could have been earned with reasonable diligence. Failure to mitigate reduces the claim but does not eliminate it, because the burden is on the employer to show avoidable loss.

  76. Question 76Contracts

    Seller signs a written contract to sell a house to Buyer for $400,000. Before closing, Seller refuses to convey and returns Buyer's deposit. Buyer sues for specific performance. What is the likely outcome?

    1. Granted only if Buyer proves the house has unusual features making it special.
    2. Granted, because every parcel of land is treated as unique. Correct answer.
    3. Denied, because Buyer has an adequate remedy at law in money damages.
    4. Denied, because specific performance is unavailable for real property.

    Explanation

    Land is presumed unique, so money damages are considered inadequate and specific performance is routinely available to a buyer under a land sale contract. The buyer need not show any special feature of the particular parcel. The remedy is subject to defenses such as unclean hands and hardship.

  77. Question 77Contracts

    Artist agrees to paint Buyer's portrait for $10,000, payable 'if Buyer is satisfied with the likeness.' Buyer, acting in good faith, is not satisfied and refuses to pay. Artist sues, offering evidence that the portrait is well executed. What result?

    1. Buyer wins only if Buyer proves the portrait is objectively defective in some material respect.
    2. Artist wins, because Buyer's promise to pay was unconditional.
    3. Artist wins, because Buyer's dissatisfaction must be reasonable.
    4. Buyer wins, because satisfaction as to personal taste is judged by Buyer's subjective good faith. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Where a condition calls for satisfaction with matters of personal taste, aesthetics, or opinion, courts apply a subjective standard and require only that the dissatisfaction be honest and in good faith. Reasonableness review applies to satisfaction with mechanical fitness or commercial quality. Because the portrait involves personal taste, Buyer's good-faith dissatisfaction defeats the condition.

  78. Question 78Contracts

    Buyer's obligation to close is conditioned on Seller delivering a clean termite report by May 1. On April 25, Buyer tells Seller, 'Forget the termite report; I will close anyway.' Relying on that statement, Seller does not order the report and lets the inspection deadline pass. On May 10, Buyer changes his mind and demands the report, which Seller cannot produce. Buyer refuses to close. What result?

    1. Buyer may not refuse to close, because Seller relied on Buyer's waiver of the condition. Correct answer.
    2. Buyer may refuse to close, because the condition was never satisfied.
    3. Buyer may refuse to close, because a waiver without consideration is always ineffective.
    4. Buyer may refuse to close, because a waiver of a condition must be in writing.

    Explanation

    A party may waive an express condition, and the waiver becomes irrevocable once the other party has materially relied on it. Because Seller relied on Buyer's statement by letting the inspection deadline pass, Buyer cannot retract the waiver. Without reliance, a waiver of a condition not yet due could be retracted.

  79. Question 79Contracts

    A consumer with limited English signs a contract to buy a used car. The contract disclaims all warranties, sets the price at three times market value, and requires all disputes to be arbitrated 1,000 miles away. Which doctrine most directly supports a court's refusal to enforce these terms?

    1. Mutual mistake
    2. Unconscionability Correct answer.
    3. Anticipatory repudiation
    4. Commercial impracticability

    Explanation

    Unconscionability addresses contracts or clauses that are both procedurally oppressive, such as unfair surprise or unequal bargaining power, and substantively one-sided. Courts may refuse to enforce the entire contract or merely the offending clause. The other doctrines concern mistaken assumptions, supervening events, and premature breach.

  80. Question 80Contracts

    Which of the following best states the elements of economic duress?

    1. An improper threat that leaves the victim no reasonable alternative and induces assent. Correct answer.
    2. A threat to file a civil lawsuit to collect a legitimate debt.
    3. A threat to do something that the party making the threat has a legal right to do.
    4. Persuasion by a close family member who is trusted by the promisor.

    Explanation

    Duress requires an improper threat that induces assent by leaving the victim no reasonable alternative. The resulting contract is voidable by the victim. Threats to pursue lawful remedies, such as good-faith litigation, are generally not improper.

  81. Question 81Contracts

    Seller of a used car tells Buyer that the car has never been in an accident, knowing the statement is false. Buyer relies on the statement and buys the car, later discovering the truth. What is Buyer's best remedy?

    1. Rescind the contract and recover the price paid, because of fraudulent misrepresentation. Correct answer.
    2. Nothing, because Buyer could have inspected the car before buying.
    3. Recover damages only, because rescission requires a mutual mistake.
    4. Rescind only if the statement was included in the written contract.

    Explanation

    A fraudulent misrepresentation of a material fact that induces reliance renders the contract voidable and supports rescission as well as damages. The parol evidence rule does not bar evidence of fraud, even where a writing exists. Reliance on an affirmative lie about hidden history is generally justified.

  82. Question 82Contracts

    Which of the following contracts is most likely unenforceable on grounds of illegality?

    1. A contract to commit a felony in exchange for payment. Correct answer.
    2. A gambling contract in a state where gambling is legal.
    3. A contract to sell lawful goods at a price well above market.
    4. A contract with a minor for necessities such as food and shelter.

    Explanation

    A promise whose performance is itself a crime is unenforceable because the subject matter is illegal. Courts generally leave the parties where they find them, subject to limited exceptions for less culpable parties. High prices, necessities for minors, and lawful gambling are not illegal subject matter.

  83. Question 83Contracts

    A 17-year-old buys a $2,000 stereo on credit. Two months later, still a minor, he returns the stereo in damaged condition and demands a refund of the payments he has made. Under the traditional rule, what result?

    1. The minor may disaffirm and recover all payments, returning the stereo as is. Correct answer.
    2. The minor is bound because he damaged the stereo while using it.
    3. The minor may disaffirm only if he returns the stereo in its original condition.
    4. The minor may disaffirm but may recover nothing.

    Explanation

    A minor may disaffirm a contract at any time while still a minor or within a reasonable time after reaching majority. Under the traditional rule the minor need only return what remains of the consideration, without compensating for depreciation or damage, although modern statutes often impose a duty of restoration. Necessities are the principal exception.

  84. Question 84Contracts

    On March 1, a merchant sends Buyer a signed writing offering to sell 1,000 bushels of wheat at $5 per bushel and stating that the offer will be held open for 60 days. Buyer gives no consideration for that promise. On April 15, before Buyer accepts, the merchant revokes. Is the revocation effective?

    1. No, because a merchant's signed firm offer is irrevocable for up to three months. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because 60 days exceeds the maximum period permitted by the UCC.
    3. No, because the buyer accepted the offer by remaining silent.
    4. Yes, because no consideration was given for the option.

    Explanation

    Under UCC 2-205, a merchant's offer to buy or sell goods in a signed writing that gives assurance it will be held open is irrevocable during the stated period even without consideration, but in no event longer than three months. The assurance here is 60 days, so it remains open until Buyer accepts or the period expires.

  85. Question 85Contracts

    Homeowner posts a notice: 'I will pay $100 to anyone who finds and returns my lost dog.' Neighbor, without promising anything, searches for two days and returns the dog. Which statement is correct?

    1. A contract was formed as soon as Neighbor read the notice and decided to search.
    2. A contract was formed when Neighbor completed performance, and Neighbor is entitled to $100. Correct answer.
    3. Homeowner may revoke the offer at any time before Neighbor completes the search.
    4. No contract was formed, because Neighbor never promised to search for the dog.

    Explanation

    An offer that invites acceptance by performance creates a unilateral contract, and acceptance occurs only on complete performance. Neighbor's return of the dog formed the contract and entitles him to the reward. Under modern doctrine, once the offeree begins the invited performance, the offeror's power to revoke is suspended.

  86. Question 86Contracts

    A homeowner emails a contractor: "I offer to pay you $8,000 to remodel my kitchen; this offer stays open until June 30." The contractor replies the same day: "I need to think about it - I'll get back to you." On June 10, before the contractor has accepted, the homeowner dies. The contractor learns of the death on June 12 and accepts on June 15. Is a contract enforceable?

    1. No, because the homeowner's death revoked the offer before acceptance. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because the contractor's reply was a mere inquiry that kept the offer alive.
    3. Yes, because the offer was irrevocable for a stated period.
    4. No, because the contractor's reply was a counteroffer that terminated the original offer.

    Explanation

    An offer terminates automatically when the offeror dies, and without consideration the promise to hold the offer open is not an option contract binding the offeror's estate. A mere statement of a deadline does not make the offer irrevocable, so the contractor's acceptance after death creates no contract.

  87. Question 87Contracts

    A buyer and a merchant seller sign a written contract for 500 lamps at $20 each, to be shipped on May 1. The contract states: "Seller's promise to ship is conditional on Buyer obtaining a letter of credit by April 15." Buyer never applies for the letter of credit, and on May 1 Seller does not ship. Buyer sues for breach. What is the most likely result?

    1. Seller wins, because Buyer's failure to obtain the letter of credit excused Seller's duty to ship. Correct answer.
    2. Seller wins only if Seller can show that Buyer's failure made performance commercially impracticable.
    3. Buyer wins, because obtaining the letter of credit was not a material part of the exchange.
    4. Buyer wins, because Seller's duty to ship was unconditional and independent of Buyer's financing.

    Explanation

    When a party's duty is expressly made conditional on the other party's performance, the failure of that condition of cooperation excuses the conditional duty. Because Buyer never obtained the letter of credit, Seller's duty to ship never became due, so Seller is not in breach.

  88. Question 88Contracts

    A tenant signs a five-year commercial lease at $4,000 per month. Six months later the landlord sells the building, and the new owner raises the rent to $5,000 per month, telling the tenant that the lease does not bind a purchaser. The tenant pays the higher amount for four months, then sues the original landlord and the new owner for the overpayment. How should the court rule?

    1. The tenant recovers the overpayment, because the new owner took subject to the lease and the rent increase lacked consideration. Correct answer.
    2. The tenant recovers nothing, because the tenant paid voluntarily under the new owner's demand.
    3. The tenant recovers only from the original landlord, because the new owner never contracted with the tenant.
    4. The tenant recovers nothing, because the sale of the building terminated the lease.

    Explanation

    A purchaser of leased premises takes the property subject to an existing lease, so the new owner succeeds to the landlord's rights and obligations under it. Demanding higher rent than the lease permits is a breach, and the tenant's payment under the new owner's assertion of right is not a binding modification because the tenant received no new consideration.

  89. Question 89Criminal Law and Procedure

    At common law, which mental state is required for a conviction of murder?

    1. A specific intent to kill and nothing less
    2. Malice aforethought Correct answer.
    3. Ordinary negligence in the operation of a motor vehicle
    4. Reckless indifference to a risk of harm to property

    Explanation

    Common law murder requires malice aforethought, which is satisfied by an intent to kill, an intent to inflict serious bodily harm, reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life, or a killing during an enumerated felony. A specific intent to kill is therefore not the only route to murder; general recklessness toward human life can suffice.

  90. Question 90Criminal Law and Procedure

    An officer has reasonable suspicion, based on a reliable tip, that a person standing on a street corner is carrying a concealed handgun. Under Terry v. Ohio, the officer may:

    1. Stop the person and pat down outer clothing for weapons Correct answer.
    2. Enter the person's home without consent to search for the weapon
    3. Arrest the person immediately without any warrant or further inquiry
    4. Conduct a full search of the person's pockets and clothing

    Explanation

    Terry permits a brief investigative detention on reasonable suspicion and a limited pat-down of outer clothing when the officer reasonably believes the person is armed and dangerous. The frisk is confined to what is necessary to discover weapons, not a general search for evidence.

  91. Question 91Criminal Law and Procedure

    A man opens an unlocked window of a house at 11 p.m., climbs inside, and intends to steal a television. At common law, he has committed:

    1. Attempted burglary, because the theft was not completed
    2. Trespass, because no force was used
    3. Larceny only, because the window was unlocked and no force was used
    4. Burglary, because opening an unlocked window is a breaking Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Common law burglary is the breaking and entering of the dwelling of another at night with intent to commit a felony therein. Opening a window or door, even one that is unlocked, constitutes a constructive breaking, and the entry occurred at night with the intent to commit larceny already formed.

  92. Question 92Criminal Law and Procedure

    Which statement best distinguishes robbery from extortion at common law?

    1. Robbery requires a taking from the person's presence, while extortion requires a taking from a building
    2. Robbery requires the use of a deadly weapon, while extortion requires only a written demand
    3. Robbery uses immediate force or fear; extortion uses a threat of future harm with consent Correct answer.
    4. Extortion requires force, while robbery requires only a threat

    Explanation

    Robbery is a taking of property from the person or presence of another by force or intimidation. Extortion obtains property with the victim's consent induced by a threat of future harm, such as a threat to accuse the victim of a crime or to reveal embarrassing information.

  93. Question 93Criminal Law and Procedure

    Which formulation states the M'Naghten test for insanity?

    1. The defendant lacked the capacity to conform his conduct to the law
    2. He did not know what he was doing or that it was wrong Correct answer.
    3. The defendant could not control his conduct
    4. The defendant's conduct was a product of mental illness

    Explanation

    M'Naghten asks whether, because of a mental disease or defect, the defendant did not know the nature and quality of the act or did not know that the act was wrong. The other formulations test volitional control or require a causal product relationship.

  94. Question 94Criminal Law and Procedure

    An employee lawfully receives his employer's cash for the limited purpose of making a bank deposit, then keeps the money for himself. The employee has committed:

    1. Robbery, because he took the employer's money from the premises
    2. Receiving stolen property, because the money belonged to another
    3. Embezzlement, because he had lawful possession of the money Correct answer.
    4. Larceny, because he carried away money belonging to his employer

    Explanation

    Embezzlement is the fraudulent conversion of the property of another by a person who has lawful possession of it. Because the employee's possession was initially lawful and was converted to his own use, the crime is embezzlement rather than larceny.

  95. Question 95Criminal Law and Procedure

    A man asks his friend to burn down a rival's store, and the friend flatly refuses. The man may properly be convicted of:

    1. Attempt, because he took a substantial step toward the crime
    2. Conspiracy, because he reached an agreement with the friend
    3. Solicitation, because he urged another to commit a felony Correct answer.
    4. Nothing, because the friend refused to participate

    Explanation

    Solicitation is complete the moment a person invites or requests another to commit a crime, regardless of whether the other agrees. Conspiracy would require an agreement, and attempt would require conduct by the solicitor amounting to a substantial step toward the target offense.

  96. Question 96Criminal Law and Procedure

    An officer lawfully admitted into a suspect's living room sees a clear plastic bag of cocaine on the coffee table. The officer may seize the bag because:

    1. No, because the officer lacked a warrant for the contraband
    2. Yes, but only if the contraband is immediately dangerous to the officer
    3. No, because the officer was not searching for contraband
    4. Yes, because the officer was lawfully in a position to see it Correct answer.

    Explanation

    The plain view doctrine permits a warrantless seizure when the officer is lawfully present at the vantage point, the incriminating character of the item is immediately apparent, and the officer has a lawful right of access to the item. All three conditions are satisfied here.

  97. Question 97Criminal Law and Procedure

    Police arrest a suspect at his home and question him for 45 minutes without Miranda warnings, obtaining a confession. At the station two hours later, after full warnings and a waiver, he confesses again. Which statement is correct?

    1. Neither confession is admissible because the first confession was unwarned
    2. Both confessions are admissible because the second was preceded by warnings
    3. The second confession is inadmissible because it was continuous with the first
    4. The second is admissible if the taint of the first was attenuated Correct answer.

    Explanation

    An unwarned confession does not automatically bar a later confession given after valid warnings and waiver; the question is whether the warnings were effective to cure the earlier taint or whether the two-step process was a deliberate technique to undermine Miranda. Courts examine the timing, continuity, and deliberateness of the sequence.

  98. Question 98Criminal Law and Procedure

    During a planned robbery, one robber shoots and kills the shopkeeper. In a jurisdiction applying the agency theory of felony murder, a co-felon who planned the robbery but did not fire is:

    1. Not liable, because he did not fire the shot and the killing was not in furtherance of the felony
    2. Not liable, because the fatal shot was fired by another person rather than by him
    3. Liable for felony murder, because a co-felon fired the shot during the felony Correct answer.
    4. Liable only for manslaughter, because he personally did not intend any killing

    Explanation

    Under the agency theory, a felon is liable for felony murder when the killing is committed by a felon or his agent in furtherance of the felony. Because a co-felon fired the fatal shot during the robbery, all co-felons are liable; the proximate cause theory would also reach police or victim killings in many jurisdictions.

  99. Question 99Criminal Law and Procedure

    Which of the following comes closest to a substantial step toward attempted burglary of a house?

    1. Abandoning the plan after arriving at the house
    2. Thinking about which house to burglarize
    3. Buying crowbars and driving to the target house Correct answer.
    4. Driving slowly around a neighborhood looking at houses

    Explanation

    Attempt requires an act beyond mere preparation that strongly corroborates the actor's criminal purpose. Acquiring tools and traveling to the target strongly corroborates intent, whereas surveillance, deliberation, and abandonment fall on the preparation side of the line.

  100. Question 100Criminal Law and Procedure

    An accomplice who encourages a robbery is liable for a killing committed by the principal during the robbery when:

    1. The accomplice personally intended that the victim be killed
    2. The accomplice knew the principal carried a loaded weapon
    3. It was a natural and probable consequence of the robbery Correct answer.
    4. The accomplice was physically present at the scene of the robbery

    Explanation

    Under the natural and probable consequences doctrine, an accomplice is liable for crimes other than the one he intended if those crimes were a natural and probable consequence of the intended offense. Fatal violence during an armed robbery is commonly treated as such a consequence.

  101. Question 101Criminal Law and Procedure

    A defendant who honestly but unreasonably believes he faces an imminent threat of death and uses deadly force is entitled at most to:

    1. Conviction of first-degree murder
    2. Acquittal on all charges
    3. Conviction of voluntary manslaughter Correct answer.
    4. Conviction of involuntary manslaughter

    Explanation

    Imperfect self-defense applies when the defendant honestly but unreasonably believed deadly force was necessary. The honest belief negates malice, reducing what would otherwise be murder to voluntary manslaughter.

  102. Question 102Criminal Law and Procedure

    Voluntary intoxication may operate as a defense to which of the following crimes?

    1. Voluntary manslaughter
    2. First-degree murder committed with premeditation
    3. Second-degree murder based on reckless indifference
    4. Burglary, a specific intent crime Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Voluntary intoxication may negate the specific intent required for a crime but does not negate malice, recklessness, or general intent. Burglary requires the specific intent to commit a felony inside, so evidence of intoxication can defeat that element.

  103. Question 103Criminal Law and Procedure

    Officers obtain a search warrant from a magistrate, but the supporting affidavit fails to establish probable cause. Evidence seized under the warrant is:

    1. Admissible if the officers relied on the warrant in good faith Correct answer.
    2. Inadmissible, because a magistrate is not a neutral and detached reviewer
    3. Inadmissible, because the warrant was issued without probable cause
    4. Admissible only if the officers had independent probable cause for the search

    Explanation

    Under the good faith exception, evidence obtained in reasonable reliance on a warrant later found defective is generally admissible. The exception does not apply where the affidavit is so lacking in indicia of probable cause that reliance is objectively unreasonable, or where the officer misled the magistrate.

  104. Question 104Criminal Law and Procedure

    Police have probable cause to believe a parked car contains contraband. Without a warrant, they may:

    1. Search only if the car is parked on a public road at the time
    2. Search the whole car, including the trunk, for contraband Correct answer.
    3. Search only the passenger compartment and any open containers
    4. Search only after first arresting the owner of the vehicle

    Explanation

    The automobile exception permits a warrantless search of the entire vehicle, including the trunk and closed containers, when officers have probable cause to believe it contains contraband. The exception rests on the reduced expectation of privacy in vehicles and their inherent mobility.

  105. Question 105Criminal Law and Procedure

    The constitutional protection against double jeopardy bars:

    1. A retrial after a mistrial caused by a hung jury
    2. A second prosecution after an acquittal for the same offense Correct answer.
    3. A civil suit arising from the same conduct
    4. A retrial after a conviction is reversed on appeal for legal error

    Explanation

    Double jeopardy bars a second prosecution after an acquittal or conviction for the same offense and bars multiple punishments for the same crime. Retrial is permitted after a hung-jury mistrial or after a conviction is reversed on appeal, and civil proceedings are generally unaffected.

  106. Question 106Criminal Law and Procedure

    The federal entrapment defense turns on:

    1. Whether the defendant was predisposed to commit the crime before any official contact
    2. Whether the government induced a person who was not predisposed Correct answer.
    3. Whether the defendant mistakenly believed the conduct was lawful
    4. Whether the government merely provided an opportunity to commit the crime

    Explanation

    The subjective federal test asks whether the government induced the offense in a person who was not predisposed to commit it. If the defendant was already predisposed, government provision of an opportunity is not entrapment.

  107. Question 107Criminal Law and Procedure

    A man takes an umbrella he reasonably but mistakenly believes is his own. He is:

    1. Not guilty only if he later returns the umbrella to its owner
    2. Not guilty, because he lacked the intent to permanently deprive Correct answer.
    3. Guilty of larceny, because he intentionally took the umbrella
    4. Guilty of attempted larceny, because he intended to take an umbrella

    Explanation

    A reasonable mistake of fact negates the mens rea required for larceny, which includes an intent to permanently deprive another of the property. Because he believed the umbrella was his, he lacked the intent to take property belonging to another.

  108. Question 108Criminal Law and Procedure

    A man shoots at Alice intending to kill her but misses and kills bystander Bob. The man is:

    1. Liable for murder of Bob and attempted murder of Alice Correct answer.
    2. Liable only for attempted murder of Alice
    3. Not liable for Bob's death, because he lacked intent as to Bob
    4. Liable for involuntary manslaughter as to Bob

    Explanation

    Under transferred intent, the intent to kill Alice transfers to the actual victim, Bob, making the killing murder. The original intent also supports a conviction for the attempted murder of Alice in most jurisdictions.

  109. Question 109Criminal Law and Procedure

    After agreeing with two others to commit a robbery, a conspirator tells them he is out and does nothing further; the others carry out the robbery. The withdrawing conspirator:

    1. Remains liable, because he did not take affirmative steps to defeat it Correct answer.
    2. Is relieved of liability because he clearly communicated his withdrawal to the others
    3. Is liable only if he later received a share of the robbery proceeds
    4. Is liable only for the conspiracy, not for the substantive robbery itself

    Explanation

    Withdrawal from a conspiracy requires communicating the withdrawal to all co-conspirators and taking affirmative steps to neutralize the scheme, such as notifying police. Even effective withdrawal does not erase liability for the conspiracy itself, which was complete on agreement, but it can cut off liability for later substantive crimes.

  110. Question 110Criminal Law and Procedure

    After an illegal arrest, a suspect names a witness. Police locate the witness, who voluntarily agrees to testify at trial. The witness's testimony is:

    1. Inadmissible, because it derives directly from the illegal arrest
    2. Admissible only if the police had independent probable cause for the original arrest
    3. Admissible, because her voluntary decision to testify attenuates the taint Correct answer.
    4. Inadmissible, because the police would not have found the witness but for the illegal arrest

    Explanation

    The fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine yields to attenuation when the connection between the illegality and the evidence is remote. A witness's independent, voluntary decision to testify is an intervening circumstance that purges the taint of the initial unlawful arrest.

  111. Question 111Criminal Law and Procedure

    After a defendant is formally charged with murder, police direct a jailhouse informant to draw him out, and the informant elicits incriminating statements. The statements are:

    1. Inadmissible, because Miranda warnings were not given before the statements were made
    2. Inadmissible, because the government deliberately elicited statements Correct answer.
    3. Admissible, because the defendant was never interrogated by any police officer
    4. Admissible, because the informant was a fellow inmate rather than a police officer

    Explanation

    Once adversary judicial proceedings have begun, the Sixth Amendment bars the government from deliberately eliciting incriminating statements from the defendant without counsel present. An informant acting at police direction is a government agent, so the rule applies even though no officer questioned him directly.

  112. Question 112Criminal Law and Procedure

    A defendant kills a man intentionally because another threatens to kill him on the spot unless he does so. At common law, the defendant is:

    1. Guilty of voluntary manslaughter only, because duress mitigates the killing
    2. Not guilty, because duress excuses every crime including homicide
    3. Not guilty, because the threat was of imminent death to himself
    4. Guilty of murder, because duress is no defense to intentional killing Correct answer.

    Explanation

    At common law, duress is not a defense to intentional homicide: one who takes an innocent life to save his own is guilty of murder. Duress may excuse other crimes, and the Model Penal Code recognizes a narrower exception, but the traditional rule bars the defense to murder.

  113. Question 113Criminal Law and Procedure

    Which fact most strongly supports a finding of premeditation and deliberation for first-degree murder?

    1. Killing while highly intoxicated
    2. Evidence that the killer obtained a weapon and lay in wait Correct answer.
    3. Killing during a heated argument with no cooling-off period
    4. A single blow delivered during a sudden quarrel

    Explanation

    Premeditation and deliberation require reflection before the killing, and courts look to planning activity, motive, and the manner of killing. Procuring a weapon and lying in wait is the paradigm of planning activity evidencing a considered decision to kill.

  114. Question 114Criminal Law and Procedure

    At common law, a person commits burglary when the person:

    1. Breaks into a dwelling in daytime intending to commit a felony
    2. Remains in a dwelling after closing intending to commit theft
    3. Enters a store after dark intending to steal merchandise
    4. Breaks into a dwelling at night intending to commit a felony Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Common-law burglary is the breaking and entering of the dwelling of another at night with the intent to commit a felony inside. The felonious intent must exist at the moment of entry, so an intent formed after entry will not support the offense. Modern statutes have largely relaxed the nighttime, dwelling, and breaking elements, but the common-law definition governs unless a statute says otherwise.

  115. Question 115Criminal Law and Procedure

    At 2 a.m. in a high-crime area, an officer watches a man repeatedly peer into parked cars and try their door handles. The officer approaches, identifies himself, and asks the man to stop. The man turns abruptly and thrusts both hands into his jacket pockets. The officer has no warrant and no probable cause to arrest. The officer may lawfully:

    1. Order him to empty his pockets and seize whatever falls out
    2. Arrest him for attempted burglary based on the peering and handle-trying
    3. Frisk his outer clothing if he reasonably believes the man is armed Correct answer.
    4. Reach into his jacket pockets and search them for drugs or weapons

    Explanation

    A Terry stop permits a brief detention on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, and a protective frisk of outer clothing is allowed when the officer reasonably believes the person is armed and dangerous. The frisk is confined to a pat-down for weapons; reaching into pockets requires independent justification such as plain feel of a weapon or contraband. Peering into cars at night may justify the stop but does not by itself supply probable cause to arrest.

  116. Question 116Criminal Law and Procedure

    A man with long-treated paranoid schizophrenia kills a stranger. At trial he testifies that he believed the stranger was a demon who was about to kill him and that killing the stranger was the only way to save his own life. The jurisdiction applies the M'Naghten test. The man:

    1. Is guilty because delusions of persecution never support an insanity defense
    2. Is not guilty because he was unable to control his impulse to kill the stranger
    3. Is not guilty only if his delusion kept him from knowing his act was wrong Correct answer.
    4. Is not guilty because his delusional belief negates the malice required for murder

    Explanation

    M'Naghten excuses a defendant who, because of a mental disease or defect, did not know the nature and quality of the act or did not know that it was wrong. A delusion matters only to the extent it destroys that cognitive capacity, as where the defendant believes he is lawfully defending himself. Loss of control and the absence of malice are analyzed under other doctrines, not under M'Naghten.

  117. Question 117Evidence

    Which statement best describes when evidence is relevant under the Federal Rules of Evidence?

    1. It has been authenticated by its proponent before the court admits it.
    2. It is more probative than any evidence the opposing party intends to offer.
    3. It is offered through a witness who has firsthand knowledge of the underlying events.
    4. It tends to make a fact of consequence more probable or less probable. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Evidence is relevant when it has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence, and that fact is of consequence in determining the action. Authentication, firsthand knowledge, and comparative weight are separate concerns that do not define relevance.

  118. Question 118Evidence

    In a civil suit over an allegedly breached construction contract, the defendant mailed the plaintiff a letter offering to pay $40,000 to "settle this whole dispute." The plaintiff rejected the offer. At trial, the plaintiff offers the letter as an admission that the defendant knew it owed the money. How should the court rule?

    1. Admissible, because the offer was made in a signed writing.
    2. Inadmissible, because the letter was not made under oath.
    3. Admissible, because it is a statement of a party opponent.
    4. Inadmissible, because settlement offers and negotiations are excluded to encourage compromise. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Offers to compromise and conduct or statements made during settlement negotiations are inadmissible to prove liability for or the validity of a disputed claim. The rule exists to encourage frank settlement discussions, and the statement's status as a party admission does not overcome it.

  119. Question 119Evidence

    A witness testifies, "Maria told me the blue car ran the red light." The testimony is offered to prove that the blue car ran the red light. How should the statement be classified?

    1. Hearsay, but admissible under the excited utterance exception.
    2. Hearsay, because it is an out-of-court statement offered for its truth. Correct answer.
    3. Non-hearsay, because it is offered only to show its effect on the listener.
    4. Non-hearsay, because it is a prior statement of identification.

    Explanation

    Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted. Because the proponent wants the jury to accept that the blue car ran the light, the statement is being used for its truth and is hearsay.

  120. Question 120Evidence

    A party wishes to admit a handwritten letter purportedly signed by the opposing party. What must the proponent show to satisfy the authentication requirement?

    1. A handwriting expert's testimony, which the rules require for every disputed signature.
    2. Evidence sufficient to support a finding that the letter is what the proponent claims. Correct answer.
    3. That the letter was produced during discovery.
    4. Proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the opposing party wrote the letter.

    Explanation

    Authentication requires only evidence sufficient for a reasonable juror to find that the item is what the proponent claims it to be. The burden is a conditional-fact standard, not proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and no particular type of evidence is mandatory.

  121. Question 121Evidence

    A lay witness may offer opinion testimony only if it is rationally based on the witness's perception and is what else?

    1. Supported by a reliable methodology that has been peer reviewed.
    2. Helpful to a clear understanding of the witness's testimony or a fact in issue. Correct answer.
    3. Based on specialized knowledge within the witness's field of expertise.
    4. Disclosed to the opposing party in advance of trial.

    Explanation

    Rule 701 permits lay opinion when it is rationally based on perception and helpful to a clear understanding of the witness's testimony or of a disputed fact. Specialized knowledge, reliability methodology, and pretrial disclosure are requirements for expert testimony, not lay opinion.

  122. Question 122Evidence

    In a criminal trial, the court takes judicial notice of an adjudicative fact that is not subject to reasonable dispute. How must the court instruct the jury?

    1. It should disregard the fact unless the defendant consents to the notice.
    2. It must accept the fact as conclusively established for all purposes.
    3. It may, but need not, accept the fact as established. Correct answer.
    4. It may consider the fact only if it is corroborated by other evidence.

    Explanation

    In a criminal case, a judicially noticed adjudicative fact is not conclusive; the court instructs the jury that it may accept the fact as established. Only in civil cases is the noticed fact treated as conclusively established.

  123. Question 123Evidence

    A patient tells her treating physician, "My neck hurts because I was rear-ended by a truck yesterday." The physician relies on the information in diagnosing and treating her. The patient sues the truck driver, and the physician testifies to the statement. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because it is a statement of fault rather than of injury.
    2. Inadmissible, because the patient is unavailable for cross-examination.
    3. Admissible only if the physician qualifies as an accident reconstruction expert.
    4. Admissible as a statement made for medical diagnosis or treatment. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Statements describing medical history, past or present symptoms, and the cause or general character of an injury are admissible when reasonably pertinent to diagnosis or treatment. The patient's description of being rear-ended is pertinent to treating her neck injury.

  124. Question 124Evidence

    A witness testifies for the prosecution. Defense counsel seeks to show that the witness is currently on probation and hopes for leniency from the same prosecutor's office. What is this evidence offered to establish?

    1. That the witness lacks personal knowledge of the events.
    2. A defect in the witness's character for truthfulness.
    3. Bias or motive to testify falsely. Correct answer.
    4. A prior inconsistent statement by the witness.

    Explanation

    Evidence that a witness hopes for favorable treatment from the government shows a motive to curry favor and is a classic form of bias impeachment. Bias is always relevant to credibility and is not governed by the special limits on character-based impeachment.

  125. Question 125Evidence

    In a civil battery suit, the defendant claims he acted in self-defense and offers evidence that the plaintiff has a reputation for violence. Is the evidence admissible?

    1. Inadmissible, because character evidence is not admissible in civil cases to prove conduct. Correct answer.
    2. Admissible, because the plaintiff's violent character is directly at issue in a self-defense claim.
    3. Admissible, because reputation evidence is not hearsay.
    4. Inadmissible, because reputation evidence is hearsay.

    Explanation

    Rule 404(a) permits a criminal defendant to offer evidence of a victim's character, but that exception does not extend to civil cases. In civil litigation, character evidence offered to show that a person acted in conformity with it is barred.

  126. Question 126Evidence

    After a shopper slipped on a wet floor, the store installed non-slip mats and warning signs. The shopper sues and offers the evidence of the mats and signs to show the store was negligent. How should the court rule?

    1. Admissible, because the evidence directly shows the store's negligence.
    2. Admissible, because remedial measures are not hearsay statements.
    3. Inadmissible under any circumstances, because such evidence is privileged.
    4. Inadmissible for the purpose of proving negligence, though it may be admitted for another purpose such as ownership or control. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 407 excludes evidence of subsequent remedial measures when offered to prove negligence, culpable conduct, a defect, or the need for a warning. The evidence remains admissible for other purposes, such as proving ownership, control, or the feasibility of precautionary measures.

  127. Question 127Evidence

    Thirty seconds after watching a car crash, a woman who is visibly shaking and screaming tells a bystander, "That red truck blew through the stop sign!" The bystander is called to testify at trial. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because the declarant is available and could testify herself at trial.
    2. Admissible only if the woman first denies making the statement on the stand.
    3. Inadmissible, because the statement goes to fault rather than to what happened.
    4. Admissible as an excited utterance made under the stress of a startling event. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    An excited utterance is a statement relating to a startling event made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement it caused. The brief interval, the visible agitation, and the subject matter all satisfy the exception, and the declarant's availability is irrelevant.

  128. Question 128Evidence

    A hospital billing clerk testifies that an invoice was prepared by another employee who has since left the hospital, in the regular course of business, at or near the time of the patient's treatment. The invoice is offered to prove the amount charged. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because the clerk lacks personal knowledge of the treatment rendered.
    2. Admissible only if the clerk personally prepared the invoice.
    3. Admissible as a business record, because a qualified witness may lay the foundation. Correct answer.
    4. Inadmissible, because the employee who created the record is unavailable and cannot be cross-examined.

    Explanation

    A business record may be authenticated by the custodian or another qualified witness who can explain the record-keeping system; the person who created the entry need not testify. The record must be made in the regular course of business, at or near the time of the event.

  129. Question 129Evidence

    A shooting victim, believing he is about to die, tells a police officer, "Danny shot me." The victim survives. Danny is tried for attempted murder, and the prosecution offers the statement as a dying declaration. How should the court rule?

    1. No, because the dying declaration exception applies only in homicide prosecutions and civil cases. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because the victim subjectively believed that death was imminent.
    3. Yes, because the statement concerns the cause of the victim's injuries.
    4. No, because the statement was not electronically recorded.

    Explanation

    Rule 804(b)(2) admits statements made under a belief of imminent death only in civil cases and in homicide prosecutions. Because the victim survived and the charge is attempted murder, the exception does not apply.

  130. Question 130Evidence

    A defendant's friend tells police, "I, not the defendant, broke into the warehouse." The friend later invokes the Fifth Amendment and refuses to testify. The defendant offers the friend's statement to exculpate himself. How should the court rule?

    1. Admissible, because the declarant is unavailable and the statement was against his interest.
    2. Inadmissible, because the friend was not under oath when he spoke.
    3. Inadmissible, because statements against penal interest are never admissible in criminal cases.
    4. Admissible, if corroborating circumstances clearly show the statement is trustworthy. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A statement against interest requires an unavailable declarant and a statement so contrary to the declarant's interest that a reasonable person would not have made it unless true. When offered to exculpate the accused, Rule 804(b)(3) adds a requirement of corroborating circumstances that clearly indicate trustworthiness.

  131. Question 131Evidence

    A witness testifies at trial and denies making an earlier statement. The earlier statement was made under oath at a preliminary hearing and contradicts her trial testimony. May the earlier statement be used as substantive evidence?

    1. Yes, because any prior inconsistent statement is admissible substantively.
    2. No, it may be used only to impeach her credibility.
    3. No, unless the witness is shown to be unavailable.
    4. Yes, because it was given under oath at a proceeding and contradicts her testimony. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 801(d)(1)(A), a prior inconsistent statement is non-hearsay and may be used substantively if it was given under oath at a trial, hearing, or other proceeding. Unsworn or otherwise unqualified prior statements remain limited to impeachment.

  132. Question 132Evidence

    A prosecution witness was convicted of felony fraud 12 years ago and was released from confinement 11 years ago. The defendant seeks to impeach her with the conviction and has given written notice. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because fraud is not a crime involving dishonesty.
    2. Admissible only if the court finds that probative value substantially outweighs prejudicial effect. Correct answer.
    3. Admissible, because any felony conviction may be used to impeach a witness.
    4. Inadmissible, because remote convictions are never admissible for impeachment.

    Explanation

    If more than ten years have passed since the conviction or the witness's release from confinement, whichever is later, a conviction is admissible only if the proponent gives notice and the court finds that its probative value substantially outweighs its prejudicial effect. Fraud is a crime of dishonesty, so the character of the offense is not the obstacle.

  133. Question 133Evidence

    A party seeks to prove the contents of a recorded deed by reading from a copy. The original is held by the opposing party, who refused to produce it after receiving proper notice. Is the secondary evidence admissible?

    1. No, because the copy has not yet been authenticated by a witness.
    2. No, because the best evidence rule requires the original in every case.
    3. Yes, because the best evidence rule applies only in criminal cases.
    4. Yes, because the opponent holds the original and had notice. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Rule 1004 excuses production of the original when it is in the possession of the opposing party and that party was put on notice that the contents would be proved at trial. Secondary evidence is then admissible to prove the contents.

  134. Question 134Evidence

    A husband and wife are defendants in a civil suit brought by a neighbor. The neighbor calls the wife to testify about a private conversation she had with her husband during their marriage. The husband objects. How should the court rule?

    1. She may not testify, because the communication was confidential and made during marriage. Correct answer.
    2. She must testify, because only she holds the privilege and she did not object.
    3. She may testify, because the privilege protects only criminal defendants.
    4. She must testify, because this is a civil action rather than a criminal one.

    Explanation

    The confidential marital communications privilege protects private communications between spouses made during the marriage, applies in civil and criminal cases, and may be asserted by either spouse. The husband's objection is therefore sufficient.

  135. Question 135Evidence

    A witness testifies that for the past five years the defendant has walked his dog along Elm Street at 7:00 a.m. every weekday. The testimony is offered to show the defendant was on Elm Street at 7:00 a.m. on the morning in question. How should the court rule?

    1. Admissible, because it describes habit-a regular response to a repeated situation. Correct answer.
    2. Admissible, because it is reputation evidence about the defendant.
    3. Inadmissible, because it is improper opinion testimony from a lay witness.
    4. Inadmissible, because it is character evidence offered to show conduct in conformity.

    Explanation

    Habit evidence describes a person's specific, regular response to a repeated specific situation and is admissible to prove conduct on the occasion in question. A consistent five-year weekday routine fits that definition.

  136. Question 136Evidence

    In a sexual assault prosecution, the defendant seeks to offer evidence that the complainant had consensual sexual relations with two other men on the same evening. He argues this shows someone else caused her injuries. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because the evidence serves only to show the complainant's character for promiscuity.
    2. Admissible, because a defendant has an absolute right to present evidence of this kind.
    3. Admissible only if the court, after an in camera hearing, finds it relevant and that its probative value outweighs the danger of harm to the complainant. Correct answer.
    4. Inadmissible in all circumstances under the rape shield rule.

    Explanation

    Rule 412 generally bars evidence of a complainant's sexual behavior, but allows specific-instance evidence offered to prove that another person was the source of physical evidence or injury. The proponent must follow the notice and in camera procedure, and the court must find the evidence relevant and not more prejudicial than probative.

  137. Question 137Evidence

    At a first trial that ended in a mistrial on a charge, a witness testified and was fully cross-examined by the defendant. The witness has since moved abroad and cannot be subpoenaed. At the retrial on the same charge, the prosecution offers the transcript of the witness's testimony. How should the court rule?

    1. Admissible, because former testimony need not have been subject to cross-examination.
    2. Admissible, because the witness is unavailable and the defendant had a similar motive to cross-examine. Correct answer.
    3. Inadmissible, because unavailability requires proof that the witness is dead.
    4. Inadmissible, because testimony from a mistried trial has no legal effect.

    Explanation

    Former testimony is admissible when the declarant is unavailable and the party against whom it is offered had an opportunity and a similar motive to develop the testimony at the earlier proceeding. A mistrial does not erase the cross-examination, and the same charge supplies the same motive.

  138. Question 138Evidence

    After a witness testifies, the opposing party impeaches her with a prior inconsistent statement and suggests she recently fabricated her account to protect her employer. May the proponent then introduce a statement the witness made before the alleged motive to fabricate arose?

    1. Yes, because it rebuts an express or implied charge of recent fabrication. Correct answer.
    2. No, because prior consistent statements are always hearsay.
    3. Yes, but only if the prior statement was made under oath.
    4. No, unless the witness is shown to be unavailable.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 801(d)(1)(B), a prior consistent statement is non-hearsay when offered to rebut an express or implied charge of recent fabrication or improper influence or motive. A statement made before the alleged motive arose directly rebuts that charge.

  139. Question 139Evidence

    A client meets a lawyer about structuring a real estate deal and asks whether the transaction "would look like fraud" to the IRS. The lawyer gives tax advice, and the government later subpoenas the lawyer's notes. The client asserts attorney-client privilege. How should the court rule?

    1. The privilege applies only if the client signed a written retainer agreement.
    2. The notes must be produced, because the client used the word fraud.
    3. The privilege applies, because there is no showing the client sought advice to further a fraud. Correct answer.
    4. The notes must be produced, because tax matters are never privileged.

    Explanation

    The crime-fraud exception strips the privilege only when the communication is made to further a crime or fraud. Asking a lawyer about the tax consequences of a transaction is a request for legal advice, and no evidence shows the client's purpose was to facilitate fraud.

  140. Question 140Evidence

    In a conspiracy trial, the government offers a statement made by one alleged conspirator to a third party implicating the defendant. The statement was made after the conspirator's arrest and after the conspiracy had ended. How should the court rule on admissibility as a co-conspirator statement?

    1. Inadmissible, because the statement was not made under oath.
    2. Admissible, because co-conspirator statements are always admissible against the defendant.
    3. Admissible, if the conspiracy is established by a preponderance of the evidence.
    4. Inadmissible, because it was not made during and in furtherance of the conspiracy. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A co-conspirator's statement is a party statement only when made during the conspiracy and in furtherance of its objectives. Statements made after arrest, after the conspiracy has ended, or merely to recount past events do not qualify.

  141. Question 141Evidence

    An expert testifies on direct examination and relies on a peer-reviewed study that is not in evidence. On cross-examination, opposing counsel reads a statement from a different treatise, and the expert denies the treatise is authoritative. May the statement be admitted as substantive evidence?

    1. Yes, because the expert relied on other studies from the same field.
    2. No, because it was not established as reliable authority and may at most be used to impeach. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, because learned treatises are always admissible as substantive evidence.
    4. No, because treatises are hearsay and are never admissible in any form.

    Explanation

    Under Rule 803(18), a learned treatise is substantively admissible only if it is called to an expert's attention on cross-examination and established as reliable authority by the expert's testimony, another expert, or judicial notice. If the expert denies its authority and nothing else establishes it, the passage cannot come in substantively.

  142. Question 142Evidence

    A driver sues another motorist for negligence after a collision. At trial, the plaintiff offers evidence that the defendant carried a $500,000 automobile liability insurance policy, and explains that she is offering it to establish that the defendant owned and controlled the car that struck her. The defendant objects to the evidence. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because evidence of liability insurance is barred for every purpose.
    2. Admissible, because it is offered to prove ownership and control rather than negligence. Correct answer.
    3. Inadmissible, unless the insurance company is joined as a party to the action.
    4. Admissible, because the policy amounts to an admission by a party-opponent.

    Explanation

    Under the rule governing liability insurance, evidence that a person was or was not insured against liability is not admissible to prove negligence or wrongful conduct, but it may be admitted when offered for another purpose, such as proving agency, ownership, or control, or bias of a witness. Because the plaintiff expressly offers the policy to show ownership and control of the vehicle, the evidence is admissible, ordinarily with a limiting instruction.

  143. Question 143Evidence

    A homeowner sues a contractor for defamation, alleging that the contractor stood on the sidewalk and announced to neighbors that the homeowner 'cheats his workers and never pays his bills.' To prove the utterance, the homeowner calls a neighbor who heard the remark. The contractor objects that the statement is hearsay. How should the court rule?

    1. Overruled; the words are offered as the act itself, not for their truth. Correct answer.
    2. Overruled, because a statement by a party-opponent is admissible without regard to whether it is offered for its truth.
    3. Sustained, because the neighbor who repeated the remark is not a party to the lawsuit and therefore cannot sponsor it.
    4. Sustained, because the statement is an out-of-court assertion offered to prove its truth.

    Explanation

    In a defamation action, the defendant's words are the very act that creates liability, so they are offered to prove that the words were spoken rather than to prove the truth of the matter they assert; such legally operative words are not hearsay. The neighbor is simply testifying to what she perceived, and the statement need not fall within any hearsay exception.

  144. Question 144Evidence

    The defendant is charged with robbing a convenience store. The store clerk died of an unrelated illness before trial. The prosecution offers a recording of the clerk's statement made to a detective in a formal, recorded stationhouse interview two days after the robbery, in which the clerk identified the defendant as the robber. The defendant never had an opportunity to cross-examine the clerk. The prosecution argues the statement is admissible. How should the court rule?

    1. Inadmissible, because the statement is testimonial and the defendant had no prior chance to cross-examine. Correct answer.
    2. Admissible, because the clerk is unavailable and her statement qualifies as a dying declaration.
    3. Admissible, because the statement was against the clerk's penal interest when she made it.
    4. Inadmissible, because any statement made to a police officer during an investigation is automatically excluded as testimonial hearsay in a criminal case.

    Explanation

    The Confrontation Clause bars admission of testimonial statements by an unavailable declarant unless the defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine. A recorded, formal stationhouse interview conducted by police to investigate a past crime is testimonial, so the clerk's identification cannot come in even if a hearsay exception would otherwise apply.

  145. Question 145Real Property

    A deed conveys Blackacre "to Alice and her heirs." What estate does Alice hold under the modern approach?

    1. A fee tail.
    2. A fee simple absolute. Correct answer.
    3. A fee simple subject to a condition subsequent.
    4. A life estate with a remainder in her heirs.

    Explanation

    At common law the words "and her heirs" were words of limitation that created a fee simple absolute, not words granting anything to the heirs themselves. Modern law presumes a fee simple even without those words. Alice therefore owns the entire estate and her heirs have no present interest.

  146. Question 146Real Property

    Which set of unities must exist for cotenants to hold a joint tenancy?

    1. Possession and payment of equal purchase prices.
    2. Time, title, and a recorded declaration of survivorship.
    3. Time, title, interest, and possession. Correct answer.
    4. Community of interest plus a signed written agreement.

    Explanation

    A joint tenancy requires the four unities of time, title, interest, and possession; the survivorship right follows from those unities. Failure of any unity converts the co-tenancy into a tenancy in common. Equal contributions are not required so long as the unities exist.

  147. Question 147Real Property

    Landlord and Tenant sign a lease for a fixed nine-month term at a stated monthly rent. How does this tenancy end?

    1. When the tenant abandons the premises.
    2. Automatically when the fixed term expires. Correct answer.
    3. By either party giving thirty days' notice.
    4. Only by the landlord's written notice to quit.

    Explanation

    An estate for years is for a fixed period and terminates automatically at the end of that period without notice from either party. No notice to quit is required because the end date is certain. Abandonment does not shorten the term, though it may affect the landlord's damages.

  148. Question 148Real Property

    Which of the following is an essential element of adverse possession?

    1. Actual notice of the possession to the record owner.
    2. Hostile use under a claim of right. Correct answer.
    3. Payment of property taxes for the statutory period.
    4. A good-faith belief that the possessor holds title.

    Explanation

    Adverse possession requires possession that is actual, open and notorious, exclusive, continuous for the statutory period, and hostile (under a claim of right). Good faith is not required under the majority objective standard, and the record owner need not have actual notice because open possession supplies constructive notice.

  149. Question 149Real Property

    Three friends take title to a cottage as tenants in common in equal shares. One of them wants to move in and occupy the entire cottage. What is her right?

    1. She may occupy the whole property without paying rent to the others. Correct answer.
    2. She may occupy only one-third of the property.
    3. She may occupy the whole only if the others consent.
    4. She may occupy the whole only after a partition action.

    Explanation

    Each tenant in common has the right to possess all of the commonly owned property, not just a fractional slice of it. A cotenant in exclusive possession owes no rent to the others absent ouster or an agreement, though she must share rents received from third parties. Her occupancy therefore does not require consent or partition.

  150. Question 150Real Property

    A tenant installed heavy shelving bolted to the floor for use in her retail store. The lease says nothing about removal. When the lease ends, the shelving is:

    1. A fixture belonging to the landlord and not removable.
    2. Her personal property, because she installed it herself.
    3. The landlord's property, because it is attached to the realty.
    4. A trade fixture she may remove if removal causes no substantial damage. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Items installed by a tenant for use in her trade or business are trade fixtures, which the tenant may remove before the lease ends if removal does not materially damage the premises. The purpose of the annexation and the identity of the annexer both matter in distinguishing fixtures from personalty. She must repair any damage caused by removal.

  151. Question 151Real Property

    Owner grants a neighbor an easement over Owner's parcel "for access to the public road." The neighbor later sells the benefited parcel. The easement:

    1. Terminates unless the deed expressly assigns it.
    2. Passes automatically with the benefited parcel. Correct answer.
    3. Terminates because it was personal to the original owner.
    4. Passes only if the new owner records a notice of the easement.

    Explanation

    An easement is appurtenant when it benefits the holder in use and enjoyment of a particular parcel; it then runs with that dominant parcel automatically on conveyance. No separate assignment or recording is needed. Only easements in gross, held for personal or commercial advantage, raise questions of assignability.

  152. Question 152Real Property

    Owner signs and delivers a deed to Buyer, but Buyer never records it. Owner then dies. As between Buyer and Owner's heirs, Buyer's title is:

    1. Subject to the heirs' rights as bona fide purchasers.
    2. Voidable at the election of the heirs.
    3. Valid, because recording is not required as between grantor and grantee. Correct answer.
    4. Void, because an unrecorded deed does not transfer title.

    Explanation

    Recording statutes protect subsequent purchasers from the grantor; they do not make a delivered deed ineffective between the original parties. Once the deed is delivered, title passes to the grantee and nothing remains in the grantor to pass to heirs or devisees. The heirs are volunteers rather than purchasers in any event.

  153. Question 153Real Property

    Life Tenant holds a farm with the remainder to Remainderperson. Life Tenant strips the topsoil and sells it, and also lets the barn roof go unrepaired until the structure rots. Life Tenant has:

    1. Committed waste and is liable for the resulting diminution in value. Correct answer.
    2. Committed no wrong, since a life tenant may use the land as she chooses.
    3. Committed waste only if the land was worth less at her death.
    4. Committed waste only if Remainderperson objected when she began.

    Explanation

    A life tenant may make reasonable use of the land but is liable for voluntary waste (acts that diminish the inheritance) and permissive waste (failure to make ordinary repairs). Removing topsoil and letting structures decay are classic examples of both. Damages are measured by the injury to the remainder interest.

  154. Question 154Real Property

    Tenant vacates an apartment six months before the end of a one-year lease, without cause, and the landlord does nothing to relet it. Under the modern majority rule, the landlord may recover:

    1. Rent for a reasonable period only, since the landlord must try to relet. Correct answer.
    2. Nothing, because the tenant's abandonment terminates the lease.
    3. All rent remaining due, because the lease is a binding contract for a term.
    4. The remaining rent only if the landlord advertised the unit.

    Explanation

    Most jurisdictions now require a residential landlord to make reasonable efforts to mitigate damages after abandonment, limiting recovery to the rent that accrues during a reasonable re-letting period plus reletting costs. The lease is not terminated by abandonment, and the landlord's duty arises regardless of advertising.

  155. Question 155Real Property

    The ceiling of Tenant's apartment leaks whenever it rains. Tenant notifies the landlord repeatedly; the landlord refuses to repair, and mold spreads through the unit. Tenant moves out and stops paying rent. Tenant is most likely:

    1. Excused from rent, because a substantial interference with use permitted her to vacate. Correct answer.
    2. Liable, because she gave no written notice of intent to terminate.
    3. Liable for abandonment, because a failure to repair is not an eviction.
    4. Excused from rent only if the building was formally condemned.

    Explanation

    Constructive eviction occurs when the landlord's act or omission substantially interferes with the tenant's use and enjoyment, the tenant gives notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, and the tenant vacates within a reasonable time. Those facts excuse further rent. Condemnation is not a prerequisite.

  156. Question 156Real Property

    In a race-notice jurisdiction, Owner conveys Blackacre to Able, who does not record. Owner then conveys the same parcel to Baker, who pays value but knows of Able's prior unrecorded deed, and Baker records first. Who holds title?

    1. Able, because Baker was not a purchaser without notice. Correct answer.
    2. Baker, because Baker paid valuable consideration.
    3. Baker, because Baker recorded first.
    4. Able, if Able records within a statutory grace period.

    Explanation

    A race-notice statute protects only a later purchaser who both takes without notice of the prior conveyance and records first. Because Baker had actual notice of Able's deed, Baker cannot prevail regardless of recording first. Able keeps title even though Able never recorded.

  157. Question 157Real Property

    Owner conveys "to Anna for life, then to Anna's children." Anna is alive and has one child at the time of the conveyance. The gift to Anna's children is:

    1. Valid, because the class closes and the interests vest at Anna's death. Correct answer.
    2. Void, because Anna's children may fall outside the perpetuities period.
    3. Valid only if the existing child survives Anna.
    4. Void, because Anna may have additional children after the conveyance.

    Explanation

    Anna is a life in being, and the class of her children closes at her death, which is when every member's interest either vests or fails. Because vesting is certain to occur within Anna's lifetime, the Rule Against Perpetuities is satisfied. Later-born children simply join the class before it closes.

  158. Question 158Real Property

    Ana owns Lot 1, which has an easement over neighboring Lot 2. Ana then buys Lot 2, so she owns both parcels. The easement:

    1. Continues, because it is appurtenant to Lot 1.
    2. Is converted into a prescriptive right.
    3. Is extinguished by merger of ownership. Correct answer.
    4. Is suspended until Ana sells one of the lots.

    Explanation

    An easement is extinguished by merger when one person acquires ownership of both the dominant and servient estates in fee simple, because a person cannot hold an easement over her own land. The easement does not automatically revive if the parcels are later separated, although a new easement may arise by implication. Suspension is not a recognized status here.

  159. Question 159Real Property

    Owen conveys Blackacre by general warranty deed containing the usual covenants. Which covenant is breached, if at all, at the moment the deed is delivered?

    1. The covenant of seisin. Correct answer.
    2. The covenant of further assurances.
    3. The covenant of warranty.
    4. The covenant of quiet enjoyment.

    Explanation

    Present covenants, such as seisin, the right to convey, and the covenant against encumbrances, are breached, if ever, at delivery. Future covenants, such as quiet enjoyment, warranty, and further assurances, are breached only when the grantee is actually disturbed or evicted. The statute of limitations on present covenants therefore begins to run at delivery.

  160. Question 160Real Property

    Senior Bank holds a first mortgage on Blackacre and Junior Bank holds a second mortgage. Junior Bank forecloses on its mortgage. The purchaser at the foreclosure sale takes title:

    1. Free of both mortgages.
    2. Subject to the senior mortgage but free of the junior mortgage. Correct answer.
    3. Subject to both mortgages.
    4. Free of the senior mortgage but subject to the junior mortgage.

    Explanation

    A foreclosure sale extinguishes the foreclosing lien and all liens junior to it, because junior lienholders are joined as necessary parties. Liens senior to the foreclosing mortgage survive the sale and continue to burden the property. The purchaser therefore takes subject to Senior Bank's first mortgage.

  161. Question 161Real Property

    A factory was operating lawfully before the town zoned the surrounding area for residential use only. Under prevailing zoning law, the owner may:

    1. Continue the use only until the property is sold.
    2. Continue the existing use but not expand it. Correct answer.
    3. Expand the use onto adjoining lots the owner also holds.
    4. Continue the use only upon obtaining a variance.

    Explanation

    A use that predates the zoning ordinance is a nonconforming use that may be continued despite the new restrictions, but it generally may not be enlarged, extended to other parcels, or resumed after abandonment. A variance requires a showing of hardship and is unnecessary for a lawful preexisting use. Sale of the property does not by itself terminate the protected use.

  162. Question 162Real Property

    Tess assigns her entire remaining leasehold to Al, who does not expressly assume the lease covenants. As between the landlord and Al, Al is:

    1. Liable only for rent accruing after written notice to the landlord.
    2. Liable only if the landlord consents in writing to the assignment.
    3. Liable for rent, because privity of estate exists between the landlord and Al. Correct answer.
    4. Not liable, because Al never assumed the covenants.

    Explanation

    An assignee of the tenant's entire remaining term stands in privity of estate with the landlord and is liable for covenants, such as rent, that run with the leasehold. An express assumption creates additional liability in privity of contract. The original tenant remains liable in privity of contract.

  163. Question 163Real Property

    Al and Ben hold Blackacre as joint tenants. Al conveys her interest to Carl. The result is:

    1. Al, Ben, and Carl hold as joint tenants.
    2. The conveyance is void without Ben's consent.
    3. Ben holds a fee simple and Carl takes nothing.
    4. Ben and Carl hold as tenants in common in equal shares. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A joint tenant may convey her interest unilaterally, and that conveyance severs the joint tenancy as to the transferred share. Ben keeps his half, Carl takes Al's half, and each holds as a tenant in common with the other because the unities are no longer intact. No cotenant's consent is required.

  164. Question 164Real Property

    Owen conveys to Alice, who does not record. Owen then conveys the same land to Ben, a bona fide purchaser who records. Ben then conveys to Carl, who knows of Alice's prior unrecorded deed. In a notice jurisdiction, Carl's title is:

    1. Subject to Alice's deed, because Carl had notice.
    2. Good, because Carl takes by shelter of Ben's status as a bona fide purchaser. Correct answer.
    3. Void, because Carl was not a purchaser for value.
    4. Subject to Alice's deed unless Carl paid value.

    Explanation

    Under the shelter rule, a person who takes from a bona fide purchaser receives all of the transferor's protection, even if the taker has actual notice of the earlier conveyance. Carl steps into Ben's superior position and prevails over Alice. Notice matters only for the purchaser whose status is being tested, not for the purchaser's transferees.

  165. Question 165Real Property

    Owen conveys "to Anna for life, then to Anna's children who reach 25." Anna has one child, age 3, when the deed is delivered. Which statement is correct?

    1. The remainder is valid because Anna is a life in being who must die before the period expires.
    2. The remainder is valid as to the existing child but void as to after-born children.
    3. The remainder is void under the Rule Against Perpetuities, leaving Anna with a life estate and Owen with the reversion. Correct answer.
    4. The remainder is void, and Anna takes a fee simple absolute.

    Explanation

    A child born to Anna shortly before her death could not reach 25 until more than 21 years after Anna's death, so no member of the class is certain to vest within the perpetuities period. Because the class gift fails as a whole, Anna keeps only her life estate and Owen's reversion remains. Modern statutes may reform the age or time period, but at common law the gift is void.

  166. Question 166Real Property

    Owen purports to convey Blackacre to Alice by warranty deed at a time when Owen owns no interest in Blackacre. Two years later Owen acquires title to Blackacre. Who owns Blackacre?

    1. Alice, but only if she recorded before Owen acquired title.
    2. Owen, because he held no title when the deed was delivered.
    3. Alice, because title passes automatically to her when Owen later acquires it. Correct answer.
    4. Owen and Alice as tenants in common.

    Explanation

    Under estoppel by deed, a grantor who conveys by warranty deed an interest he does not own is estopped to deny title, and when he later acquires the interest it passes automatically to the grantee. Recording is irrelevant to this doctrine. A quitclaim deed, by contrast, carries no such after-acquired title effect.

  167. Question 167Real Property

    Owen subdivides a tract and sells lots under a recorded declaration restricting all lots to residential use. Owen later conveys Lot 5 to Beth by a deed that omits the restriction, though a title search would reveal the declaration. Beth opens a day-care center, and a neighbor sues. The likely result is:

    1. The neighbor loses, because the restriction binds only the original purchaser.
    2. The neighbor loses, because the restriction does not appear in Beth's deed.
    3. The neighbor wins, because the restriction runs at law without regard to notice.
    4. The neighbor wins; Beth had record notice and is bound in equity. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A restriction enforceable as an equitable servitude binds a successor who takes with notice, whether or not the covenant appears in that successor's own deed, provided the original scheme intended to bind all lots. Record notice from the declaration satisfies the notice requirement, and horizontal privity existed between Owen and Beth. The remedy is typically injunctive rather than damages.

  168. Question 168Real Property

    A judgment creditor properly records a judgment lien against Owen. Owen then purchases Blackacre and gives Bank a purchase-money mortgage on it, which Bank records a week after closing. As between Bank and the judgment creditor:

    1. The judgment creditor prevails, because its lien was recorded first.
    2. The judgment creditor prevails, because Owen had no title when the lien was recorded.
    3. Bank prevails, because the judgment lien reaches only the equity Owen acquired. Correct answer.
    4. Bank prevails only if Owen signed a subordination agreement.

    Explanation

    A purchase-money mortgage takes priority over liens that attached to the purchaser's assets before the purchaser acquired title, because those liens reach only the equity the purchaser actually receives. This priority arises without recording and without any subordination agreement. The judgment lien therefore attaches only to Owen's equity after the purchase-money mortgage is satisfied.

  169. Question 169Real Property

    Work on a building begins April 10. On May 1, Bank records a mortgage it made to the owner. The contractor finishes in August and records a mechanic's lien on September 1. As between Bank and the contractor:

    1. The contractor prevails, because its lien relates back to the visible commencement of work. Correct answer.
    2. Bank prevails, because it recorded before the lien was recorded.
    3. The contractor prevails only if it notified Bank before starting work.
    4. Bank prevails, because it recorded before any work was done.

    Explanation

    Most mechanic's lien statutes date the lien from the commencement of the work of improvement, so a lien filed later still primes encumbrances recorded after visible work began. Bank's May 1 mortgage therefore falls behind the contractor's lien. Some statutes give construction lenders special priority only if they follow recording and notice requirements, which are absent here.

  170. Question 170Real Property

    Owen conveys Blackacre 'to the City School Board and its successors, so long as the parcel is used for a public school, and if it ceases to be so used, to Owen and his heirs.' Owen then dies. What interest in Blackacre passed to Owen's heirs?

    1. A fee simple subject to a condition subsequent.
    2. A right of entry for condition broken.
    3. A vested remainder in fee simple.
    4. A possibility of reverter. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Words such as 'so long as' or 'while' create a fee simple determinable, and the grantor automatically keeps a possibility of reverter, which is freely devisable and inheritable. The interest shifts back on its own when the stated use ends, with no need for the grantor or successors to re-enter or declare a forfeiture. Because the retained interest was inheritable, it descended to Owen's heirs at his death.

  171. Question 171Real Property

    Priya enclosed a strip of her neighbor's land with a fence in 2010 and farmed it openly and continuously. In 2016 she sold her parcel to Raj by warranty deed describing her lot, and Raj farmed the same strip openly and continuously until 2022. The adverse possession period is ten years. Who now holds title to the strip?

    1. Raj, because his predecessor's possession may be tacked onto his own. Correct answer.
    2. Neither, because adverse possession rights cannot be transferred to a successor.
    3. Priya, because Raj did not receive a deed to the strip.
    4. Priya and Raj as tenants in common.

    Explanation

    An adverse possessor may tack a predecessor's period of possession onto her own when the two are in privity, meaning the possession was transferred voluntarily as part of a conveyance of the land. Priya's six years plus Raj's six years exceed the ten-year period, and Raj's possession was open, hostile, and continuous. The deed need not describe the strip, because the transfer of the possessory interest is what supplies privity.

  172. Question 172Real Property

    Landlord grants Tenant a five-year lease in January and then in March mortgages the building to Bank, which immediately records. Landlord defaults and Bank forecloses, and a third party buys the building at the foreclosure sale. Tenant has eight months left on the lease. Which statement is correct?

    1. The purchaser may evict Tenant, because the lease is junior to the foreclosed mortgage. Correct answer.
    2. Tenant may remain in possession because the lease was signed before the mortgage was recorded.
    3. Tenant may remain as long as Tenant pays rent to the purchaser for the remaining term.
    4. Tenant may remain because foreclosure proceedings do not affect leases of the mortgaged property.

    Explanation

    A mortgage is a lien on the property, and foreclosure of a lien destroys every interest that is junior to it, including a lease granted after the mortgage was executed. Here the lease followed the mortgage, so the foreclosure sale extinguished it and the purchaser takes free of Tenant. A pre-existing lease senior to the mortgage would have survived the foreclosure sale, but that is not this case.

  173. Question 173Torts

    A man deliberately spat on another person's shoe during an argument. The other person was not physically hurt but was highly offended. In a battery action, is the man liable?

    1. No, because spitting amounts to an assault rather than a battery.
    2. No, because the plaintiff suffered no physical injury from the sputum.
    3. Yes, because the defendant intended an offensive contact that touched the plaintiff. Correct answer.
    4. Yes, but only if the plaintiff can prove lasting emotional harm from the contact.

    Explanation

    Battery requires intent to cause a harmful or offensive contact (or apprehension of one) and a resulting contact with the plaintiff's person or something closely connected to it. Physical injury is not an element, and offense is judged by a reasonable sense of personal dignity.

  174. Question 174Torts

    A man in a crowded room raised his fist and said, 'I'm going to knock your teeth out.' He stood close enough to strike, and the other person feared he would. Before any blow landed, security separated them. Can the frightened person recover for assault?

    1. No, because no physical contact ever occurred between the two men.
    2. Yes, because he intended to cause apprehension of an imminent harmful contact. Correct answer.
    3. Yes, but only if he was physically able to carry out the threatened blow at the time.
    4. No, because words alone can never amount to an assault at common law.

    Explanation

    Assault requires an act intended to cause apprehension of an imminent harmful or offensive contact and apprehension by the plaintiff. Words coupled with threatening conduct, such as a raised fist at close range, can suffice, and apparent ability to carry out the threat is enough.

  175. Question 175Torts

    A shopper with no suspicious behavior was stopped by a store guard, accused of shoplifting, and told she could not leave a small office for about ten minutes. The door was unlocked and she was not touched, but she believed she was not free to go and stayed. What is the best analysis of her claim?

    1. Battery, because the accusation was itself an offensive contact.
    2. No claim, because the detention lasted only about ten minutes.
    3. False imprisonment, because confinement may rest on an assertion of authority. Correct answer.
    4. No claim, because she was never physically restrained or locked in by the guard.

    Explanation

    False imprisonment is intentional confinement of another within boundaries fixed by the defendant, without consent or legal authority. Confinement may be accomplished by a threat or an assertion of authority to which the plaintiff submits; physical restraint and a locked door are not required, and any appreciable time suffices.

  176. Question 176Torts

    A neighbor intentionally threw a ladder onto another person's land and left it there for a week. The ladder caused no damage to the property. Is the neighbor liable for trespass to land?

    1. Yes, because an intentional entry by an object is a trespass regardless of harm. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, but only if the landowner had posted no-trespassing signs.
    3. No, because a physical entry by the neighbor's own body would be required.
    4. No, because the landowner suffered no measurable damage.

    Explanation

    Trespass to land requires an intentional physical invasion of land possessed by another, whether by the defendant personally or by a thing the defendant causes to enter. Harm to the land is not an element, and no posting or notice is required.

  177. Question 177Torts

    A strong swimmer watched a stranger drown in a shallow pool, though he could have saved the stranger without any risk to himself. The stranger was not his child, and he had no relationship with the stranger. Under the traditional common-law rule, is the swimmer liable?

    1. No, because there is no general duty to rescue a stranger absent a special relationship. Correct answer.
    2. Yes, because a reasonable person in his position would have attempted to save the swimmer.
    3. Yes, because his superior swimming skill imposed a higher duty on him.
    4. Yes, because he could have performed the rescue without risk to himself.

    Explanation

    The common law imposes no general duty to aid or rescue a stranger. Affirmative duties arise only from special relationships, from the defendant's creation of the peril, or from a voluntary undertaking, and superior skill or ease of rescue does not by itself create one.

  178. Question 178Torts

    A consumer was injured when the leg of a newly purchased chair collapsed as she sat on it. In a strict products liability action against the manufacturer, which element must she prove?

    1. That the defect existed when the product left the manufacturer and caused the injury. Correct answer.
    2. That the consumer bought the chair directly from the manufacturer.
    3. That the manufacturer failed to exercise reasonable care in making the chair.
    4. That the manufacturer knew of the defect at the time the chair was sold.

    Explanation

    Strict products liability requires proof of a defect that existed when the product left the defendant's control and that caused the plaintiff's injury. Negligence, the manufacturer's knowledge, and privity are not required.

  179. Question 179Torts

    A twelve-year-old child rode his bicycle on a sidewalk and struck and injured a pedestrian. What standard of care governs the child's conduct in the pedestrian's negligence action?

    1. That of a reasonable child of the same age and experience, unless engaged in an adult activity. Correct answer.
    2. That of a reasonable adult, because operating a bicycle on public walkways is an inherently dangerous activity.
    3. No duty at all, because a child of twelve cannot be negligent.
    4. Strict liability, because riding a bicycle is an abnormally dangerous activity.

    Explanation

    A minor is held to the standard of a reasonable child of the same age, intelligence, and experience, unless the child is engaged in an activity normally undertaken only by adults, in which case the adult standard applies. Riding a bicycle is a childhood activity, so the child standard governs.

  180. Question 180Torts

    A newspaper printed a false statement that a private citizen had been convicted of burglary; the citizen had never been charged with any crime. The statement concerned a purely private matter. What must the citizen show to make out the publication element of libel?

    1. That the newspaper acted with actual malice toward the citizen.
    2. That the newspaper actually believed the statement to be true.
    3. That the statement was defamatory and was published to a third party. Correct answer.
    4. That the statement was spoken aloud rather than printed and circulated to readers.

    Explanation

    Libel requires a defamatory statement of and concerning the plaintiff that is published to a third party. A private figure on a matter of private concern need not prove actual malice, and written or printed publication is what makes the statement libel rather than slander.

  181. Question 181Torts

    A salesperson driving a company car to a client meeting during work hours turned two blocks out of his way to buy coffee for himself. While returning to his route he negligently struck another car. Is the employer vicariously liable?

    1. Yes, because a minor personal errand is a detour within the scope of employment. Correct answer.
    2. No, because the employee was not authorized to buy coffee on the trip.
    3. No, because any personal deviation ends the scope of employment.
    4. Yes, because the employer owned the vehicle the employee was driving.

    Explanation

    Under respondeat superior an employer is liable for torts committed by an employee acting within the scope of employment. A minor personal errand that does not substantially depart from the employer's business is a detour rather than a frolic and does not relieve the employer.

  182. Question 182Torts

    A customer in a grocery store slipped on a spilled jar of salsa that had been on the floor for several hours while employees walked past it. Which statement best describes the store's duty to the customer?

    1. A duty of reasonable care to inspect for dangerous conditions and to warn of or remedy them. Correct answer.
    2. No duty until the customer is actually harmed by a condition on the premises.
    3. Only a duty to refrain from willful or wanton misconduct toward customers.
    4. Strict liability for any injury that occurs on the premises, because customers are invitees.

    Explanation

    A possessor of land owes an invitee a duty of reasonable care, which includes the duty to inspect for and discover latent dangerous conditions and to warn of or remedy them. The possessor is not an insurer of the customer's safety.

  183. Question 183Torts

    A patient undergoing a routine appendectomy awoke with a burn on his thigh that was not present beforehand and that does not ordinarily occur without negligence. All instruments and staff involved were under the hospital's control, but the patient cannot identify the specific negligent act. What is the best analysis?

    1. The patient may invoke res ipsa loquitur, and the jury may infer negligence. Correct answer.
    2. The patient loses, because res ipsa loquitur requires a single instrumentality.
    3. The patient loses, because he cannot identify the specific negligent act.
    4. The patient must prove negligence by clear and convincing evidence.

    Explanation

    Res ipsa loquitur permits an inference of negligence when the injury is of a kind that ordinarily does not occur without negligence, was caused by an instrumentality in the defendant's exclusive control, and is not attributable to the plaintiff. The doctrine exists precisely to allow recovery when the specific negligent act cannot be identified.

  184. Question 184Torts

    A driver ran a red light and blocked an intersection; a second driver, forced to stop, was then struck by a third car that skidded on ice. In deciding whether the first driver's conduct was an actual cause of the second driver's injury, which test applies?

    1. The first driver is an actual cause only if he was the last negligent actor.
    2. The first driver is an actual cause only if the resulting harm was foreseeable to him.
    3. The first driver is an actual cause if his conduct was a substantial factor. Correct answer.
    4. The first driver is an actual cause only if his conduct was the sole cause.

    Explanation

    Actual cause is established by the but-for test or, where multiple causes concur, by showing that the conduct was a substantial factor in bringing about the harm. Foreseeability is a question of proximate cause, not of cause in fact.

  185. Question 185Torts

    A defendant negligently injured a pedestrian. At the hospital, a physician negligently treated the wound and significantly worsened the pedestrian's condition. Is the defendant liable for the worsened condition?

    1. Yes, but only if the physician's negligence amounted to gross negligence.
    2. Yes, because negligent medical treatment is a foreseeable intervening force. Correct answer.
    3. No, because the defendant is liable only for the harm that his own conduct directly caused.
    4. No, because the physician's negligence is a superseding cause of the worsening.

    Explanation

    A tortfeasor is liable for the foreseeable consequences of the injury inflicted, and negligent medical treatment of that injury is a classic foreseeable intervening force that does not supersede the original actor's liability. Only extraordinary, unforeseeable intervening acts break the chain of causation.

  186. Question 186Torts

    A plaintiff suffered $100,000 in damages. A jury found the plaintiff 30% at fault and the defendant 70% at fault, and the jurisdiction follows pure comparative negligence. What amount may the plaintiff recover from the defendant?

    1. $100,000, because comparative negligence applies only to defendants' fault.
    2. $50,000, because the loss is divided equally between the parties.
    3. $70,000, because the award is reduced by the plaintiff's share of fault. Correct answer.
    4. Nothing, because any fault on the plaintiff's part bars recovery entirely.

    Explanation

    Pure comparative negligence reduces the plaintiff's recovery by the plaintiff's percentage of fault but does not bar recovery however great that fault may be. Damages of $100,000 with 30% plaintiff fault therefore yield $70,000.

  187. Question 187Torts

    A spectator at a baseball game sat in an unscreened seat behind first base, knowing that foul balls occasionally fly into that area. She was struck by a foul ball. Which doctrine is the stadium most likely to invoke?

    1. Contributory negligence, which bars recovery in every jurisdiction.
    2. The last clear chance rule, because the stadium could have screened that seat.
    3. Res ipsa loquitur, because foul balls rarely leave the field of play.
    4. Assumption of risk, because she voluntarily confronted a known risk inherent in the sport. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under primary assumption of risk, a plaintiff who voluntarily attends a sporting event assumes the risks inherent in it, and the defendant owes no duty as to those risks. Foul balls hit into unscreened seating are an inherent, known risk of baseball.

  188. Question 188Torts

    A defendant, knowing that a woman was especially vulnerable after a recent miscarriage, deliberately and repeatedly telephoned her with false claims that her husband had died. She suffered severe distress requiring treatment. Which tort is established?

    1. Defamation, because the statements about her husband were false.
    2. Intentional infliction of emotional distress, because the conduct was extreme and outrageous. Correct answer.
    3. Negligent infliction of emotional distress, because he should have foreseen the harm.
    4. Assault, because the telephone calls caused her to apprehend imminent contact.

    Explanation

    Intentional infliction of emotional distress requires extreme and outrageous conduct, intent or recklessness as to causing severe distress, causation, and severe emotional distress. Exploiting a known vulnerability with repeated false death notices exceeds all bounds of decency.

  189. Question 189Torts

    A neighbor borrowed another person's $800 bicycle for a planned one-hour ride but, becoming angry over an unrelated dispute, sold the bicycle to a stranger and kept the money. Which tort best describes this conduct?

    1. Trespass to chattels, because the bicycle itself was not destroyed.
    2. No tort, because the neighbor originally consented to the borrowing.
    3. Nuisance, because the sale interfered with the owner's use of property.
    4. Conversion, because an unauthorized sale seriously interferes with the owner's rights. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Conversion is an intentional exercise of dominion over a chattel that so seriously interferes with the owner's rights that the defendant may justly be required to pay its full value. An unauthorized sale of another's property is the classic illustration.

  190. Question 190Torts

    A factory emits noxious fumes that drift onto an adjacent residential property, making the home uninhabitable and causing the owners to become ill. The factory is lawful, uses reasonable care, and holds all required permits. Which claim is most likely to succeed?

    1. No claim, because the factory complied with its permits and used due care.
    2. Conversion, because the fumes deprived the owners of the use of their home.
    3. Strict liability, because emitting noxious fumes is an abnormally dangerous activity.
    4. Private nuisance, because the fumes substantially interfere with use and enjoyment. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Private nuisance is a substantial and unreasonable interference with another's use and enjoyment of land. Compliance with permits and the exercise of reasonable care do not defeat the claim, and liability does not depend on the activity being abnormally dangerous.

  191. Question 191Torts

    During a heated argument, a man raised his hand as if to slap a woman. She reasonably believed he was about to strike her and punched him in the nose, breaking it. In fact he had only been reaching to swat a mosquito. In her defense to his battery claim, which is correct?

    1. She is liable, because the man was not in fact about to strike her.
    2. She is not liable, because reasonable self-defense may rest on a reasonable mistake. Correct answer.
    3. She is not liable, because any force is permitted against a raised hand.
    4. She is liable, because self-defense permits only retreat, never force.

    Explanation

    A person may use reasonable force to defend against an imminent battery if she reasonably believes force is about to be used, even if that belief proves mistaken. The privilege covers only force proportionate to the threatened harm.

  192. Question 192Torts

    A boxer consented to a professional bout and was injured by a punch thrown within the rules of the match. He sued his opponent for battery. What result?

    1. He recovers, because consent to a boxing match is never a valid defense to battery.
    2. He does not recover, because consent covers contacts within the rules of the bout. Correct answer.
    3. He recovers, because a battery requires only a harmful contact.
    4. He recovers, because the other boxer intended the contact that caused his injury.

    Explanation

    Consent to a particular contact is a defense to battery and covers contacts within the scope of what was consented to. A boxer consents to blows within the rules of the bout, though not to blows deliberately outside them.

  193. Question 193Torts

    A manufacturer sold a power saw whose blade guard could be removed by the user to make a particular cut. The design was the safest practical alternative then known and met industry standards; a consumer who removed the guard was injured. Under the risk-utility test, which is the strongest argument that the design is not defective?

    1. That the consumer removed the guard, which bars any claim based on design.
    2. That the manufacturer complied with industry custom, which conclusively establishes that the design is not defective.
    3. That the consumer did not purchase the saw directly from the manufacturer.
    4. That the design's benefits outweigh its risks and no reasonable alternative design was available. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under the risk-utility test a product is defectively designed only if its risks outweigh its benefits and a reasonable alternative design could have reduced the risk without excessive cost or loss of utility. Compliance with standards is evidence of, but not conclusive proof of, non-defectiveness.

  194. Question 194Torts

    A defendant's negligent driving caused a minor fender-bender. The other driver, who had a rare pre-existing bone condition, suffered a severe fracture from a modest impact that would not have hurt an ordinary person. Is the defendant liable for the full extent of that injury?

    1. No, because the severity of the injury was not foreseeable.
    2. Yes, but only if the defendant knew of the pre-existing bone condition.
    3. No, because liability is limited to the harm that an ordinary person would have suffered from that impact.
    4. Yes, because a defendant takes the plaintiff as he finds him, including an unforeseeable extent. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A tortfeasor takes the plaintiff as she finds him, so a pre-existing condition that aggravates the harm does not reduce liability, and the full extent of the foreseeable type of harm is compensable. Foreseeability limits the kind of harm, not its severity.

  195. Question 195Torts

    Two defendants independently and concurrently started fires that merged and burned a plaintiff's house. Neither fire alone would have destroyed the house, and the harm is indivisible. The jurisdiction retains joint and several liability. What is the result?

    1. Each defendant is liable only for a proportionate share, since several liability is the modern default.
    2. Neither defendant is liable, because neither one alone was a but-for cause of the harm.
    3. Each is jointly and severally liable for the whole judgment, since each caused an indivisible harm. Correct answer.
    4. Only the defendant whose fire was larger is liable, in proportion to the size of the fire.

    Explanation

    When two tortfeasors act independently but each is a substantial factor in causing a single indivisible harm, each is jointly and severally liable for the entire harm. The substantial factor test substitutes for but-for causation when multiple causes concur.

  196. Question 196Torts

    A mother watched from a nearby porch as a negligent driver struck and killed her child. She was outside the zone of physical danger and suffered no physical injury, but she developed severe emotional distress. Under the bystander rules followed in most jurisdictions, may she recover?

    1. Yes, because any person who witnesses a traumatic event may recover for emotional distress.
    2. No, because she suffered no physical manifestation of her distress, which every jurisdiction requires.
    3. No, because she was outside the zone of physical danger and cannot recover for emotional harm.
    4. Yes, if she was closely related to the victim, present at the scene, and perceived the accident. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under the bystander theory a close relative who is present at the scene and contemporaneously perceives the accident may recover for serious emotional distress caused by observing injury to the victim, without being in the zone of danger or showing physical symptoms.

  197. Question 197Torts

    A store manager, reasonably but mistakenly believing a customer had stolen merchandise, swore out a criminal complaint. The customer was prosecuted and acquitted, then sued for malicious prosecution. Which fact will defeat the customer's claim?

    1. The manager's reasonable belief that the customer stole merchandise. Correct answer.
    2. The absence of any physical injury to the customer from the prosecution.
    3. The customer's acquittal, which establishes favorable termination of the case.
    4. The filing of a sworn complaint, which proves probable cause in every case.

    Explanation

    Malicious prosecution requires a prior proceeding initiated or continued without probable cause, with malice and an improper purpose, that terminates favorably to the plaintiff. A reasonable belief that the plaintiff committed the crime supplies probable cause and defeats the claim.

  198. Question 198Torts

    A homeowner invited a neighbor over for dinner. The homeowner knew that the third step of the front porch had rotted through, but she had never repaired it and said nothing to the neighbor. As the neighbor climbed the steps after dark, the step gave way and he fell, breaking his ankle. The neighbor had never visited the house before and could not see the defect. What duty did the homeowner owe the neighbor?

    1. A duty to inspect the premises for latent defects and to repair every defect that a reasonable inspection of the property would have revealed.
    2. A duty to warn of known concealed dangerous conditions that the guest is unlikely to discover. Correct answer.
    3. A duty to guarantee that the premises are reasonably safe for any visitor the homeowner invites onto the property.
    4. No duty at all, because a social guest takes the premises as he finds them.

    Explanation

    A social guest is a licensee, to whom the possessor owes a duty to warn of concealed dangerous conditions that the possessor knows about and that the guest is unlikely to discover. Because the homeowner knew the step was rotten and the guest could not see the defect, the failure to warn breached that duty. A licensee is not owed a duty of inspection or repair, nor is the possessor an insurer of the visitor's safety.

  199. Question 199Torts

    A city ordinance requires that every commercial delivery truck operating within the city be equipped with an audible backup alarm. A bakery's delivery truck lacked the alarm. While the driver was backing into an alley, he struck and injured a pedestrian who was walking behind the truck. The pedestrian sues the bakery in negligence. What effect does the ordinance have on the claim?

    1. It has no bearing on the claim, because only statutes enacted by the state legislature can supply a standard of care in negligence.
    2. It supplies a standard of care only if the pedestrian shows that the bakery acted with the specific intent to violate the ordinance.
    3. It makes the bakery strictly liable for the pedestrian's injuries without any showing that the bakery was at fault.
    4. It supplies the standard of care, and an unexcused violation of it is a breach of the duty owed to the pedestrian. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    Under negligence per se, a statute or ordinance sets the standard of care when the plaintiff is within the class of persons the law was meant to protect and the injury is of the type the law was meant to prevent. An unexcused violation of that standard establishes breach of duty, leaving the plaintiff to prove cause and damages. Pedestrians are the class protected by a backup-alarm requirement, and being struck by a reversing truck is the harm the ordinance targets.

  200. Question 200Torts

    A patient told his psychotherapist that he intended to kill a named woman he had recently dated. The therapist believed the threat was serious but took no steps to warn the woman or to notify the police. Several weeks later the patient carried out the killing. The woman's family sues the therapist for wrongful death. What is the most likely result?

    1. The therapist is not liable, because the psychotherapist-patient privilege absolutely barred the therapist from disclosing anything the patient said during treatment.
    2. The therapist is not liable, because the patient's deliberate criminal act is a superseding cause that cuts off any duty the therapist may have owed.
    3. The therapist is liable only if the patient had previously committed an act of violence against this particular woman.
    4. The therapist may be liable, because the therapist owed a duty of reasonable care to protect the identified victim from the patient's foreseeable violence. Correct answer.

    Explanation

    A mental health professional who determines, or reasonably should determine, that a patient presents a serious danger of violence to an identifiable third person owes that person a duty of reasonable care to protect her. That duty is discharged by taking reasonable steps, such as warning the intended victim and notifying law enforcement. Public policy places the duty to control foreseeable danger on the therapist rather than on the unaware victim.

CA Bar flashcards

32 cards. Read the term and the definition here. The deck at the top of this page is optional.

Complete diversity
For federal diversity jurisdiction, no plaintiff may share state citizenship with any defendant; citizenship is measured at the time the action is filed and minimal diversity is insufficient.
Amount in controversy
Diversity jurisdiction requires that the amount in controversy exceed $75,000, measured by the plaintiff's good-faith claim rather than the eventual recovery and exclusive of interest and costs.
Erie doctrine
A federal court sitting in diversity applies state substantive law and federal procedural law; where a valid Federal Rule directly conflicts with state practice, the Rule governs under Hanna.
Claim preclusion elements
A final judgment on the merits bars a later action when the same parties or their privies assert the same claim, including claims that could have been raised in the first suit.
Strict scrutiny
A law survives only if it serves a compelling government interest and is narrowly tailored as the least restrictive means; it applies to suspect classifications and infringements of fundamental rights.
Intermediate scrutiny
The classification must serve an important government interest and be substantially related to achieving that interest; the standard applies to sex-based classifications and to illegitimacy.
Dormant Commerce Clause
States may not discriminate against interstate commerce absent a legitimate local purpose that cannot be served by nondiscriminatory means, and nondiscriminatory burdens face Pike balancing.
Standing requirements
A plaintiff must show an injury in fact that is concrete and particularized, fairly traceable to the defendant's conduct, and likely to be redressed by a favorable decision.
Content-neutral time, place, manner
Regulation of speech in a public forum must be content-neutral, narrowly tailored to serve a significant government interest, and must leave open ample alternative channels of communication.
UCC 2-207
A definite and seasonable expression of acceptance operates as acceptance even with additional terms; between merchants those terms join the contract unless material, objected to, or already refused.
Statute of Frauds categories
A signed writing is required for promises involving marriage, performance over one year, land, executor liability, goods of $500 or more, and suretyship obligations.
Promissory estoppel
A promise that the promisor reasonably expects to induce reliance, and on which the promisee actually and justifiably relies, is binding to the extent justice requires despite the absence of consideration.
Perfect tender rule
Under UCC Article 2 the buyer may reject goods that fail in any respect to conform, subject to the seller's right to cure and to limitations on installment contracts.
Anticipatory repudiation
A clear and unequivocal indication, before performance is due, that a party will not perform discharges the other party's duties and permits immediate suit for breach.
Miranda trigger
Warnings are required for custodial interrogation: custody exists when a reasonable person would not feel free to leave, and interrogation means words likely to elicit an incriminating response.
Terry stop
Police may briefly detain a person on reasonable suspicion of criminal activity and may frisk for weapons when they reasonably suspect the person is armed and presently dangerous.
Felony murder limits
The underlying felony must be inherently dangerous and independent of the killing under the merger doctrine, and agency jurisdictions require the killing to be committed by a felon.
M'Naghten test
A defendant is not guilty if, because of a mental disease or defect, he did not know the nature and quality of the act or did not know that it was wrong.
Double jeopardy attachment
Jeopardy attaches when the jury is sworn or, in a bench trial, when the first witness is sworn; an acquittal bars retrial for the same offense.
Hearsay definition
An out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted; a statement offered only to show its effect on the listener is not hearsay.
Excited utterance
A statement describing or explaining a startling event, made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement it caused; the declarant's availability is immaterial.
MIMIC exceptions
Evidence of prior bad acts is admissible to prove motive, intent, absence of mistake, identity, or a common plan, but not to show propensity, and remains subject to Rule 403.
Confrontation Clause
Testimonial hearsay is inadmissible unless the declarant is unavailable and the defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine, even when a hearsay exception otherwise applies.
Best evidence rule
To prove the contents of a writing, recording, or photograph, the original must be produced unless an exception such as loss, collateral matter, or an official record applies.
Joint tenancy unities
Joint tenancy requires the unities of time, title, interest, and possession and gives the surviving joint tenant the entire estate by right of survivorship.
Real covenant requirements
Enforcement by damages requires a writing, intent to bind successors, touch and concern, horizontal and vertical privity, and notice to the burdened party.
Adverse possession elements
Possession must be actual, exclusive, open and notorious, continuous for the statutory period, and hostile under the objective standard; color of title may extend constructive possession.
Race-notice recording
A later purchaser prevails by recording first without actual, inquiry, or record notice of a prior unrecorded interest; the shelter rule protects grantees of a protected purchaser.
Res ipsa loquitur
Negligence may be inferred when the injuring instrumentality was in the defendant's exclusive control and the accident is of a kind that would not ordinarily occur absent negligence.
Negligence per se
An unexcused statutory violation establishes breach when the statute sets a standard of conduct, the plaintiff is within the protected class, and the harm is the type the statute prevents.
Strict products liability
A commercial seller is liable for harm caused by a product defect in manufacture, design, or warnings existing at the time of sale, without proof of negligence, if the use was foreseeable.
Public figure actual malice
A public official or public figure suing for defamation about public conduct must prove knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for the truth by clear and convincing evidence.

CA Bar study guide

Civil Procedure

Jurisdiction and the Federal Framework

Civil Procedure rewards a checklist mindset. Start with subject-matter jurisdiction: federal question (well-pleaded complaint), diversity (complete diversity at filing plus more than $75,000 in controversy, excluding interest and costs), and supplemental jurisdiction under §1367, which does not reach claims by plaintiffs against non-diverse parties. Corporations are citizens of both the state of incorporation and the principal place of business; unincorporated associations take their members' citizenship. Personal jurisdiction requires minimum contacts plus fairness - general (essentially at home) versus specific (arising out of or relating to purposeful availment). Venue lies where a defendant resides, where events occurred, or where property sits.

Erie, Pleading, and Preclusion

Erie: federal courts apply substantive state law but federal procedure; ask whether a rule is arguably procedural. Pleading requires plausibility, not conclusory labels. Know the joinder devices (permissive and compulsory counterclaims, impleader, intervention, interpleader) and the trial sequence: JMOL before verdict, renewed JMOL after, then a new-trial motion.

Traps

  • Removal: a forum-state defendant cannot remove; one-year cap on diversity removal.
  • Amount in controversy: the plaintiff's good-faith claim controls unless it appears to a legal certainty that recovery is impossible.
  • Claim preclusion requires the same claim, a final judgment, and privity; issue preclusion requires an issue actually litigated and necessary to the judgment.

Worked example: Plaintiff, a citizen of State A, sues defendants who are citizens of A and B for $80,000. Diversity fails because of the A defendant - complete diversity is measured from the complaint, and §1367 cannot cure a plaintiff-versus-party defect. Rule of thumb: draw the citizenship columns before anything else.

Constitutional Law

Structure and Justiciability

Constitutional Law questions usually turn on a threshold. Confirm judicial review, standing (injury in fact, causation, redressability), ripeness, mootness, and the political question doctrine before reaching the merits. Sovereign immunity blocks damages against states, but Ex parte Young permits prospective injunctive relief against officers. The Supremacy Clause produces preemption: express, field, or conflict.

Federalism and Individual Rights

The Commerce Clause reaches channels, instrumentalities, and activities substantially affecting interstate commerce. The Dormant Commerce Clause bars discriminatory state laws absent a legitimate local purpose; Pike balancing applies to neutral laws. Article IV Privileges and Immunities protects fundamental commercial activities of nonresidents.

Due process divides procedural (notice plus Mathews balancing) from substantive (fundamental rights get strict scrutiny; economic regulation gets rational basis). Equal protection: suspect classes strict, sex intermediate (exceedingly persuasive justification), everything else rational basis.

First Amendment: content-based regulation of protected speech gets strict scrutiny; content-neutral time/place/manner rules in a public forum need narrow tailoring and alternatives. Viewpoint discrimination is fatal. Unprotected categories include incitement (Brandenburg), true threats, fighting words, obscenity, and fraud. Commercial speech gets intermediate scrutiny. Establishment Clause analysis now emphasizes historical practices and coercion; free exercise generally applies neutrality (Smith), with strict scrutiny for individualized exemptions.

Traps

  • State action is required; private conduct is not covered.
  • Taxpayer standing is narrow (Establishment Clause).
  • Facially neutral laws with discriminatory purpose still fail.

Worked example: a city bans all park signs except political signs - content-based, strict scrutiny, likely invalid.

Contracts

Formation

Ask first: common law or UCC Article 2 (goods, merchants)? Common law requires offer, acceptance (mirror image, mailbox rule), and consideration (bargained-for exchange). An option needs consideration; a merchant's firm offer under UCC 2-205 does not. UCC 2-207 governs the battle of the forms: a definite acceptance operates even with different terms; between merchants, additional terms enter unless material, objected to, or the offer limits acceptance.

Defenses and Performance

Statute of Frauds categories (MY LEGS: marriage, year, land, executor, goods $500+, surety), with exceptions - part performance, admissions, specially manufactured goods. Parol evidence bars prior and contemporaneous terms but permits course of dealing, usage of trade, and explanations of ambiguity. Conditions must be strictly satisfied; promises need only substantial performance. Anticipatory repudiation excuses the other party. Impracticability requires an unforeseen event making performance commercially impracticable.

Remedies and Third Parties

Expectation equals benefit of the bargain; reliance and restitution are alternatives. Liquidated damages must be reasonable; specific performance is for unique goods. Third-party beneficiary rights vest on adoption, assent, or reliance. Assignment is valid unless it materially changes duties or is barred by contract; delegation is barred for personal services.

Traps

  • Pre-existing duty rule; UCC changes it for part-payment checks.
  • Merchant status changes many UCC rules.
  • Option contracts cannot be revoked.

Worked example: Buyer sends a purchase order for 1,000 widgets; Seller ships 1,000 with an added arbitration clause. Under 2-207 a contract exists; the clause is a proposal and, between merchants, may become part unless material - arbitration clauses are often material.

Criminal Law and Procedure

Elements and Defenses

Criminal law tests mens rea precision: purposely, knowingly, recklessly, negligently. Actus reus requires voluntary conduct, concurrence with intent, and actual and proximate causation. Inchoate crimes: attempt requires intent plus a substantial step; conspiracy requires agreement plus intent plus an overt act (common law no overt act; MPC yes) and does not merge with the completed offense. Accomplices are liable for foreseeable crimes in furtherance of the enterprise.

Homicide and Defenses

Murder is an unlawful killing with malice (intent, reckless indifference, felony murder). First-degree typically requires premeditation or an enumerated felony; manslaughter is heat of passion or criminal negligence. Defenses: self-defense (reasonable belief, proportionality, no initial aggressor), defense of others, duress (not for homicide), necessity, insanity (M'Naghten or MPC), and intoxication (specific intent only).

Procedure

Fourth Amendment: searches need probable cause plus a warrant absent an exception - consent, search incident to arrest, automobile, plain view, exigency, inventory, or stop-and-frisk (reasonable suspicion of weapons). The exclusionary rule has good-faith, inevitable-discovery, and attenuation exceptions. Fifth Amendment: Miranda requires custody plus interrogation; booking questions and public safety do not. Sixth Amendment attaches at formal proceedings and is offense-specific. Double jeopardy bars reprosecution after acquittal.

Traps

  • Miranda warnings are not required for spontaneous statements.
  • Probable cause to search a car extends to containers within it.
  • Conspiracy is punishable even if the substantive crime is impossible.

Worked example: an officer stops a car for speeding, smells marijuana, and searches the trunk - lawful under the automobile exception if probable cause exists.

Evidence

Relevance and Character

Relevance is a low bar (probative plus material); Rule 403 excludes unfair prejudice. Character evidence is barred to prove propensity, except: the accused may open the door, the prosecution may rebut, victim character in self-defense, and specific sex-offense exceptions (with 404(b) notice requirements). Other acts are admissible for MIMIC: motive, identity, absence of mistake, intent, common plan.

Impeachment and Hearsay

Impeach with prior inconsistent statements (under oath, also substantive), bias, sensory deficiency, convictions (felony with 403; dishonesty per se), reputation for truthfulness, and contradiction. Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered for truth. Nonhearsay: effect on listener, verbal act, state of mind. Exemptions: party-opponent and prior sworn statements. Exceptions: present sense impression, excited utterance, then-existing condition, medical treatment, business records, public records, learned treatises, judgment of conviction, dying declaration, forfeiture.

Confrontation, Experts, and Privileges

Crawford bars testimonial hearsay absent unavailability plus prior cross-examination. Experts need qualification, reliable method, and helpfulness (Daubert; California uses Kelly-Frye). Authentication and the best-evidence rule complete the chain. Privileges: attorney-client, physician-patient (California), spousal.

Traps

  • A statement offered to show its effect is not hearsay even if false.
  • Prior consistent statements are generally rehabilitative, not substantive.
  • Curative admissibility does not open the door to extrinsic evidence on collateral matters.

Worked example: "Watch out, the floor is wet!" offered to show the listener had notice is nonhearsay; offered to prove the floor was wet, it is hearsay but likely an excited utterance or present sense impression.

Real Property

Estates and Future Interests

Fee simple absolute, defeasible fees (fee simple determinable with possibility of reverter; fee simple subject to condition subsequent with right of entry; fee simple subject to executory limitation), and life estates. Remainders are vested (indefeasibly, subject to open or divestment) or contingent. The Rule Against Perpetuities: no interest is good unless it must vest, if at all, within 21 years of a life in being; it applies to contingent remainders, executory interests, and vested remainders subject to open - not to reversions or indefeasibly vested remainders.

Co-tenancy and Landlord-Tenant

Joint tenancy requires the four unities plus survivorship; severance by conveyance. Tenancy in common has no survivorship; tenancy by the entirety in some states. Leaseholds: term of years, periodic, at will, at sufferance. Know the implied warranty of habitability, constructive eviction, and rent abatement.

Servitudes and Recording

Easements: express, implied (prior use), necessity (strict necessity plus unity of ownership), prescriptive (adverse use). Covenants run with land if there is writing, intent, touch and concern, notice, and privity. Equitable servitudes require notice. Recording acts: race, notice, race-notice; a BFP takes free of prior unrecorded interests. The shelter rule protects transferees from BFPs. Marketable title requires no encumbrances.

Traps

  • RAP: fertile octogenarian and unborn widow problems.
  • Easement by necessity ends when the necessity ends; prescriptive easements need adverse use, not exclusivity.
  • Wild deeds give no constructive notice.

Worked example: O conveys to A, who does not record; O then conveys to B, a BFP who records first. In a notice or race-notice jurisdiction, B wins.

Torts

Intentional Torts and Negligence

Intentional torts require intent (purpose or substantial certainty) plus causation. Battery (harmful or offensive contact), assault (apprehension), false imprisonment, IIED (extreme and outrageous conduct), trespass, conversion. Defenses: consent, self-defense, necessity.

Negligence: duty (Cardozo foreseeability or Andrews), breach (reasonable person; professionals; children; landowners - no duty to trespassers except known or anticipated, warning of known dangers to licensees, reasonable inspection for invitees), actual cause (but-for) and proximate cause (foreseeability; intervening causes). Res ipsa loquitur requires exclusive control and an injury that ordinarily does not occur without negligence. Negligence per se requires the statute's class and harm. Defenses: comparative negligence and assumption of risk.

Strict Liability and Products

Animals (wild strict; domestic if known propensity), abnormally dangerous activities, and products liability (manufacturing, design, warning; foreseeable use; learned intermediary). Defamation: publication, defamatory meaning, damages; public figures need actual malice. Privacy torts: intrusion, disclosure, false light, appropriation.

Damages and Traps

Eggshell plaintiff; mitigation; joint and several liability. Traps: no duty to rescue absent a special relationship; firefighter's rule; economic loss rule; unforeseeable intervening criminal acts usually cut off proximate cause.

Worked example: a driver speeds through a red light and hits a pedestrian - negligence per se if the statute was designed to protect pedestrians from this type of harm; causation must still be shown.

CA Bar cheat sheet

Quick reference

Civil Procedure

  • Personal jurisdiction requires purposeful availment plus fair play and substantial justice; general jurisdiction exists only where a defendant is essentially "at home" (domicile, principal place of business, or state of incorporation).

  • Diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1332 requires complete diversity of citizenship and an amount in controversy exceeding $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.

  • Removal must be filed within 30 days of service of the removable pleading; a diversity case cannot be removed more than one year after commencement or if any properly joined defendant is a citizen of the forum.

  • Venue under § 1391 lies where any defendant resides if all defendants reside in the same state, where a substantial part of the events occurred, or where any defendant is subject to personal jurisdiction.

  • A Rule 12(b)(6) motion tests plausibility under Twombly/Iqbal; a responsive pleading is due 21 days after service, or 60 days if a waiver of service was returned.

  • Erie requires federal courts in diversity cases to apply state substantive law and federal procedural law; a valid Federal Rule that directly conflicts governs under Hanna.

  • Summary judgment requires no genuine dispute of material fact and entitlement to judgment as a matter of law, with evidence viewed in the nonmovant's favor.

  • Claim preclusion requires a final judgment on the merits, the same parties or their privies, and the same claim; issue preclusion additionally requires that the issue was actually litigated and necessarily decided.

  • Rule 23(b)(3) certification requires that common questions predominate and that a class action is superior to individual adjudication.

Quick reference

Constitutional Law

  • Strict scrutiny (compelling interest plus narrow tailoring/least restrictive means) applies to suspect classifications such as race and national origin and to fundamental rights such as voting, travel, and marriage.

  • Intermediate scrutiny (important interest plus substantial relation) applies to sex-based classifications, illegitimacy, and content-neutral time, place, and manner regulations of speech.

  • Rational basis review upholds a law rationally related to a legitimate government purpose and governs economic and social legislation, age, and wealth classifications.

  • Dormant Commerce Clause: a discriminatory state law is invalid unless it serves a legitimate local purpose that cannot be served by nondiscriminatory means; nondiscriminatory burdens are upheld unless clearly excessive under Pike.

  • Standing requires an injury in fact that is concrete and particularized, fairly traceable to the defendant, and likely redressable; taxpayer standing is limited to Establishment Clause challenges to enacted spending.

  • Content-based speech restrictions receive strict scrutiny, prior restraints are presumptively invalid, and obscenity (Miller), incitement (Brandenburg), fighting words, and true threats fall outside First Amendment protection.

  • Fourth Amendment: a warrant requires probable cause and particularity, and exceptions include search incident to arrest, automobile, consent, plain view, exigency, inventory, and the Terry frisk.

  • Procedural due process under Mathews balances the private interest, the risk of erroneous deprivation, and the government's burden; substantive due process protects fundamental rights against arbitrary interference.

  • Preemption may be express, field, or conflict (impossibility or obstacle); state law is invalid to the extent it stands as an obstacle to a valid federal scheme.

Quick reference

Contracts

  • UCC § 2-207: a definite and seasonable expression of acceptance operates as an acceptance even with different terms; between merchants, additional terms enter unless material, objected to within a reasonable time, or already refused.

  • Statute of Frauds categories (MY LEGS): marriage, year-or-more performance, land, executor's personal promise, goods of $500 or more, and suretyship.

  • Consideration requires a bargained-for exchange of legal value; the preexisting duty rule and past consideration do not supply consideration, though promissory estoppel may substitute.

  • Parol evidence: a fully integrated writing bars prior or contemporaneous agreements on covered terms, with exceptions for ambiguity, fraud, mistake, condition precedent, and consistent additional terms in partial integrations.

  • Under the UCC perfect tender rule the buyer may reject nonconforming goods, but the seller may cure within the contract time, or beyond it with reasonable notice where the buyer has accepted or the time has not expired.

  • Anticipatory repudiation must be clear and unequivocal; it excuses the other party's remaining duties and permits immediate suit unless retracted before a material change in position.

  • Impracticability requires an unforeseen event whose nonoccurrence was a basic assumption and no assumption of risk by the party; frustration of purpose requires substantial frustration of the principal purpose.

  • Expectation damages equal loss in value plus incidental and consequential damages minus costs avoided; the aggrieved party must mitigate, and liquidated damages must be a reasonable forecast of a hard-to-estimate loss.

  • UCC risk of loss: in a shipment contract risk passes to the carrier, in a destination contract risk passes on tender at destination, and FOB terms turn on whether the place named is shipment or destination.

Quick reference

Criminal Law and Procedure

  • A full arrest requires probable cause; a Terry stop requires reasonable suspicion grounded in specific and articulable facts, and a frisk requires reasonable suspicion that the person is armed and dangerous.

  • Miranda applies to custodial interrogation; invocation of the right to remain silent must be unambiguous, and once counsel is requested no further interrogation may occur unless counsel is present or the suspect initiates (Edwards).

  • The exclusionary rule bars evidence obtained through unconstitutional searches and its fruits, subject to inevitable discovery, independent source, attenuation, and good-faith exceptions.

  • The Sixth Amendment right to counsel attaches after formal charging at all critical stages; Massiah bars deliberate elicitation without counsel and Crawford bars testimonial hearsay absent a prior opportunity to cross-examine.

  • MPC mens rea levels are purpose, knowledge, recklessness, and negligence; when a statute is silent on culpability, recklessness suffices for most offenses.

  • Felony murder requires an inherently dangerous underlying felony and is limited by the merger doctrine, the agency or proximate cause rule, and the res gestae requirement.

  • Murder requires malice, shown by intent to kill, intent to inflict serious bodily harm, depraved-heart recklessness, or felony murder; adequate provocation negates malice and reduces the killing to voluntary manslaughter.

  • Attempt requires specific intent to commit the crime plus a substantial step beyond mere preparation; factual impossibility is not a defense, while pure legal impossibility is.

  • Self-defense requires a reasonable belief in imminent unlawful force; deadly force requires a reasonable belief in imminent death or serious harm, and the majority rule imposes no duty to retreat outside the home.

Quick reference

Evidence

  • Relevant evidence has any tendency to make a fact of consequence more or less probable; Rule 403 permits exclusion where unfair prejudice, confusion, or waste substantially outweighs probative value.

  • Propensity character evidence is inadmissible in civil and criminal cases, but a criminal defendant may open the door to reputation or opinion character evidence and to specific acts on cross-examination.

  • MIMIC: prior bad acts are admissible to show motive, intent, absence of mistake, identity, or common plan, but never to show conduct in conformity.

  • Hearsay is an out-of-court statement offered for its truth; party-opponent statements, prior consistent statements, and prior inconsistent statements under oath are defined as non-hearsay.

  • Availability-immaterial exceptions include present sense impression, excited utterance, then-existing state of mind, medical diagnosis or treatment, recorded recollection, business records, public records, and learned treatises.

  • Crawford requires that testimonial statements be met with the declarant's unavailability and a prior opportunity to cross-examine; nontestimonial statements are governed by ordinary hearsay rules.

  • Impeachment by conviction requires a felony (subject to Rule 403) or any crime involving dishonesty; convictions more than ten years old require special findings of probative value.

  • The best evidence rule requires the original writing, recording, or photograph to prove its contents, unless an exception such as loss, collateral matter, or public record applies.

  • Rule 702 and Daubert require expert testimony to rest on reliable methodology and helpful specialized knowledge; Rule 701 limits lay opinion to opinions rationally based on the witness's perception.

Quick reference

Real Property

  • A fee simple determinable ends automatically on a stated event and leaves the grantor a possibility of reverter; a fee simple subject to a condition subsequent requires the grantor to exercise a right of entry.

  • Joint tenancy requires the four unities of time, title, interest, and possession and carries a right of survivorship; conveyance by one joint tenant severs survivorship as to that share.

  • Real covenants require writing, intent, touch and concern, horizontal and vertical privity, and notice, and are enforced by damages; equitable servitudes need no privity and are enforced by injunction.

  • Easements may be express, implied (necessity or prior use), or prescriptive through adverse use for the statutory period; they terminate by merger, release, abandonment, estoppel, or prescription.

  • Adverse possession requires actual, exclusive, open and notorious, continuous, and hostile possession for the statutory period; the majority uses the objective standard, and color of title extends constructive possession.

  • Recording statutes are race (first to record), notice (first without notice), and race-notice (first to record without notice); notice includes actual, inquiry, and record notice, and the shelter rule protects grantees of a protected purchaser.

  • Residential leases carry an implied warranty of habitability and covenant of quiet enjoyment that generally cannot be waived; constructive eviction arises when conditions are uninhabitable and the tenant vacates within a reasonable time.

  • Fixtures are determined by annexation, adaptation, and intent; a mortgage or lien on real property attaches to fixtures as of the date of recording.

  • Regulatory takings: a permanent physical occupation or a denial of all economically viable use (Lucas) requires compensation, while Penn Central balances economic impact, investment-backed expectations, and the character of the government action.

Quick reference

Torts

  • Negligence requires duty, breach, actual cause (but-for), proximate cause measured by foreseeability, and damages.

  • Duty runs to foreseeable plaintiffs within the zone of danger under Cardozo/Palsgraf; there is no general duty to rescue absent a special relationship or creation of the risk.

  • Professionals are held to the standard of ordinary skill in their field, and children to a reasonable child of like age, intelligence, and experience except when engaged in adult activities.

  • Negligence per se requires that the plaintiff be within the class the statute protects and that the harm be the type the statute was designed to prevent.

  • Res ipsa loquitur permits an inference of negligence where the instrumentality was in the defendant's exclusive control and the accident would not ordinarily occur absent negligence.

  • Strict liability applies to abnormally dangerous activities, wild animals, and defective products sold by a commercial seller under 402A, covering manufacturing, design, and warning defects.

  • Defamation requires a defamatory statement of and concerning the plaintiff, publication, fault, and damages; public officials and figures must prove actual malice by clear and convincing evidence.

  • Affirmative defenses include comparative negligence (majority rule), contributory negligence (complete bar in a few jurisdictions), assumption of risk, and immunity.

  • Intentional torts require intent in the form of purpose or substantial certainty; consent, self-defense, defense of others, and necessity operate as privileges.

CA Bar key terms

Subject-matter jurisdiction

A court's authority to hear a particular category of case, such as federal-question or diversity cases. Without it, the court must dismiss, regardless of what the parties want.

Related: Diversity jurisdiction, Removal
Personal jurisdiction

A court's power over a particular defendant. It generally requires minimum contacts with the forum state such that suit there does not offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.

Related: Subject-matter jurisdiction
Diversity jurisdiction

Federal court power over suits between citizens of different states, or between a citizen and an alien, when the amount in controversy exceeds $75,000 and complete diversity exists when the case is filed.

Related: Subject-matter jurisdiction, Removal
Removal

The procedure by which a defendant moves a case from state court to federal court, available only when the federal court would have had original jurisdiction over the plaintiff's claim.

Related: Diversity jurisdiction, Subject-matter jurisdiction
Claim preclusion

Rule barring a party from suing again on a claim that was, or could have been, raised in an earlier action resolved by a final judgment on the merits.

Related: Summary judgment
Summary judgment

A pretrial motion granted when the pleadings, discovery materials, and affidavits show no genuine dispute of any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law.

Related: Claim preclusion
State action

The constitutional requirement that most individual rights protect against conduct by government officials rather than private parties, although some private conduct is treated as governmental in function or entangled with the state.

Strict scrutiny

The toughest standard of judicial review. A law must serve a compelling governmental interest and be narrowly tailored to achieve that interest, and it applies to suspect classifications and fundamental rights.

Related: Rational basis review
Rational basis review

The most deferential standard of review. A law survives if it is rationally related to a legitimate government purpose, and the challenger must show that no conceivable justification supports it.

Related: Strict scrutiny
Dormant Commerce Clause

The principle that states may not discriminate against, or unduly burden, interstate commerce even when Congress has not acted, subject to exceptions such as the market participant doctrine.

Standing

The requirement that a plaintiff have a concrete personal stake in the dispute, shown by an actual or imminent injury, fairly traceable to the defendant, and likely to be redressed by a favorable ruling.

Consideration

Something of value, such as a promise or a performance, bargained for and given in exchange for another party's promise, which makes the agreement legally enforceable.

Related: Promissory estoppel
Promissory estoppel

Doctrine that enforces a promise made without consideration when the promisor reasonably expected the promisee to rely, the promisee did rely, and injustice can be avoided only by enforcement.

Related: Consideration
Statute of Frauds

A rule requiring certain agreements, including those involving land or that cannot be performed within one year, to be evidenced by a writing signed by the party being sued.

Related: Parol evidence rule
Anticipatory repudiation

An unequivocal statement or act by a party, before performance is due, indicating it will not perform, which lets the other party sue immediately or wait for performance.

Parol evidence rule

Rule that a fully integrated written agreement cannot be contradicted or varied by earlier or contemporaneous oral or written statements, though such evidence may be admitted to explain an ambiguity.

Related: Statute of Frauds
Mens rea

The mental state required for a crime, such as purpose, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence. The prosecution must prove it along with the prohibited act for most offenses.

Related: Actus reus
Actus reus

The voluntary physical act, or a failure to act where a legal duty exists, that makes up the prohibited conduct of a crime. Thoughts and status alone cannot be punished.

Related: Mens rea
Felony murder

A rule making a defendant liable for murder when a death occurs during the commission of an inherently dangerous felony, even without intent to kill, though many jurisdictions limit its reach.

Exclusionary rule

The remedy that suppresses evidence obtained through an unconstitutional search or seizure, subject to exceptions such as good faith reliance on a warrant and inevitable discovery.

Related: Miranda warnings
Miranda warnings

Advice police must give a suspect in custody before interrogation, warning of the rights to remain silent and to counsel, whose waiver must be voluntary, knowing, and intelligent.

Related: Exclusionary rule
Relevance

The tendency of evidence to make a fact of consequence more or less probable. Irrelevant evidence is inadmissible, and relevant evidence may still be excluded if its probative value is outweighed by unfair prejudice.

Related: Hearsay
Hearsay

An out-of-court statement offered to prove the truth of the matter it asserts. It is generally inadmissible unless a hearsay exception applies or the statement is offered for another purpose.

Related: Excited utterance
Excited utterance

A hearsay exception for a statement about a startling event or condition made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement that the event caused.

Related: Hearsay
Impeachment

The process of attacking a witness's credibility, for example with prior inconsistent statements, evidence of bias, a criminal conviction, or contradictory evidence.

Related: Character evidence
Character evidence

Evidence of a person's traits offered to show that the person acted in conformity with them, generally barred in civil cases and in the prosecution's case-in-chief, subject to exceptions.

Related: Impeachment
Fee simple absolute

The most complete estate in land. It lasts indefinitely, is freely inheritable, and carries no limits on transfer unless the owner separately creates a restriction.

Related: Joint tenancy
Adverse possession

A way to gain title to another person's land by possessing it openly, notoriously, exclusively, continuously, and hostilely for the period the statute requires.

Related: Easement appurtenant
Easement appurtenant

A nonpossessory right to use another's land that benefits a neighboring parcel and passes automatically when that benefited parcel is transferred.

Related: Fee simple absolute
Joint tenancy

Co-ownership with a right of survivorship that requires the four unities of time, title, interest, and possession; ending any one unity turns the arrangement into a tenancy in common.

Related: Fee simple absolute
Recording statute

A state law governing priority among competing interests in land. Under a notice or race-notice statute, a later buyer who pays value without notice and records first prevails.

Related: Adverse possession
Negligence

Conduct that falls below the standard of a reasonable person and causes harm. Proving it requires duty, breach, causation, and damages.

Related: Proximate cause, Res ipsa loquitur
Res ipsa loquitur

A doctrine allowing an inference of negligence when the accident is one that normally does not happen without negligence and was caused by something under the defendant's exclusive control.

Related: Negligence
Proximate cause

The requirement that the defendant's conduct be a substantial factor in causing the harm and that the injury be a foreseeable result rather than an extraordinary, unforeseeable consequence.

Related: Negligence
Comparative negligence

A system that reduces a plaintiff's damages in proportion to the plaintiff's own fault, sometimes barring recovery entirely when that fault exceeds a set percentage.

Related: Negligence
Defamation

A false statement of fact, published to a third party, that harms another's reputation. Public figures and public matters require proof of actual malice.

CA Bar study plan

8 weeks · About 7 hours per week

Week 1

Civil Procedure

  • Map the four personal-jurisdiction bases and the purposeful-availment test into a one-page decision tree

  • Draft the Rule 8 claim/defense taxonomy and Rule 12(b) waiver rules from memory

  • Work 40 MBE-style Civil Procedure questions on jurisdiction and pleadings, logging every miss by error type

  • Distinguish subject-matter jurisdiction, supplemental jurisdiction under 1367, and removal timing in writing

Your checkpoint

A one-page Civil Procedure jurisdiction flowchart plus a scored 40-question log showing at least 70% accuracy

Week 2

Civil Procedure & Constitutional Law

  • Sequence the Erie analysis and state the outcome-determinative test without notes

  • Apply claim and issue preclusion to three novel fact patterns and state which elements fail

  • Explain the incorporation doctrine and the levels of scrutiny with one anchor case per tier

  • Complete 30 mixed Civil Procedure questions and 20 Con Law questions under timed conditions

Your checkpoint

Two IRAC-style essays (one Erie/preclusion, one scrutiny analysis) graded against a self-made rubric, plus a timed 50-question score sheet

Week 3

Constitutional Law

  • Classify state action, due process, and equal protection triggers on sight

  • Reconstruct the First Amendment framework for speech, expressive conduct, and prior restraint

  • Write out the dormant Commerce Clause and privileges-or-immunities tests from memory

  • Drill 45 MBE-style Con Law questions and re-teach the five most-missed rules aloud

Your checkpoint

A 15-rule Con Law flashcard deck covering only rules missed on the drills, plus a 45-question log with written corrections

Week 4

Constitutional Law & Contracts

  • Close out Con Law by briefing two full essay answers under 30-minute time limits

  • State the formation, acceptance, and consideration rules including UCC 2-207 variations

  • Identify the Statute of Frauds categories and the exceptions without reference

  • Take a 60-question mixed set spanning Civil Procedure, Con Law, and Contracts

Your checkpoint

A timed half-length simulated exam (100 questions plus one essay) scored and reviewed, with a written list of the five weakest rules to revisit

Week 5

Contracts & Criminal Law and Procedure

  • Trace contract defenses, third-party rights, and remedies through a full fact pattern

  • Differentiate material breach from minor breach and compute expectation, reliance, and restitution damages

  • Map the mental states for homicide, battery, assault, and theft crimes

  • Apply accomplice liability and inchoate offense rules to two hypotheticals

Your checkpoint

A one-page Contracts remedies damages worksheet and a scored 50-question set split evenly between Contracts and Criminal Law

Week 6

Criminal Law and Procedure & Evidence

  • Sequence the Fourth Amendment analysis from seizure through warrant exceptions to exclusion

  • Outline Fifth and Sixth Amendment protections, including custody, interrogation, and right to counsel attachment

  • State the relevance, character evidence, and impeachment rules with their exceptions

  • Apply hearsay definitions and the main exemptions and exceptions to six short statements

Your checkpoint

A hearsay decision tree and a 55-question timed set (30 Evidence, 25 Criminal Law and Procedure) with a written error analysis

Week 7

Evidence & Real Property

  • Apply the confrontation right and the best evidence rule to written scenarios

  • Distinguish present estates and future interests and identify the type of concurrent estate created

  • Analyze recording acts, bona fide purchaser status, and priority among competing interests

  • Explain landlord-tenant obligations, easements, and covenants running with land

Your checkpoint

A future-interests chart plus a timed 30-question Evidence and 30-question Real Property set scored at 70% or better

Week 8

Real Property & Torts

  • Complete Real Property by working mortgage priority and adverse possession problems

  • State the elements of negligence, strict liability, and the intentional torts from memory

  • Apply comparative fault, joint and several liability, and the collateral source rule to damage questions

  • Sit a full-length mixed simulated exam and review every missed item by domain

Your checkpoint

A full-length simulated exam score report by domain plus a one-page personal rule sheet of the ten most-missed rules across all seven domains

Milestones

Week 2: Score 70% or higher on a timed 50-question Civil Procedure set and produce the jurisdiction flowchart from memory in under 10 minutes

Week 4: Finish the half-length simulation at or above 65% overall, with Civil Procedure and Con Law both above 60% and every missed rule written out in your own words

Week 6: Complete all seven domains' first-pass outlines and hit 70% on the combined Criminal Law/Evidence timed set

Week 8: Score 70% or higher on the full-length simulation and be able to recite the ten most-missed rules without notes

CA Bar exam day

Your checklist

Government-issued photo ID

Bring the original ID whose name matches your application exactly. Confirm with the provider which forms of ID are accepted and whether an expired ID is refused.

Admission/eligibility confirmation from the State Bar

Confirm with the provider whether you need a printed confirmation, a digital permit, or nothing at all beyond your ID, and whether your testing location and session have been finalized.

Laptop with the required exam software installed and a completed practice/mock exam

If you are typing, install the current version of the approved software well before the deadline, run the required mock exam, and confirm your registration/license is active. Confirm deadlines and technical requirements with the provider.

Laptop charger and power cord

Pack the original charger. Do not assume outlets are available at every seat; confirm power availability with the provider.

Handwriting supplies, if you registered to handwrite

Bring the number and type of pens/pencils the provider specifies in its instructions; confirm permitted items in advance.

Approved clear bag with snacks and water

Bring a quiet snack and water in the container type the provider allows. Food and drink rules vary by site, so confirm with the provider.

Non-electronic earplugs or permitted noise protection

Confirm with the provider whether earplugs are allowed, whether they must be foam/non-corded, and whether the site supplies them.

Simple analog watch (no smart features)

Many sites have wall clocks but not all. Confirm whether wristwatches are permitted and whether they must be analog only.

Travel, parking, and lodging plan

Know the exact address, security screening process, and how long entry takes. Plan to arrive well before the reporting time the provider gives you.

A written one-page logistics card

Note reporting time, seat/registration info, site address, parking, and a contact number for the provider, so you are not relying on your phone on exam morning.

Clothing in layers

Room temperature varies and you cannot leave to adjust; dress comfortably and in layers.

Nothing else in the testing room

Leave notes, outlines, phones, smart watches, and study materials behind or stored per site instructions. Confirm the provider's prohibited-items list before you pack.

Plan the day

Final 72 hours

Stop learning new material. Re-read your own condensed outlines, frequency lists, and rule statements for high-yield topics, and do at most light timed practice to keep pacing sharp. Re-confirm your testing location, reporting time, software requirements, and any accommodation approvals with the provider. Run or re-run the laptop mock exam if you have not already.

Final 72 hours

Shift your sleep schedule so you are waking at the time you will need to wake on exam day, and do a dry run of the commute or at least map it precisely, including parking and security lines.

Final 72 hours

Pack your bag once, early: ID, charger, permitted supplies, snacks, layers, and confirmation documents. Set out clothing the night before each day so mornings are decision-free.

Final 24 hours

Charge every device fully and pack chargers. Re-check the reporting time and any site-specific instructions one last time. Do a short review of formats and timing only, not substantive cramming, then stop studying by early evening.

Final 24 hours

Eat a normal dinner, avoid alcohol and heavy caffeine late in the day, set two alarms plus a backup wake-up call, and aim for a full night's sleep. If you cannot sleep, rest quietly; do not get up to study.

Exam morning

Eat a real breakfast with protein, hydrate moderately, and leave earlier than you think necessary to absorb screening and check-in delays. Bring only what is permitted.

Exam morning

At the site, follow staff instructions for ID check and seating, set up your laptop and power, run any required login or exam-file download before time is called, and use the restroom before the session begins.

During each session

Read the timing instructions first and budget minutes per question or task. Write to the clock: if a question or essay is running long, finish it in outline-quality form and move on rather than leaving anything blank.

During each session

If equipment fails, stop and raise your hand for a proctor immediately and follow the provider's documented technical-failure procedure. Do not attempt to troubleshoot alone or continue on an unapproved device.

Between sessions and at breaks

Eat, hydrate, and reset. Avoid comparing answers with other examinees, avoid post-mortems on completed sessions, and avoid last-minute cramming that spikes anxiety; do a two-minute reset of your pacing plan instead.

Rules to check

  • Bring the government-issued photo ID the provider requires, with a name matching your application. Confirm accepted ID forms and any name-discrepancy procedure with the State Bar before exam day; a mismatch can bar entry.

  • No electronic devices other than your approved testing laptop may be in the testing room. Phones, smart watches, and wearables must be off and stored exactly as instructed; unauthorized devices can result in disqualification.

  • All exam content is confidential. Do not discuss, photograph, record, or reproduce questions or task materials at any time, including at breaks and after the exam.

  • Breaks are only at scheduled times. Leaving the room outside a scheduled break may be treated as the end of your session; confirm the site's policy on restroom and emergency exits with the provider.

  • If you are typing, use only the approved exam software and follow the provider's instructions for file download, submission, and technical failure. Confirm those procedures and deadlines in advance.

  • Testing accommodations must be requested and approved before the exam. Confirm your approval in writing with the provider and bring whatever documentation the provider instructs.

  • Scoring and the passing standard are set by the State Bar and may change between administrations. Confirm the current passing score and scoring methodology with the State Bar rather than relying on older figures.

  • Prohibited items, food and drink rules, and allowed noise protection vary by testing site. Confirm the current list of permitted and prohibited items with the provider before you pack.

CA Bar FAQ

How many CA Bar practice questions are available?

The practice set has 200 CA Bar questions. Each one includes the choices, the correct answer, and an explanation, and the set is free to read with no signup.

How many CA Bar flashcards are available?

The flashcard set has 32 CA Bar cards. Each card shows the term and its definition.

Which topics does the CA Bar study material cover?

The CA Bar study material has 7 sections, including Civil Procedure, Constitutional Law, and Contracts.

What format facts does the catalog list for the CA Bar exam?

The catalog lists these item types: multiple choice (Multistate Bar Examination, 200 questions, answered on a Scantron sheet with a No. 2 pencil), written sessions (constructed responses typed on applicant laptops via the ExamSoft delivery vendor), and in person at designated test sites for the CA Bar exam.